Harvard University has agreed to adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism and strengthen its policies against discrimination and harassment, following a lawsuit alleging the school was not doing enough to protect Jewish students.
A passerby walks through a gate to the Harvard University campus. Harvard University has agreed to strengthen its policies against antisemitism on campus as part of a settlement of two federal lawsuits accusing the school of not doing enough to prevent antisemitic discrimination and harassment. Harvard will adopt the broad International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance ('IHRA') definition of antisemitism, which considers certain cases of anti-Zionist or anti-Israeli criticism as antisemitism.
Critics say the definition is overly strict and wrongly conflates the two, and will stifle free and open academic inquiry. Harvard calls the move one of many 'robust steps' that will ensure that Jewish and Israeli students are treated in the same manner and with the same urgency as all protected groups. As part of the deal, Harvard will post an explainer stating that 'For many Jewish people, Zionism is a part of their Jewish identity' and will also list examples of antisemitism, such as 'excluding Zionists from an open event, calling for the death of Zionists, applying a 'no Zionist' litmus test for participation in any Harvard activity.' Harvard also agreed that for the next five years it will publicly share the outcomes of alleged cases of antisemitism along with complaints of other forms of bias. Students have accused Harvard of being more lax when enforcing harassment and discrimination policies involving Jews, compared with Black or LGBTQ students, for example. Harvard says it will mandate outside training for staff reviewing antisemitism complaints, and will invest additional resources to study antisemitism, including hosting an annual academic symposium on the topic, hosting a variety of events on campus and partnering with an Israeli university. 'When fully implemented, this agreement will help ensure that Jewish students are able to learn and thrive in an environment free from anti-Semitic hate, discrimination, and harassment,' said Kenneth L. Marcus, former U.S. assistant secretary of education and chairman of the Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, which filed one of the lawsuits accusing Harvard of violating Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. That prohibits discrimination based on race, religion and national origin in schools that receive federal funds. Harvard also agreed to an unspecified monetary payment, but the university did not admit to any wrongdoing. 'We are committed to ensuring our Jewish community is embraced, respected, and can thrive at Harvard,' the university said in a statement. 'We are resolute in our efforts to confront antisemitism.' The settlement was welcomed by many on campus, including Harvard Law school professor Noah Feldman. He says the clarification was especially needed in the wake of the congressional hearing where Harvard's then-president, Claudine Gay, said 'The truth is, as a matter of law, it does depend,' so it's important that Harvard has now articulated more clearly the criteria it will use to determine what crosses the line. But, he says, it's not very different from the rules it has applied in the past. 'It's a commonsensical balance,' he says. 'People have to be able to say whatever they believe, and you need a respectful community where all participants can take part in debate without being bullied, harassed or discriminated against. These are both equally important parts of the university's core mission.' Another user, identified as Jayanti Leslie-Iyer, a Harvard student, replied 'it's insane that harvard has exceptionalized israel and zionism to be above criticism.' Violet Baron, a Harvard junior and organizer with the group Harvard out of occupied Palestine as well as Jews for Palestine, calls the settlement 'extremely dangerous.' 'To me that's like saying racists aren't welcome here,' she says. 'Zionism is a political ideology, and for Harvard to protect Zionists, perhaps at the expense of free speech, that is not what combating antisemitism looks like. That's what policing speech looks like.' Marc Kasowitz, the attorney who brought the lawsuit and negotiated the settlement with Harvard, vehemently rejects such arguments. 'There's nothing about our settlement that prohibits or limits political speech in any way, shape or form,' he says. 'However, if anyone expresses the idea that they believe Zionists should not be welcome at Harvard, because of a belief that have in the existence of the state of Israel, that sounds very antisemitic to me.' Several other schools have recently settled similar lawsuits, and suits are pending against others, including the University of Pennsylvania and Columbia University. One student who was part of the lawsuit declined to be part of the deal, and is taking his claim to trial instead
HARVARD UNIVERSITY ANTI-SEMITISM IHRA DEFINITION LAWSUIT CAMPUS DISCRIMINATION FREE SPEECH ZIONISM
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Harvard Agrees to Strengthen Antisemitism Policies in Campus SettlementHarvard University has agreed to adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism and implement various policies to combat antisemitism on campus as part of a settlement in two federal lawsuits.
Read more »
Harvard settles civil rights lawsuits over antisemitism on campus: 'Upholding the rights of Jewish students'Harvard in antisemitism storm over ‘genocide’ talk by professor who appeared with Hamas leader
Read more »
Harvard Settles Antisemitism Lawsuits Amidst Political BacklashHarvard University has resolved two lawsuits alleging antisemitism on campus, a move coinciding with the return of President Donald Trump to office. The lawsuits, filed by Jewish activist groups, claimed the university failed to provide a safe learning environment for Jewish students. As part of the settlement, Harvard agreed to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Association’s definition of antisemitism and commit additional resources to studying it.
Read more »
Harvard Settles Antisemitism Lawsuits, Commits to Combating BiasHarvard University has settled two lawsuits alleging antisemitism on campus, agreeing to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Association's definition of antisemitism and commit additional resources to studying it. The university also pledged to clarify its non-discrimination policies to explicitly protect Jewish and Zionist students.
Read more »
Harvard Settles Antisemitism LawsuitsHarvard University agreed to adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism and invest in antisemitism research and education.
Read more »
Harvard settles two antisemitism lawsuits as President Trump takes officePresident Donald Trump while campaigning vowed to crack down on universities accused of antisemitism.
Read more »