A recap of the news text, highlighting the resignation of senior officials and the Cabinet shakeup under President Trump. The article also provides historical context on Cabinet rebellions and the role of Kitchen Cabinets and advice groups in presidential administrations. Additionally, it mentioNs the factors contributing to President Ford's staff shakeup in 1975 and the impact of Carters Cabinet changes on his presidency in 1979
, we’ve now reached what can be called an actual Cabinet shakeup. Over the past six weeks, we’ve seen the resignation offrom the Department of Labor.
When we include the departure of Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Martin Makary and Secretary of the Navy John Phelan, it is clear theCabinet shakeups don’t come around often. They are risky because they are often interpreted as a sign of political desperation, but that is not always the case.
Inside Scoop: Trump and Mamdani, Restoring America, why women are moving leftIn the 1829-31 Petticoat Affair during President Andrew Jackson’s administration, Vice President John Calhoun inspired a Cabinet rebellion against Jackson over disapproval of Secretary of War John Eaton’s wife, Peggy. It was a protracted affair, but eventually, in 1831, Old Hickory demanded that Cabinet members not on his side resign. They did, save for one person: Postmaster William T. Barry.
In the wake of this realignment, Jackson relied instead on a Kitchen Cabinet of advisers. In addition, Secretary of State Martin Van Buren — who had supported Jackson during the controversy — joined Jackson’s ticket as vice president for Jackson’s 1832 reelection. Van Buren became the last vice president elected to succeed the presidents under whom he served until George H. W. Bush succeeded Ronald Reagan. When it comes to Cabinet shakeups, it’s hard to beat the 1970s.
This is perhaps unsurprising given that it was a decade of war, stagflation, malaise, and scandal. Things started with an unforced error. In 1972, President Richard Nixon followed up on a historic landslide victory by asking for the resignations of all of the members of his Cabinet. He was inspired to do this after reading a book given to him by White House adviser Daniel Patrick Moynihan.
The, Robert Blake’s biography of British politician Benjamin Disraeli, included a description of William Gladstone’s Cabinet as “exhausted volcanoes. ” Nixon ended up accepting the resignation of eight of his 11 Cabinet members, but he later reported regretting it. Having a less experienced Cabinet may have addressed the “exhausted volcano” problem, but it also may not have served him well as he tried and failed to deal with the political fallout from the burgeoning Watergate scandal.
James Schlesinger, left, figured in Cabinet shake-ups in both the Nixon and Carter administrations, while Donald Rumsfeld, center, had roles in shuffles by Presidents Richard Nixon and George W. Bush; Tulsi Gabbard, right, left the administration of President Donald Trump after being thought widely to be out of sympathy with the administration’s foreign policy. After Nixon resigned, he was replaced by President Gerald Ford.
Ford had a tough time dealing with a bad economy, his unpopular pardon of Nixon, and seemingly endless White House staff strife. In addition, former California Gov. Ronald Reagan was a threat to defeat Ford in the upcoming 1976 Republican presidential nomination contest. On Nov. 3, 1975, Ford initiated a staff shakeup to address his internal problems to better face the outward ones.
Ford’s purge included the announcement that the liberal Republican Vice President Nelson Rockefeller would not remain on the ticket in 1976; that chief of staff Donald Rumsfeld would replace James Schlesinger as secretary of defense; that Henry Kissinger would lose his national security adviser role, even as he remained secretary of state; and that CIA chief William Colby would be out as well. A young Dick Cheney succeeded Rumsfeld as White House chief of staff.that “The feeling in Washington, so far as anybody can judge it, is that he has misjudged his problem, overestimated Mr. Reagan’s power, underestimated his early popularity, and misread the mood of the nation.
” Ford was not happy with the results, either, later claiming that the massacre was “the biggest political mistake of my life. ” While he managed to defeat Reagan and win the GOP nomination, the apparent desperation of the maneuver also contributed to Ford’s close election defeat to President Jimmy Carter in 1976. Carter did not have things much easier, as he also faced a bad economy and an energy crisis.
He tried to address his problems by bringing experts to a series of conversations at Camp David to discuss the nation’s challenges. After the meetings, he gave a July 15, 1979, speech called “Energy and the Crisis of Confidence.
” The speech initially got positive reviews, but Carter unwisely followed up with a Cabinet shakeup, firing: Joseph A. Califano Jr., secretary of health, education and welfare; Michael Blumenthal, secretary of the treasury; Brock Adams, the stubborn secretary of transportation; Attorney General Griffin Bell; and Secretary of Energy James Schlesinger, who had also fallen victim to Ford’s Halloween massacre. In the wake of the shake-up, the speech has become infamous as the “malaise address,” even though Carter never used that word in it.
