Naomi Fry on David Osit’s new documentary, “Predators,” which examines the TV show “To Catch a Predator,” which was hosted by Chris Hansen.
Kimmel’s characterization of Hansen’s show may have been tongue-in-cheek, but it also wasn’t off the mark. “To Catch a Predator,” which aired between 2004 and 2007 as part of the news-magazine series “Dateline NBC,” was essentially a hidden-camera prank program.
Unlike Ashton Kutcher’s MTV offering, however, its subjects weren’t celebrities falling prey to practical jokery but, instead, members of the public lured into a sting house under the impression that they were about to have sex with a minor, played by an of-age but young-looking decoy whom they had been engaging with online. Once at the house, these men were confronted by Hansen and his camera crew and then arrested by local law enforcement. None of this might sound particularly funny, but what struck me as I watched “Predators”—a thoughtful and disturbing documentary that uses a combination of archival clips, raw footage, and talking-head interviews to examine the history and legacy of “Catch”—was the way mirth kept cropping up again and again, in and around the show. It’s there in Oprah’s excitable interaction with Hansen when she hosts him on her program; it’s there in the uproarious response of a true-crime convention audience as its members watch footage of Hansen questioning a predator; it’s even there in the barely concealed amusement of a police lieutenant as she tells Hansen that one predator, whom the camera crew was about to capture, had shot himself in the head once he came face to face with law enforcement. The revenge impulse surely plays a part in these gleeful responses: as one woman who has served as a decoy in pedophile-sting operations tells Osit bluntly, “It is fucking funny when a bad person gets what is coming to them.” But the director’s focus on laughter also stands in for a larger critical point that he’s trying to get at. To watch “Predators” is to realize that “Catch” functioned first and foremost as entertainment, which largely mooted its other vaunted missions—to serve justice, to get to the bottom of sexual pathology, to provide solace to abuse survivors—while also flattening the essential humanity of the show’s subjects, turning troubled individuals’ actions into a quasi-pornographic exhibit meant for an audience’s voyeuristic titillation. “Catch” was a tightly edited show that relied on recurring beats to satisfy its viewers, and one of the ways in which Osit’s documentary begins to loosen that fixed familiarity is through the inclusion of long moments of raw footage taken over the course of various shoots but left on the cutting-room floor. In these clips, we see the predators, once confronted by Hansen or, later, by law enforcement, crying, apologizing, asking for forgiveness and counselling and help—all of which the show, whose chief aim is to elevate perversion and its punishment into spectacle, is both unable and unwilling to provide them with. Watching these men break down is an uncomfortable experience, and Osit, himself a survivor of childhood sexual abuse, isn’t trying to claim that they are somehow good or blameless. Still, as the ethnographer Mark de Rond says of the footage, “To show these men as human beings, the show kind of breaks down. And maybe that’s why it didn’t make it on TV.” Turning humans into fetishes to be observed rather than understood wasn’t just a characteristic of “Catch” but of popular culture more generally at the time of the show’s airing. At one point in the documentary, Osit includes an archival MSNBC clip from the conservative news show “Scarborough Country,” which, right after an interview with Hansen about “Catch,” goes on to promote an upcoming segment about Britney Spears’s mental-health battle. “Oops, she left it again!” a voice-over blares alongside videos of the singer, smiling and waving on the red carpet. “Britney’s second stint at rehab is over and done with. So, can anyone or anything convince her to get the help she so desperately needs?” Spears’s sexualization as an underage star could hardly be extricated from the later struggles that she was publicly shamed for, and, as I watched the clip, it was difficult not to think of the ways in which “Catch,” too, conveniently avoided discussing how the predators that the show uncovered didn’t entirely act alone; the culture itself was predatory. It bears mentioning, too, that “Catch” didn’t emerge in a generic vacuum. In the early- to mid-two-thousands, reality TV was a relatively young category still finding its footing, and the era was replete with shows whose utter vulgarity pushed the medium’s envelope as far as it could possibly go. Programs such as 2004’s “The Swan,” in which a group of women underwent extensive plastic surgery to become conventionally attractive over the course of a season, or 2005’s “Who’s Your Daddy,” in which eight men competed for a payout of a hundred thousand dollars by each trying to convince an adopted woman that he was her biological father, were part of that era’s reality-TV lingua franca. Like these shows, “Catch” was characterized by a desire not just to document people’s pain but to indulge in and profit off of it. What’s more, Osit’s documentary makes the point that even though Hansen’s show was cancelled, in 2007, “Catch” was just the first in a long line of predatory entertainment about predators. In the past few years, YouTube has teemed with videos of men serving rough vigilante justice to predators that they manage to lure to public spaces through online interaction, and at least one creator of such content, who goes by the name Skeet Hansen, sees “Catch” and its host as direct predecessors. Osit follows Skeet as he coaxes a predator to a motel room with the help of a decoy. Wearing an ill-fitting blazer atop his T-shirt, and sounding not unlike Chris Pratt’s dopey Andy Dwyer pretending to be F.B.I. agent Burt Macklin on the NBC sitcom “Parks and Recreation,” Skeet tells the man that he’s part of the “Predatorial Investigation Unit.” All of this make-believe in the service of clicks would be fun if it weren’t for the absolutely depressing vision of a pervert sitting in a cheap motel room, hiding his face, crying, and suggesting he might kill himself. At one point, even Skeet seems perturbed. “We’re gonna pull some strings and see if we can, you know, get you someone that you can talk to,” he tells the man, baselessly. For those familiar with the genre, it’s already clear that there is no help forthcoming. ♦
Sex Crimes Ethics Tv Shows Documentary Films
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Ryan McMahon Flips Into Red Sox Dugout to Make Best Catch of the Playoffs So FarEverything went the Yankees' way for the first eight innings of Thursday's game.
Read more »
Yankees initially sweated over Ryan McMahon's 'crazy' flip-diving catch: 'So worried'The Yankees are alive, in part, because of Ryan McMahon. The third baseman is happy to report that he, too, is alive.
Read more »
Red Sox Player Applauded for Act Towards Ryan McMahon After Tumbling CatchWeissert helped slow down McMahon's full-speed tumble into the Red Sox dugout.
Read more »
These four crankbait styles will help you catch more and bigger bass.Choose from these four crankbait styles, such as squre bill, lipless, deep diving, and wakebaits, to catch more and bigger bass when fishing.
Read more »
Dodgers’ Will Smith available to catch in NLDS vs. PhilliesSmith, who has not played since Sept. 9 while a hairline fracture in his right hand has been healing, was on the active roster for the Wild Card Series but did not appear in either game.
Read more »
Years later, WhatsApp may finally catch up to the competition with this new featureIlia, a tech journalist at PhoneArena, has been covering the mobile industry since 2011, with experience at outlets like Forbes Bulgaria. Passionate about smartphones, tablets, and consumer tech, he blends deep industry knowledge with a personal fascination that began with his first Nokia and Sony Ericsson devices.
Read more »