+34
While providing a last-ditch survival option for people trapped amid a wildfire provides an obvious benefit, refuges could also deter people from evacuating.
PARADISE, CA – NOVEMBER 08: Classic cars burn in Paradise, Calif. , as a the Camp Fire rages through Butte County, Thursday, November 8, 2018.
As wildfire researchers warn that some communities do not have enough roads to evacuate safely, they are also raising a fraught question: Should fire-risk neighborhoods have designated refuge areas for people who cannot get out? A new study that found wildfire deaths in California and across the U.S. between 2008 and 2024 were concentrated in communities with few exit routes also contains a controversial recommendation to set up refuge areas in fire-risk communities to serve as “preplanned shelter-in-place options” that could “enhance survival when evacuation fails.
”The researchers from UC Santa Barbara pointed to the 2018 Camp Fire in Paradise east of Chico. While some fleeing residents died in vehicles stuck in traffic,But the report’s suggested investment in shelter-in-place refuges is “one of the great controversial issues” in wildfire response, UC Berkeley fire scientist Michael Gollner said. A last-ditch survival option could save people trapped by flames, Gollner said, but it could also deter residents from evacuating early, putting them and firefighters at greater risk.
Seth Schalet, CEO of the Santa Clara County FireSafe Council, would like to see designated temporary refuges included in wildfire response plans by counties and local governments so they can “communicate to people that in a last-resort situation, here’s where you need to go. ” Public outreach and education would be needed to ensure residents do not delay evacuation because they believe they can rely on a refuge, Schalet said.
Local and regional fire chiefs are aware of locations that could serve as refuges for people unable to evacuate, but publicly designating such sites as shelter-in-place options is problematic, said Chelsea Burkett, spokesperson for Cal Fire’s Santa Clara County Unit.
“If we’re giving an evacuation order or a warning that’s us saying, ‘This is the time to start moving,'” Burkett said. “We would rather people adhere to those warnings and those orders that are given rather than having to use those temporary refuge areas. ” Gollner said refuges could save lives in some situations, but would need to be identified in advance by local emergency managers charged with wildfire response, who would decide when to use them.
Such sites would need to be staffed by first responders, which could divert firefighters and equipment from the battle against a blaze, Gollner added. Michael Wara, senior research scholar at Stanford University’s Woods Institute for the Environment, said the many older adults living in Bay Area communities at risk of burning could have trouble escaping a wildfire in time.
“My favorite neighbors are also most likely to die in a fire,” said Wara, who lives in Mill Valley. “It would make sense to have a temporary refuge. ” Any outdoor shelter site must be fire resistant and offer protection from heat as well as flame, Wara said.
“The heat from these fires can be enough to kill people,” Wara said. “People’s lungs get burned and then they suffocate. ” In fast-moving wildfires, the most dangerous conditions can pass through a community relatively quickly, Wara said. He said public agencies could consider using money to fire-harden a small number of homes or buildings that could serve as last-resort community refuges.
Scratch the next story
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Trump’s Controversial Sale of Arctic Drilling Rights Draws Almost No Interest“Oil and gas companies … know that drilling in the Arctic Refuge is a losing proposition,” said a critic of the sale.
Read more »
Colts' Anthony Richardson Deemed One of the Best Backup QBs in NFLThe Indianapolis Colts have a full quarterback room for the foreseeable future after Anthony Richardson Sr.'s time spent on the trade block failed to land any s
Read more »
Why Sam Ehlinger Could Stick Around as Broncos' Backup QBEhlinger has caught the eye of Broncos coach Sean Payton.
Read more »
Structures threatened in Saratoga Springs brush fire, evacuations orderedA brush fire in Saratoga Springs on Saturday has led to the evacuation of Mahogany Street.
Read more »
Backup catcher Sebastián Rivero goes 5 for 5 with 6 RBIs as Angels rout Dodgers 13-5Backup catcher Sebastián Rivero went 5 for 5 with six RBIs, leading the Los Angeles Angels to a 13-5 victory over the Dodgers.
Read more »
Few roads out, higher wildfire risk: New study maps Bay Area evacuation dangerAmong the deadly tragedies cited in the report are the 2018 Camp Fire east of Chico, and the 2020 North Complex Fire in Butte, Plumas and Yuba counties.
Read more »