The Texas Education Agency is taking over several school districts due to low academic performance, impacting Black, Hispanic, and low-income students. Critics say state intervention penalizes districts without addressing root causes.
The Texas Education Agency is currently overseeing plans to take over four school districts due to consistently low academic performance . This action, triggered by state-issued failing grades on specific campuses, effectively removes decision-making power from locally elected officials. The students affected by these takeovers are predominantly Black, Hispanic, and from low-income households.
Data reveals that between 80% and 97% of the students in these districts live in low-income homes, surpassing the state average of 60%. Furthermore, the student populations at these schools are largely composed of Black and Hispanic children, with significant percentages of students at risk of dropping out. The consequences of these low test scores are significant, placing a momentous decision in the hands of the state's education commissioner. If a school receives an F grade for five consecutive years, the commissioner is obligated to either shut down the campus or initiate a state takeover of the entire district, replacing the elected school board with officials appointed by the commissioner. Commissioner Mike Morath, during his tenure, has already ordered the closure of two campuses and implemented seven district takeovers. These decisions are rooted in the belief that school leaders have consistently failed to govern effectively and have hindered students' academic progress. The implications extend far beyond the individual schools, impacting entire communities and raising concerns about equity and opportunity.\Critics of the accountability system argue that state takeovers disproportionately penalize districts based on factors beyond their control. They highlight the undeniable link between socioeconomic status, race, and academic outcomes, emphasizing that schools alone cannot solve the complex issues of inequality stemming from poverty and systemic racism. The characteristics shared by many of the schools targeted for takeover reveal this reality. These schools often serve students who lack access to basic necessities and support systems that significantly impact their educational experiences. As Jill Bottelberghe, superintendent of the Connally Independent School District, pointed out, not all students have the same advantages. Morath justified the decision to appoint superintendents and replace school boards in the affected districts citing their failure to implement effective changes aimed at improving student performance. He also pointed to the elevated percentages of students failing to meet grade-level expectations, extending beyond the specific campuses that triggered the takeover. The A-F accountability system, in its attempt to measure student learning and school performance, has faced criticisms for failing to adequately account for these external factors. While the system attempts to compare schools with similar demographics, the impact of poverty and racial disparities remains a significant challenge. Getting an F grade five years in a row is considered a sign of a serious emergency. However, it is important to acknowledge that low-income schools, including those educating mostly Black and Hispanic students, can also thrive within the A-F system. Evidence demonstrates that some high-poverty campuses achieve excellent results. The gap between the high and low poverty schools receiving the highest ratings is significant, and the racial element remains a major factor in these ratings.\Opponents of the current system also contend that the state often punishes schools without providing adequate resources or addressing the underlying causes of educational disparities. They point to the fact that schools in Texas went for six years without receiving an increase in state funding for salaries and operations. This lack of investment in public education, particularly in schools serving vulnerable populations, further exacerbates the challenges faced by students and educators. Additionally, critics argue that the focus on standardized testing outcomes overshadows other crucial factors that impede the academic progress of Black and Hispanic students. Andrew Hairston, a civil rights attorney at Texas Appleseed, stresses the importance of considering the overall environment in which students learn. He emphasizes that improving reading levels alone does not address the systemic issues faced by students who experience racial discrimination and lack a peaceful, supportive learning environment. The state needs to broaden its focus and address the impact of racism, lack of resources, and other forms of systemic disadvantage to help students of color succeed. The focus on test scores has the potential to ignore a wide range of factors, including the need to make students feel safe and included in a welcoming school environment. The issue is about ensuring that schools have the resources they need to provide high-quality education to all students, and also about creating a school climate that is supportive and inclusive of all students, regardless of their background or identity
Texas School Takeover Education Low-Income Students Academic Performance
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Chicago-area school closings: How to check your school's statusWith parts of the Chicago area dealing with heavy snow Sunday and with the prospect of frigid wind chills Monday, some schools are switching to e-learning.
Read more »
Victim killed in 12-car pileup on I-10 identified, crash under investigationJUNCTION, Texas - A tragic multi-vehicle crash on Interstate 10 in Kimble County, Texas, claimed the life of a Florida man on Jan. 24.The Texas Department of P
Read more »
North Texas school closings for Monday and TuesdayMost districts have canceled classes for Monday. Dallas ISD, Fort Worth ISD and many other major school districts are also now announcing that they will remain closed on Tuesday.
Read more »
North Texas school districts cancel Tuesday athletic activitiesSchool across the area will remain closed Tuesday after extreme winter weather hit D-FW.
Read more »
Jacksonville Beach residents push for safer school drop-off, pickup at Discovery SchoolJacksonville Beach resident Donnie Brzuska is raising concerns about traffic safety near Discovery School, a private school next door to his home, saying that the school’s drop-off and pickup traffic has become a serious problem.
Read more »
Low test scores on one campus can trigger a state takeover in Texas, affecting Black, Hispanic and low-income students mostThe demographic makeup of the “trigger” schools raises questions about whether Texas' accountability system fairly considers historic inequities tied to race and poverty.
Read more »