At a meeting that lasted more than nine hours, Michigan’s Natural Resources Commission voted Wednesday to limit hunters in the Lower Peninsula to killing one antlered deer starting next year.
CIA Director John Ratcliffe met with Raul Castro's grandson in Havana, US and Cuban officials sayTexas high court rejects removal of Democratic lawmakers who led quorum break over redistrictingThe NFL's 2026 season will kick off with a Patriots-Seahawks Super Bowl rematchAfter the Kendrick Lamar beef, can Drake come back with 'Iceman'?
Powell's tenure as Fed chair marked by fight for independence while trying to tame inflationViral phenomenon in Argentina has young people identifying themselves as animals1 million bees make for bumper-to-buzzer traffic on a Tennessee highway rampHow 2 men claimed an absurd record by driving an old 3-wheel car the length of AfricaIn an era when workers are returning to offices, here’s how Dropbox is making remote jobs workA photo captures black spots on clothespins that reveal the environmental toll of conflict in TehranTrump has hindered offshore wind while China and other countries invest heavilyPCOS is now called PMOS.
What the name change means for careBy changing women's lives, the pill changed the nationSouth Korea's ambitions for AI robots start with workers folding napkinsAdults relive the musical camaraderie of their youth at band camps reprised for grown-upsJourney of a lifetime: A US teen Buddhist lama is now a monk studying in the Himalayan foothillsUn barco cerca de los Emiratos es capturado y llevado a Irán, otro es atacado y se hunde
Powell's tenure as Fed chair marked by fight for independence while trying to tame inflationViral phenomenon in Argentina has young people identifying themselves as animals1 million bees make for bumper-to-buzzer traffic on a Tennessee highway rampHow 2 men claimed an absurd record by driving an old 3-wheel car the length of AfricaIn an era when workers are returning to offices, here’s how Dropbox is making remote jobs workA photo captures black spots on clothespins that reveal the environmental toll of conflict in TehranTrump has hindered offshore wind while China and other countries invest heavilyPCOS is now called PMOS.
What the name change means for careBy changing women's lives, the pill changed the nationSouth Korea's ambitions for AI robots start with workers folding napkinsAdults relive the musical camaraderie of their youth at band camps reprised for grown-upsJourney of a lifetime: A US teen Buddhist lama is now a monk studying in the Himalayan foothillsUn barco cerca de los Emiratos es capturado y llevado a Irán, otro es atacado y se hundeAt a meeting that lasted more than nine hours, Michigan’s Natural Resources Commission voted Wednesday to limit hunters in the Lower Peninsula to killing one antlered deer starting next year. Currently, hunters can kill up to two.
Officials and some vocal hunters favored limiting sportsmen and sportswomen statewide to one antlered deer, a policy commonly known as the “one buck rule. ” Some thought the rule, whichWednesday’s vote “just solidifies this was a waste of time,” said Elliot Hubbard, one of the hunters who had promoted the one buck rule.
“It was a collaboration between hunters and the department to bring a sound biological regulation forward. It fell on deaf ears. ” Prior to the vote, Dan Stewart, a Lower Peninsula resident and hunter, said he was opposed to the one buck rule, sometimes abbreviated as “OBR. ” “While I take a doe when populations allow, that isn’t what drives me into the woods.
If OBR passes, my season could be over by the first week of November with one nice buck. Like many others, I would pack up and head out of the state to hunt somewhere else with my money,” he said. Public commenters spoke collectively for more than four hours at the day-long meeting.
Some said that they wanted to hold onto the opportunity to kill two bucks while hunters like Hubbard lobbied for one buck to help balance the sex ratio of Michigan’s herd. The state’s doe-to-buck ratio is unknown, but DNR data shows hunters in the state prefer killing antlered deer.
Some hunters say that impacts the size of the bucks left to hunt in the state because hunters kill off the bigger bucks.killing does could help reduce the deer population in parts of the state where they are involved in a high number of vehicle collisions, eat farmers’ crops and spread disease. But critics of the one buck policy were quick to point out that only a limited number of deer hunted over the past decade — roughly 4% to 7% — represented a second antlered deer killed by one hunter.
Some opponents also argued the DNR’s recommended policy was crafted to encourage hunters to kill more antlerless deer without guaranteeing that would happen. In the Lower Peninsula, the DNR’s recommended policy would have eliminated a hunter’s ability to take an antlered deer with a single deer license.
If a hunter wanted to kill an antlered deer, they would have needed to buy a combination license with which they would have been able to take an antlered deer or an antlerless deer in combination with a second antlerless deer.
