California Democrats are clamoring to tax the rich. Why their proposals could backfire

Billionaire Tax News

California Democrats are clamoring to tax the rich. Why their proposals could backfire
Corporation TaxLow Income ResidentsMedi Cal

CalMatters is a nonpartisan and nonprofit news organization dedicated to serving the state of California.

Janitors, nurses, teachers and labor organizers rally at the state Capitol in Sacramento to launch UnRig California on March 11, 2026. This story is free to read because readers choose to support LAist. If you find value in independent local reporting, Progressive California Democrats, who have long fought and failed to raise taxes on the rich, are renewing their push this year in light of a specific threat: The seismic federal cuts to Medi-Cal, the state’s health care program for the poor. President Donald Trump’s H.R.1, signed into law last July, is estimated to strip tens of billions a year in state Medi-Cal funding and cause to lose coverage in future years — so large that the state is already struggling just to sustain the reduced level of care under H.R.1, let alone paying the federal government’s share.

It has prompted progressive lawmakers and health care advocates to call for higher taxes on corporations or billionaires to keep those at risk of losing benefits on the program. “We know that you are not responsible for these awful cuts, but now the responsibility does lie in your hands,” Judy Mark, executive director of Disability Voices United, an advocacy group for people with disabilities and their families, told state lawmakers at a January rally. “You have the power to increase our revenue so that we don’t have to make such devastating cuts.” Progressive lawmakers have introduced at least two proposals to tax corporations, including one that would direct funds toward Medi-Cal. Separately, health care advocates are backing a controversial ballot measure to tax billionaire wealth to replace lost federal dollars.

If you're enjoying this article, you'll love our daily newsletter, The LA Report. Each weekday, catch up on the 5 most pressing stories to start your morning in 3 minutes or less. A state board is considering the drastic move, which could come as soon as May, after an outbreak of the lung disease silicosis among countertop fabricators. LAUSD reaches labor deals with teachers, principals. Why schools could still be closed Tuesday Educators are expected to honor picket lines Tuesday if a deal can't be reached with the union that represents school support staff.

Backfilling the Medi-Cal cuts would make the gap larger, said Keely Martin Bosler, former state finance director with more than two decades of experience in state fiscal policy. To “maintain the same insured level of coverage, those costs are on top of the deficits that exist, and so that would be significant.” California, in its fourth consecutive year projecting a deficit, will likely see bigger shortfalls in future years as spending continues to outpace revenue. Even if the state spends nothing to backfill federal cuts, the deficit could reach $22 billion in fiscal year 2027-28, according to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s January budget proposal.

Newsom, in his last year as governor, has opposed any wealth tax over concerns that it would drive high-income earners out of California and dampen the tax base. Passing any tax increases would also require a two-thirds vote in each legislative chamber, a high bar even with a Democratic supermajority. The state is constitutionally required to direct roughly 50 cents of each dollar in excess general fund revenue toward K-14 education and reserves. That means the state would need roughly $44 billion in new revenue annually to close a $22 billion budget hole.

The Fair Games Coalition, made up of community leaders, labor organizations and advocates, announce the launch of the Overpaid CEO Tax Initiative in West Hollywood on Jan. 14, 2026. Assemblymember Connolly, an Oakland Democrat, would require businesses whose workers rely on Medi-Cal and food stamps to contribute to a fund to “prevent loss of or to restore” health care coverage under H.R.1. There are no details yet on how much the charge would be. proposed by the SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West, which would apply a 5%, one-time tax on billionaires’ wealth and use most of the revenue to backfill federal health care cuts. The initiative would establish a special fund that would exempt the revenue from constitutionally required deposits into education and savings. Supporters estimate it would generate $100 billion over five years.

SEIU-UHW spokesperson Suzanne Jimenez told CalMatters that it would allow the state to temporarily continue providing Medi-Cal coverage at the same level while giving state leaders time to figure out how best to sustain it. But even if voters approve the tax measure, critics say the funds could get locked up in court from lawsuits by billionaire taxpayers or by education groups, who might argue it skirts the state’s constitutional requirements to benefit schools. And it’s unclear how the state would sustain the funding after the money runs out: estimates that the measure could drive away billionaires and reduce income tax revenue the state could collect in future years. “The first step is to pass the billionaire tax so that we have five years to work on that plan. And then, right after Election Day, we will be ready to work with the next governor to figure out a long-term solution,” Jimenez said.