Carter lost his 1980 reelection effort to Reagan and was forever colored by the incident. When a statue of Carter was unveiled on an episode ofIn 2004, after President George W. Bush defeated John Kerry for reelection, 12 Cabinet members left, mostly voluntarily. It’s not unusual for presidents to bring in new Cabinet members after a reelection, but in this case, what was unusual to some was a Cabinet member who did not leave.
One of the departures was Secretary of State Colin Powell, whothat he should shake up his warring national security team. As Powell told the president, “You really need to change this all, after the election. ”Powell expected that both he and his rival, Defense Secretary Don Rumsfeld, would resign, but was upset to learn that Rumsfeld was staying in place. As Powell later recalled, “I thought that when he began with me, it was not going to end with me.
” During the first two years of Bush’s second term, with the Iraq War going badly, multiple advisers, including Rumsfeld, suggested that Bush ask for Rumsfeld’s resignation. These calls intensified as the 2006 midterm elections neared. It was only after Bush experienced a self-described “thumping” in the 2006 midterm elections that he accepted Rumsfeld’s resignation. , his second term has generally been smoother in terms of personnel shake-ups than his first.
In fact, the entire first term itself could be seen almost as a continuing Cabinet shakeup, with multiple secretaries of state, attorneys general, HHS secretaries, and secretaries of defense, not to mention four chiefs of staff and national security advisers. But this recent flurry of activity is indicative that Trump sees the need for some changes, which is not necessarily a bad thing.
His predecessor,Some of the officials Trump has let go were not performing well, including Bondi and Noem, while Chavez-DeRemer was embroiled in a scandal. Gabbard long seemed out of step with the administration’sYet while there may be good reasons for the shakeups, any president who shuffles his staff has to deal with the perception problem.
A shakeup implicitly demonstrates a need to address serious problems, but they are also opportunities for a reset, and Trump seems to be in need of one now. For a shakeup to be successful, the president needs to pick well-qualified replacements who not toady but are generally aligned with his policies; get them confirmed and in place before potentially losing thethis November; and, perhaps most importantly, explain to the American people why the reshuffling took place and how things will be better going forward.
These may sound like obvious steps, yet the history of shakeups shows that presidents do not always do the obvious thing in their wake. Tevi Troy is a senior fellow at the Ronald Reagan Institute and a senior scholar at Yeshiva University’s Straus Center. He is the author of five books on the presidency, including, most recently,
Cabinet Shakeup Political Crisis Kitchen Cabinet Advice Group Watergate Scandal Nixon Administration Ford Administration Carter Administration Andrew Jackson Petticoat Affair Cabinet Rebellion Conspiracies Political Ambition
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Trump convenes Cabinet while seeking breakthrough in ending Iran warThe meeting was originally supposed to take place at Camp David, but was moved to the White House because of the possibility of bad weather.
Read more »
Trump Uses Cabinet Meeting to Flog Tacky $55 HatsDonald J. Trump
Read more »
President Trump Jokes About President-Elect Al Green's Defeat, Anticipates Peaceful SOTU SpeechIn response to the defeat of Rep. Al Green (D-TX) in a Democrat primary runoff, President Donald Trump ridiculed the congressman while acknowledging he will miss his screaming and violent waving of a cane at him during his State of the Union addresses. Green's defeat was followed by a change in the congressional district boundaries and his conflicts with President Trump and House Republicans. Christian Menefee, his opponent, has been focusing on immigration issues and was decisive in winning the runoff, over 2/3 of the votes. Menefee and Green both opposed Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton's deportation fund lawsuit and had differing opinions on the terrorist status of Iran. Green also pursued multiple impeachment attempts against Trump over his strikes on Iranian nuclear sites in 2025. Menefee's victory was praised for reflecting 'Texans' voting preferences' and also for challenging the new congressional map that moved Green's base into a new congressional district. President Trump was rumored to have forgotten about Green during his first SOTU address but has later mentionedO him while acknowledging his departing presence, expressing his foresight for a peaceful Son of the Union speech. Although Green's departure, his involvement and Senate approval of the resolution will play a role in the upcoming impeachment showdown as the Democrat-controlled House impeachments stand a slim chance against a possible Republican Senate acquittal. However, Newsom's defeat could potentially affect the Hispanic vote, although they made up less than 40% of the votes, which was far less than several previous elections in 2020-present.
Read more »
Exclusive: This African leader has a diamond-rich deal for Trump'President Trump is someone with whom you can do business,' Botswana President Duma Boko told Newsweek.
Read more »