In San Francisco 49ers OTAs and minicamp, Brandon Allen took all the second-string reps and Joshua Dobbs took all the third-string reps. And that's because Allen was better.
When the 49ers signed Joshua Dobbs this offseason, he seemed like a potential upgrade over Sam Darnold as their no. 2 quarterback last year. Now, it seems like Dobbs may not even be an upgrade overDarnold signed with the Vikings this offseason, so Dobbs and Allen are competing to be Brock Purdy's backup. And Dobbs should be the overwhelming favorite to win the competition because he started 12 games last season while Allen hasn't started a game since 2021.
But in 49ers OTAs and minicamp, Allen took all the second-string reps and Dobbs took all the third-string reps. And that's because Allen was better. To be fair, Allen has been on the team since last year, so he knows Kyle Shanahan's offensive system inside and out while Dobbs is learning it for the first time. But Dobbs is extremely smart and already seems to know where he should go with the ball.
The problem for Dobbs is getting the ball accurately to his intended receiver. His passes are all over the place. He can hit the short ones, but when it's time to throw the intermediate passes over the middle, he throws high, low, behind the receiver -- anywhere but on target and in stride. He's a pass breakup or an interception waiting to happen on those plays.
And despite all of Dobbs' playing experience, he still has won just three starts in the NFL while Allen has won two. So their resumes are comparable. Neither one has a leg up on the other. Whoever plays better in training camp will be Purdy's backup, and so far Allen has the lead.Grant Cohn has covered the San Francisco 49ers daily since 2011.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Can Brandon Allen Beat Out Joshua Dobbs as the 49ers No. 2 Quarterback?Most analysts assume Joshua Dobbs will be the 49ers' no. 2 quarterback this year because started 12 games last season while Brandon Allen has started just 9 games in his entire career even though he's 31 and will turn 32 in September.
Read more »
Kyle Shanahan Explains Why the 49ers Signed Joshua DobbsOne of the most intriguing new players on the 49ers is backup quarterback Joshua Dobbs. He's smart, he's athletic and he seems to fit the 49ers offensive scheme. On Tuesday, head coach Kyle Shanahan explained why the 49ers signed him.
Read more »
SI Ranks 49ers QB Joshua Dobbs the NFL's 13th Best Backup QBIn 2022, the 49ers went through four quarterbacks -- Trey Lance, Jimmy Garoppolo, Brock Purdy and Josh Johnson. All four got injured. So their backups matter. This season, their backup quarterback is Joshua Dobbs.
Read more »
Why Ricky Pearsall Wore a Blue Non-Contact Jersey in 49ers OTAsRicky Pearsall was the talk of 49ers OTAs and minicamp. Pearsall was the only player on the team wearing a blue jersey. Usually, players wear the blue jersey when they're injured. Pearsall seemed healthy.
Read more »
Why Jacob Cowing was a Disappointment in 49ers OTAs and MinicampOf all the 49ers rookies, Jacob Cowing was the biggest disappointment this offseason. Not because he practiced poorly. He simply didn't practice much. He was injured most of the time, which isn't a great sign for a small player who relies on speed.
Read more »
Why 49ers WR Ricky Pearsall Looks Good in OTAsRicky Pearsall is not small, he's not slow and he doesn't drop passes. He also seems confident and polished for a rookie. So it's no surprise that he played with the starters during 49ers OTAs.
Read more »