Inspectors with the Hawaiʻi Department of Agriculture and Biosecurity have long been charged with inspecting the inward flow of plants and produce that may contain invasive species and restricting those that pose a risk to the islands.
The Afternoon WireJudge nixes latest policy requiring 7 days' notice for Congress members to visit ICE facilitiesFederal judge allows Gabehart continue working at Spire so long as he avoids Gibbs-related dutiesChristina Applegate unleashes a raw, probing memoir: 'You with the Sad Eyes'Federal court rejects Trump administration attempt to slow tariff refund processPhotos of a blood-red moon and total lunar eclipseToucan seen flying around Sin City has been rescuedWhat to know before asking an AI chatbot for health adviceAre expensive shampoos worth it? Here's what the experts have to sayWhat to know before asking an AI chatbot for health adviceExperts talk how to navigate distressing news stories and finding coping mechanismsCallers to Washington state hotline press 2 for Spanish and get accented AI English insteadThis smoky lentil sloppy joes packs in the plant-based protein and demands napkinsPresidente de Cuba insta a hacer cambios al modelo económico y empresarial de la islaThe Afternoon WireJudge nixes latest policy requiring 7 days' notice for Congress members to visit ICE facilitiesFederal judge allows Gabehart continue working at Spire so long as he avoids Gibbs-related dutiesChristina Applegate unleashes a raw, probing memoir: 'You with the Sad Eyes'Federal court rejects Trump administration attempt to slow tariff refund processPhotos of a blood-red moon and total lunar eclipseToucan seen flying around Sin City has been rescuedWhat to know before asking an AI chatbot for health adviceAre expensive shampoos worth it? Here's what the experts have to sayWhat to know before asking an AI chatbot for health adviceExperts talk how to navigate distressing news stories and finding coping mechanismsCallers to Washington state hotline press 2 for Spanish and get accented AI English insteadThis smoky lentil sloppy joes packs in the plant-based protein and demands napkinsPresidente de Cuba insta a hacer cambios al modelo económico y empresarial de la islaInspectors with the Hawaiʻi Department of Agriculture and Biosecurity have long been charged with inspecting the inward flow of plants and produce that may contain invasive species and restricting those that pose a risk to the islands.
But new testimony shows they may not be holding a hard enough line.to tighten the reins on enforcement of current rules, give the agency power to inspect non-agricultural goods and fine those who violate those expanded laws. In doing so, they’ve discovered the agency has been exercising discretion over whether to allow pest-infested goods across the border. The department has pushed back against the bill and, in its resistance, found itself in hot water with lawmakers over concerns that it may have been ignoring its own mandate for more than 50 years. Sen. Jarrett Keohokalole, who introduced the 11-page legislation, says that allowing inspection agents to pick and choose which infested cargo to keep out is a serious problem at a time when Hawaiʻi’s most notorious pests — including little fire ants, coconut rhinoceros beetles and coqui frogs — compromise the state’s ecological balance and its. It’s especially noteworthy given that the agriculture agency has gained over $25 million in funding in the past two years for more staff and stronger invasive species control.A few grubs going to Kona is how we got CRB in Kona; a few grubs going to Kauaʻi is why we’re currently losing all of the coconut trees at that “There’s a reason this statute was written this way 50 years ago. I’d like to know how long the department has been openly ignoring it.”The Department of Agriculture and Biosecurity submitted six pages of testimony on SB 2760. In it, Director Sharon Hurd suggested substantial changes to the lawmakers’ draft, though she did not expressly oppose the bill. The suggested changes raised some eyebrows, especially since the bill aims to fix regulatory shortcomings highlighted by the department in recent years. During the discussion about the agency’s capacity to increase inspections to include non-agricultural goods at a February hearing, Plant Quarantine Branch Manager Jonathan Ho told lawmakers that department staff were trusted to let “lightly infested” goods into the state without treatment.. According to the language, inspectors may only exercise discretion in what to do with infested material — destroy it or send it back. The agency is technically also allowed to treat incoming goods, although it does not have the facilities to do so.