COMMENT: What was the City of Cape Town thinking when it decided to round up homeless people and put them in a camp?
The City of Cape Town closed the now infamous and much-criticised temporary homeless shelter at Strandfontein last week.involved a large-scale operation, which included the removal and transportation of hundreds of homeless people off the streets of Cape Town, the initial accommodation in three large marquee tents, the use of shared ablution and sanitation facilities and congregations of large numbers of people in queues at meal times.
, “many officials and white citizens considered the move a major success, pointing the way to future policy and practice”. Did the city perhaps think that the local Strandfontein residents would not object or object less than residents in the white suburbs? Or worse, were the decision-makers ignorant of the deep psychosocial trauma inflicted by past forced removals? The city adopted a large-scale police operation to actively search for and remove homeless people from around the city.
Another serious concern that warrants reflection is allegations of mistreatment at the Strandfontein shelter. For instance, why were homeless people from Somerset West informed that they were only going to the shelter for an hour to get tested, only to learn that this was more permanent? It implies that those involved knew that taking homeless people off the streets was fundamentally misconceived and could never be achieved without manipulation.
Perhaps most concerning is the manner in which the city has responded to issues publicly. The city reacted defensively when the conditions at the shelter became public through the media, civil society organisations, human rights monitors appointed by theThe mayor derrided comments by politicians as “shameful”. In statements, he alleged that criticism of the shelter was politically motivated, referring to “political organisations and politically-aligned NGOs” or to “political and related groups”.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Inside Facebook’s big bet on Africa - The Mail & GuardianAfrica’s internet speeds are about to reach levels the continent has never experienced, mattduplessis reports.
Read more »
The inevitable rise in Covid-19 cases and deaths: What the numbers mean - The Mail & GuardianAbout 20 people in South Africa die each day from the coronavirus, and this number may peak at 300, while positive cases may reach 8 000 a day, according to some projections
Read more »
Coronavirus and the virtual sports revolution - The Mail & GuardianThe suspension of live sport has thrust the virtual sports industry into the limelight. E-sport is the only area where athletes, and amateurs, can compete while practising social distancing.
Read more »
Cryptic Crossword 233 - 22 May - The Mail & GuardianCryptic Crossword 233 – May 22.
Read more »
“I was just running along with police as they dragged her” - The Mail & GuardianSumy Sadurni describes the photo she captured of Stella Nyanzi being arrested by police in Kampala
Read more »
Two dead in new ANC KwaZulu-Natal killings - The Mail & GuardianA Mtubatuba councillor and a Hammarsdale ANC Youth League leader were shot yesterday near their homes
Read more »