A North Carolina judge has ruled that racial bias tainted the 2009 trial of a Black man, Hasson Bacote, finding 'glaring' disparities in the application of the death penalty against Black defendants compared to white defendants. While this ruling won't directly affect Bacote's sentence, which was commuted to life in prison last year, it could impact other death row inmates facing similar claims of racial bias.
A judge has ruled that racial bias tainted the decision to strike Black people from the jury pool and to impose the death penalty in the 2009 trial of a Black man in North Carolina . Hasson Bacote was among a group of 15 death row inmates whose sentences were commuted to life without parole last year by Gov. Roy Cooper in one of his final acts in office. That means the ruling won't make a legal difference for Bacote.
However, it could help several other death row inmates in similar circumstances, said Gretchen M. Engel, executive director of the Center for Death Penalty Litigation.In addition to the problems that prejudiced Bacote's trial, Superior Court Judge Wayland Sermons Jr. found that racial bias tainted jury selection and sentencing in other Johnston County cases. Sermons found “glaring” bias in the fact that Black defendants in capital cases were sentenced to death 100 percent of the time while similar white defendants received a death sentence only 45 percent of the time. None of those Black inmates in Johnston County have been executed, and North Carolina has not carried out an execution since 2006.The judge said race was a “significant factor” in the decisions to seek the death penalty in the first place and in jury selection, when looking at other cases tried by Assistant District Attorney Gregory Butler as well as other death penalty cases in the same prosecutorial district, which at the time included Harnett and Lee counties. In Bacote’s case, Butler struck 75 percent of prospective Black jurors and only 23 percent of prospective non-Black jurors. In Butler’s other cases, risk of removal from the jury pool by peremptory challenges was more than 10 times higher for Black candidates than for non-Black candidates, Sermons wrote. Butler testified that he never struck a juror for a “racial reason.” Sermons found that unconvincing. In Bacote’s case, for example, Butler explained his removal of five Black jurors by citing their opposition to the death penalty. However, “Butler did not strike white jurors who expressed similar reservations, in some cases with nearly identical language,” Sermons wrote. The US Supreme Court made clear in 1986 eliminating potential jurors merely because of their race violates the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment, which requires that people in similar circumstances be treated the same. However, jury selection bias claims are often difficult to prove. The North Carolina Department of Justice, whose lawyers represented the state in Bacote's case, have already “notified the court that we intend to appeal,” said Nazneen Ahmed, a spokesperson for Attorney General Jeff Jackson, who leads the department. Bacote challenged his death sentence under North Carolina's 2009 Racial Justice Act, which allowed prisoners to receive life without parole if they could show that racial bias was the reason for their death sentence. The law was repealed in 2013, but the state Supreme Court has ruled that it still applies to any prisoner who had a Racial Justice Act case pending at the time of the repeal. During a two-week hearing last fall, Sermons listened to evidence that included statistical studies of how the death penalty is implemented in North Carolina and Johnston County in particular. In his Friday ruling, the judge said the weight of the evidence did not prove that racial disparities prejudiced death penalty cases statewide
Racial Bias Death Penalty Jury Selection North Carolina Hasson Bacote Racial Justice Act
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Po'Boigh King scores 25, North Carolina Central tops South Carolina StatePo'Boigh King had 25 points in North Carolina Central’s 82-77 victory against South Carolina State on Saturday night.
Read more »
Police Impersonator in Georgia and North Carolina Using Black Dodge ChargerAuthorities in Georgia and North Carolina are warning drivers about a police impersonator using a black Dodge Charger with tinted windows and a single emergency light. Drivers are urged to call 911 if they believe they have been pulled over by an impersonator.
Read more »
FEMA Housing Assistance Program Ends for Some in Western North CarolinaAs the FEMA Transitional Sheltering Assistance program nears its end on January 10th, some individuals in Asheville, North Carolina, are facing eviction from their temporary hotel rooms. The program, which provides free hotel accommodations to those affected by disasters, is ending for those who have received habitable housing inspections or have been unable to be contacted by FEMA for updates. Residents expressed concerns about the short notice and the lack of affordable housing options in the area.
Read more »
UConn's Fenway Bowl MVP Pryce Yates Transfers to North CarolinaUConn defensive lineman Pryce Yates, who was named the Fenway Bowl Defensive MVP after a standout performance against North Carolina, has transferred to the Tar Heels. This move marks another significant addition to Bill Belichick's first roster at UNC.
Read more »
North Carolina's Elliot Cadeau to Receive Global Impact Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. AwardNorth Carolina basketball player Elliot Cadeau is being recognized for his community service with the 2025 Global Impact Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Award.
Read more »
Gunman in 'pizzagate' hoax fatally shot by North Carolina police during traffic stopEdgar Welch fired an assault rifle inside a Washington, D.C., restaurant in December 2016 while claiming to investigate the 'pizzagate' hoax.
Read more »