“That’s the policy we’ve always used,” Ho responded. Keohokalole sent a letter to the department to get answers on what he called shadow policy. He suspects staff have been trained to violate the agency’s mandate since it was written in 1973. Ho’s admission, Keohokalole said, shows that the agency continues toThe department partially responded to the legislator’s request for relevant documents on Monday, though it did not provide training manuals and documents related to its operational procedures and threat determinations. “The Department respectfully disagrees with the characterization that its practices constitute a violation of statute,” Hurd wrote in a letter. Ho told Civil Beat the department does not contest that the state needs better protections. But, he added, not all pests are equally concerning to Hawaiʻi. If aphids or another low-risk species shows up, inspectors might ignore those shipments, he said. But if cargo contains a brown tree snake or red imported fire ants, “that’s where the discretion comes in.” Such discretion, he added, is informed by the International Plant Protection Convention, along with national standards and laws, including the U.S. Commerce Clause, which says that interstate business should not be “overburdened by state laws.” After the hearing, Ho said he agrees there needs to be a comprehensive review of the department’s authorities and guiding statutes. But without more employees, he said the agency can only do so much. Ho told Civil Beat that the department is only now regaining the staffing levels it had before the recession led to mass layoffs in 2008 and 2009.Currently the department only has the resources to inspect 15% of inbound agricultural goods, Ho said. And only 0.03% of the more than 9 million lots inspected in fiscal year 2024 were rejected or destroyed,Lawmakers have expressed concern about the agency’s treatment of invasive species for more than a decade. However, the recent and rapid spread of coconut rhinoceros beetles and little fire ants has rekindled the Legislature’s interest in the issue and drawn scrutiny of the agriculture agency’s inner workings.“Without a doubt, we need a culture change,” Keohokalole said. “They have two conflicting mandates: to promote the agriculture industry, but also to regulate that same industry. That push and pull sometimesFormer state agriculture director Scott Enright said discretion in the inspection process at the border was a necessity due to limited resources and staff during his tenure, from 2014 until 2019. A 2017 state audit of the department’s pest control efforts said its biosecurity practices were inconsistent and its staff lacked clear guidance. Enright added that the underfunded system and use of discretion seemed to lead staff to “play favorites,” particularly with the nursery industry, which is especially vulnerable to pest infestations.Perhaps the most substantial change in SB 2760 is its expansion of the department’s authority to inspect non-agricultural goods coming into Hawaiʻi, such as building materials and vehicles. The hope is to better protect the state against new species that could be at least as problematic as coconut beetles and fire ants. Such pests could hitchhike in on just about anything, from a car’s tires to the ballast water in a ship. Advocates from environmental and agricultural organizations support broadening the department’s authority to include what the bill calls common sense regulations, even if the department’s staff feel overburdened. Other islands, such as, already take a much stricter approach to infested shipments. Lawmakers have visited the South Pacific nation several times in recent years, in a bid to learn about and emulate its system in Hawaiʻi. The country’s model informed Act 236 last year, which tasked the agency with setting up public-private partnerships to build border inspection facilities. Christy Martin, program coordinator at the Coordinating Group on Alien Pest Species, said that while the agency’s staff levels are not ideal, it’s important to ensure they are legally allowed to inspect a wide variety of goods they believe might harbor new pests. The department, she said, “has very few tools.” After reviewing its policies, Ho suggested the department should bring recommendations back to lawmakers for consideration. “I don’t think we’re in disagreement about protecting the state from the introduction of pests. There’s no question,” Ho said. “Nobody wants another CRB.”Trump says ‘someone from within’ Iranian regime may be best choice to take power
Hawaii General News News Partner HI State Wire U.S. News Climate And Environment Sharon Hurd Politics Scott Enright Industry Regulation Jonathan Ho Biodiversity Fires U.S. News Climate
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Lawmakers stress new urgency around war powers votes after Iran strikesEfforts in Congress to block President Trump from using further military force against Iran without support from lawmakers have intensified after the U.S. and Israel launched a massive military operation.
Read more »
Lawmakers and Critics Rip NY’s Zohran Mamdani for Condemning Operation Epic FurySource of breaking news and analysis, insightful commentary and original reporting, curated and written specifically for the new generation of independent and conservative thinkers.
Read more »
Buzz Kill: Colorado Lawmakers Propose Tax Increases for Alcohol, MarijuanaHouse Bill 26-1301 would refer a ballot measure to raise taxes on alcohol and marijuana, in order to fund a new state mental health hospital.
Read more »
Editorial: Lawmakers take aim at state’s lax DUI rulesThe DMV keeps letting problem drivers on the road
Read more »
State lawmakers introduce bills to fight water pollution from cruise shipsThe bills, from Sen. Jesse Kiehl and Rep. Sara Hannan, would push cruise lines to use cleaner fuel.
Read more »
Utah lawmakers reject 2 new potential state holidaysCaitlin is a trending intern for Deseret News. She covers travel, entertainment and other trending topics.
Read more »