While they might do little to address the state’s structural deficit, proposals to tax the rich shrewdly tap into the public anxiety with “rather extraordinary disparity in the distribution of income and wealth,” said Kirk Stark, a professor of tax law and policy at UCLA. “I think that targeting the rich is understandable, but I don’t think that it’s really the kind of policy that can be expected to durably address very long-term structural fiscal imbalance,” he said. More than 60% of California’s likely voters support higher taxes on the state’s wealthiest to help with the state’s budget deficit, according to a The sentiment especially speaks to progressives, who have made fighting income inequality a core belief. But even the popular idea faces an uphill climb: Some Democrats contend that raising taxes on the state’s highest earners risks driving them away, especially since the state heavily relies on their income tax.

Janitors, nurses, teachers and labor organizers rally at the state Capitol in Sacramento to launch UnRig California on March 11, 2026. The initiative is a multiyear campaign aimed at reforming the state’s economy and tax code. “The wealthiest Californians are also the most mobile Californians,” said former Assembly Budget Chair Phil Ting, a San Francisco Democrat. “They could easily decide to go domicile in some other parts of the country.” It also could deter businesses and billionaires from moving to California. “Does it signal that California is not a friendly, accommodating jurisdiction for people who want to amass billions upon billions of dollars of wealth?” Stark said.

Other ideas to address the state’s budget needs more systemically could pose even bigger political risks, especially as the state’s revenue is booming thanks to an AI-driven economy. Stark said the state should examine its three primary revenue sources: income tax, sales tax and property tax. Since taxing income could dampen the incentive to work, and sales tax could discourage consumption, the state’s property tax — capped at 1% of the property value by Proposition 13 in 1978 — “jumps out as a tax reform that needs to happen in California,” he said. “Not something that’s going to be just a one-time hit on the elite, but a fundamental, structural reconsideration of how the state of California taxes the value of land and structures.”

It’s even harder now with affordability being top of mind for Californians, Ting said. “People are very cost-sensitive because they feel that their groceries are going up, their gas is going up, rent is going up, it’s a very difficult time to introduce even further costs in taxes to middle-class Californians.” You come to LAist because you want independent reporting and trustworthy local information. Our newsroom doesn’t answer to shareholders looking to turn a profit. Instead, we answer to you and our connected community. We are free to tell the full truth, to hold power to account without fear or favor, and to follow facts wherever they lead . Our only loyalty is to our audiences and our mission: to inform, engage, and strengthen our community. Right now, LAist has lost $1.7M in annual funding due to Congress clawing back money already approved. The support we receive from readers like you will determine how fully our newsroom can continue informing, serving, and strengthening Southern California.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

LAist /  🏆 606. in US

Corporation Tax Low Income Residents Medi Cal Proposals Tax The Rich

 

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Trump energy chief attacks California oil and gas policies in Long BeachTrump energy chief attacks California oil and gas policies in Long BeachCalMatters is a nonpartisan and nonprofit news organization dedicated to serving the state of California.
Read more »

California Republicans caught between Trump loyalty and winning swing districtsCalifornia Republicans caught between Trump loyalty and winning swing districtsCalMatters is a nonpartisan and nonprofit news organization dedicated to serving the state of California.
Read more »

Eric Swalwell to resign from Congress following sex assault allegationsEric Swalwell to resign from Congress following sex assault allegationsCalMatters is a nonpartisan and nonprofit news organization dedicated to serving the state of California.
Read more »

Can medical malpractice lawsuits protect LGBTQ youth from conversion therapy? A lawmaker thinks soCan medical malpractice lawsuits protect LGBTQ youth from conversion therapy? A lawmaker thinks soCalMatters is a nonpartisan and nonprofit news organization dedicated to serving the state of California.
Read more »

Swalwell's Exit Reshapes California Governor's Race, Bolstering Democrats' ChancesSwalwell's Exit Reshapes California Governor's Race, Bolstering Democrats' ChancesRep. Eric Swalwell's withdrawal from the California gubernatorial race is expected to help Democrats consolidate support, though the impact of sexual assault allegations and a crowded field remain key factors. Experts believe this will lead to a more unified front for the Democrats, potentially aiding their chances in the general election. The race will be influenced by endorsements, voter preferences, and the shifting political dynamics.
Read more »

Swalwell’s exit from California governor’s race leaves Democratic field in disarraySwalwell’s exit from California governor’s race leaves Democratic field in disarrayCalMatters is a nonpartisan and nonprofit news organization dedicated to serving the state of California.
Read more »



Render Time: 2026-04-18 00:42:03