14 Years Ago, Avengers vs X-Men Inspired a Marvel Mistake That Lasted 102 Issues

United States News News

14 Years Ago, Avengers vs X-Men Inspired a Marvel Mistake That Lasted 102 Issues
United States Latest News,United States Headlines
  • 📰 ComicBook
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 227 sec. here
  • 5 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 94%
  • Publisher: 68%

In 2012, Marvel brought the original five X-Men back to the present, and it was one of the biggest mistakes they ever made with the team.

kicked off the beginning of the marginalization of the mutant side of Marvel, moving the team into Decimation and the Utopia Eras. This would end withThis story put the capstone on those eras, and ended with a huge status quo shift.

Cyclops was imprisoned after going Dark Phoenix, Professor X was dead, and the mutant race’s flame had been rekindled by Hope Summers and Scarlet Witch. In the real world, writer Brian Michael Bendis was moved from the Avengers books to the X-Men, writing two flagship titles:was a Cyclops book, following him as he recruited new mutants to fight in his revolution.Videos by ComicBook.com This book saw Beast decide that the only way to bring Cyclops back into the fold was to go back in time and bring the teenage versions of the original five X-Men to the past. On the surface, this seems like a fun idea, one that would be cool for a story arc or two. However, it didn’t last a story arc or two. It lasted for a 102 issues over three ongoing series and one miniseries , six years of stories that stretched credulity far beyond the breaking point. The return of the O5 was meant to bring about a new era of the X-Men, but it did exactly the opposite and showed one of Marvel’s more distressing tendencies.Image Courtesy of Marvel Comicsgets a lot of flack, but it did a good job of ending one of the most depressing eras in X-Men history. The Decimation/Utopia Eras had some great series and stories, but it was remarkably uneven and X-fans wanted something a little less dark and a little more like classic X-Men — character-focused stories with cool fights.left a lot of potential for cool new stories. Fans were cautiously optimistic, especially since Bendis wasThe return of the O5 was actually pretty cool at first. X-fans are used to time travel stories and people from different times joining the group, so bringing back the original X-Men was an idea that had legs. For a time at least. Back then, fans were all afraid of the thing that was going to happen: keeping them there for too long. The idea is really only good in whether it works or not to fix the problems of the X-Men. As far as it goes, seeing a bunch of lesser developed characters in the present had a short shelf life, because fans knew that nothing could be changed all that much. Everyone but Marvel knew that milking the idea would have been a mistake, so obviously, that’s what they did.Sales were good at first, but the whole thing ran out of steam rather early. The problem was simple: the original five X-Men weren’t all that interesting to begin with when they were teens and we knew that none of the changes to the characters would stay in canon. Creators tried to take them in new directions, like the Beast learning magic, Jean Grey learning about her history, and Angel getting fire wings, but none of these were going to matter in the long run. The only change that stayed was Iceman being gay. One of the biggest problems with Marvel in general is the lack of any actual change to characters anymore. Readers nowadays know that most changes are going to go away when the next creators come aboard, and this went doubly for the O5. Marvel wasn’t going to massively change the past versions of the O5 and couldn’t keep them in the present. Everyone knew that for the most part, nothing in this story was going to matter. , and the O5 was basically the Clone Saga for the team: a story that started out well but was stretched out long past when it should have ended.After the dark years of the Decimation/Utopia Eras, fans wanted something new and the O5 felt like a step in the right direction. If it was a two year story arc that ended with the X-Men coming back together, fans would have liked the whole thing more. Instead, the early successes of, and the tendency of Marvel to buy books they hate, meant that we got six years of stories that would never really matter very much. It even kept the overly dark tone of the earlier eras that fans were tired of. The ’10s were the decade that Marvel did their best to push the X-Men below the tide line, as it were, so that characters they owned the film rights to would get more attention. The O5 was yet another problem for fans of the time that never seemed to go away. There are exactly two reasons it matters: Iceman being outed by Jean Grey and Cyclops being friends with Ms. Marvel. None of their stories are very fondly remembered and if you skipped the entire six years they were around, you’re basically missing nothing important to the history of the X-Men. It committed the greatest sin a comic can — it didn’t matter and was never going to. What do you think about the return of the O5? Leave a comment in the comment section below and join the conversation on the

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

ComicBook /  🏆 65. in US

 

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

DC & Marvel’s Superman/Spider-Man Crossover Gets Upstaged By Batman & X-Men CharactersDC & Marvel’s Superman/Spider-Man Crossover Gets Upstaged By Batman & X-Men CharactersSuperman and Spider-Man Crossover Art 2026 Marvel:DC
Read more »

59 Years Later, X-Men’s First Big Costume Change Still Defines Marvel’s Mutant Heroes59 Years Later, X-Men’s First Big Costume Change Still Defines Marvel’s Mutant Heroesx-men's jean grey marvel girl
Read more »

Vince Vaughn Explains Why Wedding Crashers 2 Is Delayed Despite Early Talks 5 Years AgoVince Vaughn Explains Why Wedding Crashers 2 Is Delayed Despite Early Talks 5 Years AgoVince Vaughn looking off to the right
Read more »

University of Denver Pioneers roll to third straight Frozen Four after dispatching Western MichiganUniversity of Denver Pioneers roll to third straight Frozen Four after dispatching Western MichiganTwo years ago, Matt Davis became a legend around here with a magical postseason run.
Read more »

One Spider-Man Villain Peaked 23 Years Ago With the One Design Marvel Will Never TopOne Spider-Man Villain Peaked 23 Years Ago With the One Design Marvel Will Never TopCustom image of Marvel Sandman artwork.
Read more »

The Big Bang Theory’s Retcon 19 Years Ago Saved It From Show-Ending ControversyThe Big Bang Theory’s Retcon 19 Years Ago Saved It From Show-Ending ControversyNearly two decades ago, The Big Bang Theory retconned a major element that saved it from an issue that coule have ended the series.
Read more »



Render Time: 2026-04-01 00:41:02