A new property tax in New York City targeting high-value properties is expected to trigger numerous legal battles as wealthy residents challenge the assessment methods. Experts highlight discrepancies between city assessment values and market values, with concerns that using market values will lead to significant tax increases and court challenges. The tax aims to raise $500 million annually but lacks detailed implementation plans.
in New York City could bring a wave of legal battles from wealthy New Yorkers avoid new levies, according to experts. But as experts noted, there is a huge difference between NYC’s property assessment values and market values, and the pols have yet to clarify which figure will be used for the new levies.
If the democratic socialist and his Albany ally choose to factor in market values, which are typically far higher than the assessment values churned out by NYC’s outdated system, wealthy New Yorkers may respond in court, hiring their own appraisers.
“Anyone with a value between $5 million and $6 million is going to be going down to the courthouse to fight this,” Nathan Goldman, a member of the American Accounting Association and a professor at North Carolina State University, told The Post. “There are gonna be a whole lot extra layers of legal battles that ensue as a result of this because this isn’t like the stock market,” he said. “This is a subjective number.
” The new tax will raise $500 million per year for the city’s budget, say Mamdani and Hochul — who initially opposed the mayor’s tax-the-rich platform but pivoted during this year’s state budget fight. But they have released few details on how the fee, which still needs approval from the state legislature, will actually work.
Ex-Goldman banker imprisoned for fraud files for divorce from former reality TV star: report Ken Griffin's Citadel claps back at Mamdani's viral 'penthouse' video — threatens to scrap $6B NYC development “Mamdani was desperate. I think he was very interested in getting a win” by his 100th day in office, Goldman said.
“But this is far away from anything officially being ironed out. ” The pied-à-terre policy is already facing harsh criticism from business leaders concerned it could fuel an exodus of wealth from the city.
Fellow billionaire Bill Ackman also lashed out at the policy, arguing that non-resident owners of Big Apple properties drive economic growth without acting as a drain on local resources – and warning that Mamdani’s tax could pushIn one of the most expensive real estate markets in the world, the new tax policy could have a huge impact. About 70% of properties sold for $5 million or more are second homes, Jonathan Miller, CEO of appraisal company Miller Samuel, Over the past five years, 4,146 Manhattan apartments sold for at least $5 million, he said – and the new tax policy could hit their owners in vastly different ways depending on how the city implements the proposed tax.
Griffin bought his 24,000-square-foot penthouse at 220 Central Park South in 2019, with the nine-figure price tag making it the highest home sale ever in the US. Under the city’s arcane rules, officials currently give it a market value of $15.5 million and an assessment value of just $6.99 million, Robert Pollack, senior partner at Marcus & Pollack LLP, told The Post.
In New York City, co-ops and condos are not valued based on how much they sell for, but on what they would rent for if they were apartments — which is why the assessments in the case of Griffin’s property and many others are so low, Pollack explained. The city estimated Griffin’s condo would rent for $239,255 per month for tax year 2025-26, giving it a market value of $15.5 million, according to a notice of property value.
It uses a complex formula based on a range of variables, including rental buildings with similar characteristics and rental trends in similar neighborhoods – but it’s widely criticized for being outdated and inaccurate. To reach an NYC assessment value, the city ignores the $238 million transaction value altogether, and simply calculates 45% of the market value – which is about $6.99 million.
Another unresolved issue in the pied-à-terre tax proposal is whether it will have a graduated rate — as was the case with a 2019 proposal that suggested a 0.5% tax on properties worth over $5 million, a 1.5% rate on properties over $10 million and 4% for those over $25 million. If that’s the case, New Yorkers could soon notice a swath of apartments valued at $4.98 million to avoid the tax, or at $24.9 million to escape the highest rate, according to experts.
Yet another unclear detail concerns whether the proposed tax will apply to a home’s entire property value or only to its value over $5 million. Rhode Island took the latter approach with its pied-à-terre tax — also known as the “Taylor Swift Tax” since it targeted the singer’s $17 million Rhode Island vacation home.
New York City will also need to clarify who counts as a non-resident owner, since many will likely seek to skirt the tax by making their penthouses their primary residences, Goldman said.
“If Ken Griffin’s only at his condo for three months of the year, is he gonna be subject to this tax? We don’t know,” he told The Post.
“People game these systems all the time. They don’t report certain additions, they do their own appraisals and use beneficial comps that will help them depress their property values,” Goldman added.
“Now their financial advisers are going to be telling them to claim this as their primary residence. ” Wealthy property owners will likely try to argue that their property values are decreasing, not increasing, since the tax will make buyers less likely to scoop up properties worth $5 million or more, Goldman said.
How to check if you’re eligible for Capital One’s $425M settlement payments‘Love on the Spectrum’ couple Madison Marilla, Tyler White share wedding planning updates with ‘VRT’See AllDianna Russini and married Mike Vrabel caught kissing at NYC bar in bombshell new photos -- taken 6 years before scandal Stream It Or Skip It: 'Unchosen' On Netflix, Where A Woman In A Christian Cult Meets An Escaped Convict And Her Views Start To Change
NYC Property Tax Wealth Tax Legal Challenges Real Estate New York City
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
NYC, NY politics live updates: NYC Councilman arrested while intervening in evictionGov. Kathy Hochul gave up on fielding questions from reporters when a handful of lefty activists interrupted her press conference with “Tax the Rich” chants.
Read more »
New York City, New Orleans at greatest risk of extreme damage from floods, new analysis revealsWhile New York leads in terms of the absolute number of people threatened by flood, an incredible 98 percent of New Orleans' population is at risk, according to a new study
Read more »
Party city: NYC's third Real Estate Gala draws property power playersBefore Twitter became X, neighborhood strip center owner Don Tepman thought it would be fun if his social media contacts could get together in real life. A meetup, Tepman thought, might turn his fe…
Read more »
Questions persist after Gov. Hochul proposes tax on second homes in NYC worth more than $5MHigh-rise condos purchased for tens of millions are routinely assessed for a tiny fraction of their market value, which could complicate Gov. Hochul's hopes to tax the homes of non-residents, worth more than $5 million.
Read more »
Pennsylvania Seniors Could See Property Tax Relief Under New BillProposed legislation in Pennsylvania aims to exempt homeowners aged 75 and over with at least 10 years of continuous ownership from school, county, and municipal property taxes. The 'Sam Worley Elderly Tax Relief Act' seeks to provide financial stability and allow seniors to age in place with dignity.
Read more »
Florida Property Tax Push Exposes Rift Between DeSantis and LawmakersProperty tax reform is not on the agenda for the incoming special legislative session in Tallahassee.
Read more »