A U.S. Appellate Court overturned a federal law prohibiting the home production of whiskey, vodka, and other distilled spirits, ending a prohibition that dates back to the Reconstruction era. The court sided with Hobby Distillers, arguing the ban was an improper use of tax power and hindered revenue generation.
A U.S. Appellate Court ended a federal prohibition on distilling hard liquor that stretched all the way back to the Reconstruction era. The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals’ ruling, which was handed down on Friday, overturned a law that barred people from producing whiskey, vodka, and other distilled spirits in their homes.
Hobby Distillers and four of its members had challenged the law, which imposed a fine of up to $10,000 and up to five years in prison for violations.
The plaintiffs argued they should be allowed to make hard liquor at home, either as a hobby or for personal consumption. One plaintiff had claimed he had distilled alcohol for fuel near his garage and wanted to try an apple-pie-vodka recipe he came up with.
The appellate court judges rejected the federal government’s arguments that the ban was allowed under the Constitution’s taxation clause as well as its Necessary and Proper clause, finding, in part, that it does nothing to feed the government’s coffers.'Not only do they prohibit at-home distilleries, but in so doing, they amount to an antirevenue provision that prevents distilled spirits from coming into existence,' Circuit Judge Edith Hollan Jones wrote. 'The provisions operate to reduce revenue instead of raising it.'
Additionally, the court found that banning and criminalizing at-home distilling is an improper use of the tax power.'Under the government’s logic, Congress may criminalize nearly any at-home conduct only because it has the possibility of concealing taxable activity,' Hollan Jones continued. 'Home-based businesses may be forbidden. Remote work may be deemed a crime.'
The appellate court’s finding upheld a previous district court’s finding that the law was unconstitutional. The federal judge in that case had issued an injunction against enforcement of the government’s prohibition, but stayed that part of the decision until a higher court weighed in, Reuters noted. With its decision, the appellate court found the plaintiffs had standing to challenge the law and allowed the injunction to go into effect.
Home Distilling Liquor Ban Appellate Court Taxation Constitutional Law
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Trump administration can’t change President’s House panels for now, federal appeals court affirmsThe Third Circuit Court of Appeals ordered the federal government to maintain the status quo at the President's House following the National Park Service release of new exhibit panels renderings.
Read more »
Colorado Court of Appeals: Boulder can't charge fees for bodycam footage in alleged misconduct casesThe Colorado Court of Appeals this week ruled that the City of Boulder cannot charge fees for body camera footage related to a complaint of officer misconduct, a decision supporters say is a major win for police transparency and accountability across Colorado.
Read more »
Illinois law forcing pregnancy centers to give abortion info faces appeals court scrutinyAn appeals court heard arguments over the legality of an Illinois law mandating pregnancy centers provide patients with abortion information.
Read more »
Appeals court says Trump White House ballroom construction can proceed for nowA federal appeals court said Saturday that President Donald Trump can move ahead for another week with construction of a massive new White House ballroom while judges consider the project.
Read more »
Federal appeals court sends White House ballroom construction lawsuit back to lower courtThe U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit said it did not have enough information to decide how much of the project can be suspended without jeopardizing the safety of the president.
Read more »
Appeals Court Allows Trump's White House Ballroom Construction to Continue TemporarilyA federal appeals court has temporarily permitted the construction of President Trump's White House ballroom to proceed while the administration contests a lower court's ruling. The court cited concerns about the project's impact on national security and safety, allowing construction to continue until April 17 pending further review.
Read more »