“By coupling some of the licenses in the combo license, we could effectively be doubling the price of a buck license and stepping into the arena that is legislative authority,” NRC Chairperson Becky Humphries explained to the crowd before voting began. Ultimately, she said that was why she could not support the recommended one buck policy, because the Legislature, not the NRC, has the authority to raise license fees.was introduced by Commissioner David Nyberg, who said it was conceived as a compromise with other commissioners, but he wanted to protect the current combination license in the Upper Peninsula, where he lives and hunts.
“The Upper Peninsula, and even portions within the Upper Peninsula, are very different from each other, from the Lower Peninsula, in terms of habitat, food source, deer density, winter severity, predators,” he said. “And so I understand a lot of the concern that I heard from hunters about the proposed statewide one buck rule. ” George Lindquist, the vice chair of the DNR’s West UP Citizens Advisory Council, said he was “pretty darn happy” Nyberg’s proposal passed.
He didn’t like how the DNR’s recommended policy would have swapped out an antlered deer for an antlerless deer in the UP’s combination license.
“The groups and the people I’m involved with are happy that we’re keeping these rules the way they are up in the UP,” said Lindquist. “We just don’t have the numbers to allow for an increased antlerless take. ” One commissioner was concerned the new regulations would entice hunters who normally kill two antlered deer in the Lower Peninsula to head to the UP so they could kill a second antlered deer, potentially adding additional strain onto a fragile herd.
But Lindquist said he wasn’t worried because those hunters would have a hard time finding bucks with big enough antlers to legally shoot. Wording for Nyberg’s amendment, and several other amendments commissioners voted on, were not made public in the days leading up to the meeting. Many pro one buck hunters felt blindsided when Nyberg’s amendment was presented.
One public commenter suggested commissioners were like contestants on the TV show “Survivor,” saying one thing to constituents’ faces while planning to vote a different way. Advocates for one buck seemed particularly surprised when a pilot program to “earn a second buck,” allowing hunters to kill an antlerless deer in the southern Lower Peninsula in order to kill a second antlered deer, was presented.
“I was tempted to make a comment on this during the meeting, but I didn’t, I chose not to, because I didn’t want it to be perceived as argumentative,” Nyberg told Bridge Michigan after the vote. “What we heard from testimony today from a lot of hunters was, I think, a perception that the NRC today planned to implement a second buck in lower Michigan. That was not the case.
” Nyberg’s approved amendment included a request for the DNR to put forth “a framework” for the “earn a second buck” pilot project to be presented at the NRC’s July meeting. Commissioner John Walters expressed concerns that there would be issues with “ghost does,” hunters saying they killed an antlerless deer when they hadn’t, in order to kill a second buck.
DNR officials said they did not yet know how they would police that program and their ability to do so would depend on how much money the department is budgeted by the Legislature. Nyberg told Bridge the public would be able to weigh in on the earn-a-second-buck pilot before the commission voted on it in the coming months.demanding measurable scientific goals for deer policies recommended by the DNR, plus a handful of other regulations, including getting rid of certain firearm restrictions in the southern Lower Peninsula and eliminating the extended late antlerless deer season that had taken place after Jan. 1.
, which included several other regulations recommended by the DNR. The final version of the amended order was not available online as of Wednesday evening.
Michigan Zoology General News MI State Wire George Lindquist U.S. News Crime Becky Humphries Michigan Wolverines Dan Stewart Climate And Environment Elliot Hubbard David Nyberg John Walters Climate U.S. News
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Michigan Lands 2027 4-Star WR Quentin Burrell: What It Means For WR CorpsThe Wolverines picked up their No. 8 commitment in the 2027 class on Wednesday, and Michigan landed Quentin Burrell over rival Notre Dame.
Read more »
Jeep Weekend 2026: What you need to know about the 'Zero Tolerance' plan on Bolivar PeninsulaGalveston County is implementing a 'zero-tolerance' safety plan for Jeep Weekend 2026. Officials say the measures are designed to ensure public safety, citing a previous 80% drop in emergency calls following the introduction of these logistical restrictions.
Read more »
Peninsula sting ends in registered sex offender’s arrestAuthorities say the suspect “engaged in explicit conversations” with an agent posing as a 13-year-old boy.
Read more »
An Alaska Peninsula volcano is showing signs of unrest prompting additional studiesThe Alaska Volcano Observatory raised Kupreanof Volcano's alert level to Advisory and its aviation color code to Yellow. That means the volcano is showing signs of unrest, but it doesn't necessarily mean an eruption will happen.
Read more »