New York City’s latest plan to keep mentally ill people from languishing in public is billed as a common-sense strategy to get them help. But Mayor Eric Adams’ policy will have to navigate a legal challenge and some city lawmakers are skeptical.
and other cities to handle at least some crisis calls with behavioral health professionals instead of police.“We need to make mental health care like medical care, a health issue responded to and treated by the people with the right training, at the right time, in the right places,” said American Psychiatric Association President Dr.
Rebecca Brendel. She maintains that using law enforcement authorities to respond to mental health crises unfairly criminalizes the mentally ill. Adams said officers will have access to real-time input from mental health professionals and will strive to persuade people to accept help voluntarily. His administration has stressed that while police can send someone to a hospital, it’s up to doctors whether the person needs to stay there or can be safely released for outpatient care.The complexity, and stakes, became tragically clear when a Rochester, New York, family called 911 in March 2020 about a loved one who was behaving erratically and saying he wanted to die. Once at a hospital,calmly and appropriately answered questions and said he wasn’t suicidal or homicidal, according to a psychiatrist’s grand jury testimony. The hospital released him. Hours later, police found Prude running in Rochester’s snowy streets. Officers eventually held him down until he stopped breathing; he was taken off life support days later. In general, when a patient arrives for emergency psychiatric evaluation, the first step is to ascertain whether a medical problem or drug use is causing the person’s behavior. If not, psychiatrists assess the patient partly by observing and asking questions. But they also seek information from loved ones, prior mental health providers and anyone else who can shed light.“You can’t just go with what you see or what the patient has told the nurse,” because the person may be unable or unwilling to give a complete picture, says Dr. Madhu Rajanna, the interim chief of psychiatry at St. John’s Episcopal Hospital on New York City’s Rockaway Peninsula. Staffers might need to calm combative patients — St. John’s says it doesn’t use restraints for that purpose and rarely employs sedatives — or discern whether cooperative patients who insist they’re feeling better are truly well enough to leave. St. John’s emergency room usually is evaluating eight to 10 psychiatric patients at any given time, and each is supposed to be either admitted or released within 24 hours. Rajanna and emergency medicine chair Dr. Leigha Clarkson said St. John’s 43 adult psychiatric beds are generally sufficient, though the hospital tries to release people swiftly once it’s safe.Citywide, however, Adams’ new policy could test capacity after hundreds of psychiatric beds were converted for COVID-19 cases. The state recentlyIt’s possible many people won’t. Richmond University Medical Center’s psychiatric emergency program, for instance, discharges about 3/4 of patients after assessment, Idowu said. Deciding whether patients stay or go “can be anxiety-provoking sometimes. Because it’s not perfect,” he said, but the goal is that “you don’t leave anything to chance.”
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
NYC mayor's $300 fine for rat infestation is dismissedDays after Mayor Eric Adams appeared remotely at a city hearing to contest a $300 fine for a rat infestation at a townhouse he owns, the fine was dismissed.
Read more »
Ruff seas: New York puppy escapes owner, swims across Hudson to New JerseyA New York City puppy went on a multiday adventure after he escaped his owner and swam across the Hudson River to New Jersey, being rescued several days later.
Read more »
New York Common Pantry opens new location for seniors in the South BronxThe community food pantry serves more than 500,000 people annually to help reduce hunger and food insecurity.
Read more »
New York officials announces Bronx Metro-North plan to build new stations, 6,000 homesThe ultimate goal is to reduce commute times and generate job growth.
Read more »
New law in New York expands accommodations for breastfeeding in the workplaceNew York State now has a new breastfeeding law for all employers.
Read more »