The top-two primary system in California, where the top two vote-getters in the primary, regardless of party affiliation, advance to the general election, is being criticized for potentially leaving candidates from an entire political party shut out from the general election.
In this file photo, voters cast their ballots for the 2024 California primary election at Pasadena Presbyterian Church in Pasadena on Tuesday, March 5, 2024.
system — where the top two vote-getters in the primary, regardless of party affiliation, advance to the November general election — is underway, spurred by concerns that this rare way of doing things can leave candidates from an entire political party shut out from the general election. — is uncommon. Voters that year approved changes, which were pushed by then-Gov.
Arnold Schwarzenegger, in an attempt to give moderate candidates in each party a greater chance at advancing to the general election. But Maviglio, who opposed the jungle primary concept from the start, said the intended effect never panned out — and this year’s gubernatorial race has put a spotlight on its flaws.enough that two Republicans would end up in the top spots and advance to the runoff while Democrats get shut out of the November election.
Given the attention placed on that potential scenario — albeit a slim one — Maviglio said he decided now would be a good time to try and correct what he described as an “unfair” situation.
“I thought: strike when the iron is hot,” he said in an interview about his decision to try to pass a ballot initiative to repeal Proposition 14. “Over the years, I’ve seen the consequences of it , legislative districts with two Democrats running in a district that’s overwhelmingly Republican and vice versa,” he said. “It’s time for it to go.
Every Californian deserves the option of voting for a candidate of any party in the general election,” said the former CAGOP chair.
“There is a good reason why no other state has adopted a top-two primary system since California did,” he added. “No one can look at this crazy system and say it’s producing good results, or working as intended. ” Sarah Hill, an elections administration expert who teaches at Cal State Fullerton, said the intention behind the top-two system — to help more moderate candidates — has not worked as intended.
People who generally turn out in primary elections tend to be party loyalists, she said.
“What it has done, in a few cases — like what folks are concerned about in the governor race — you have two people in the same party in the general election,” she said. Case in point: The Hill expects an effort to change California’s primary system would be successful if it ends up on a ballot. After all, discontentment with the state’s top-two system is a rare case where both parties actually agree.
“Neither one wants to risk their party being shut out of a general election, which has happened on occasion,” said Hill. “It hasn’t really had the hoped-for impact, but it can lead to some strange results. ”“The top-two system effectively shuts out third-party and independent candidates by preventing them from reaching the general election ballot,” former California Libertarian Party Chair Mimi Robson said in a statement.
“A repeal would restore a system where voters can consider a full range of political perspectives, not just those of the two dominant old parties. ”Maviglio, who recently filed paperwork with the state attorney general’s office to start the process of getting an initiative onto a future ballot to repeal Proposition 14, said once state officials give the OK, he’ll start collecting the hundreds of thousands of valid voter signatures required to qualify the proposal for the 2028 ballot.
He summed up, in seven words, his belief that California’s top-two primary system must end: “It’s a matter of democracy and fairness,” he said. Prop. 64 at 10: Why the illicit cannabis market still dominates in CaliforniaLawsuits seek to stop Riverside County sheriff’s probe that seized 656,000 ballotsTelevised mayoral debate canceled after Bass and Raman pulled outRebecca Grossman can’t stop depositions of husband, daughterUCLA study says telemedicine did not increase health care cost — or help more peopleRebecca Grossman’s daughter testifies that Scott Erickson threatened her
California Primary Election Top-Two Primary System Proposition 14 Party Affiliation Run-Off Run-Off Election Trilogy Primary Gubernatorial Race
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
California Governor Race Odds Amid Call for Rule ChangeDemocrat Xavier Becerra leads the race, according to betting markets, amid calls to overhaul the top-two “jungle primary“ system.
Read more »
California's Democratic incumbents face primary challenges from political newcomersThe challenges are part of a national wave reshaping the debate over generational power and the direction of the Democratic Party ahead of the 2026 midterms.
Read more »
California’s Top-Two Primary May Be Headed for ExtinctionAs Democrats face the possibility of a GOP “lockout” in November, there’s a new push to repeal the state’s nonpartisan primary system.
Read more »
Republican votes surge early in California primary electionToday's Video Headlines: 05/12/26
Read more »