Changes in hormone levels that occur seasonally may result in incorrect diagnoses of subclinical hypothyroidism and the unnecessary prescription of levothyroxine.
that El-Khoury's letter"raises a good point, that we really need to look at our reference ranges, especially when more and more studies are showing that so many thyroid hormone prescriptions may not be necessary.
" Cubb, who is thyroid section director and assistant professor of clinical medicine at Weill Cornell Medical College/Houston Methodist Academic Institute, Texas, also agrees with El-Khoury's suggestion to repeat lab results in some instances. "I think repeating results, especially in our patients with subclinical disease, is important," she noted. And she pointed out that seasonal variation isn't the only relevant variable."We also know that multiple clinical factors like pregnancy status, co-existing comorbidities, or age can all influence what we as clinicians consider an acceptable TSH range in an individual patient." And other medications, such as steroids, or supplements like"Ensuring that minor abnormalities aren't transient is important prior to initiating medical therapy. With any medical therapy there are possible side effects, along with time, cost, [and] monitoring, all of which can be associated with thyroid hormone replacement."El-Khoury explained that to get an idea of how big the seasonal differences in TSH observed in the Japanese study were,"the upper end of the population they tracked goes from 5.2 [mIU/L] in January to 3.4 [mIU/L] in August. So you have almost a 2-unit change in concentration that can happen in the reference population. But laboratory reference ranges, or 'normal ranges,' are usually fixed and don't change by season." The higher the TSH, the more likely a person is to have hypothyroidism. Major recent studies have found no benefit of levothyroxine treatment with TSH levels below 7.0-10.0 mIU/L, he said. "So, I suggest that the limit should be 7.0 [mIU/L] to be safe, but it could be as high as 10 [mIU/L]. In any case, let's shift the mindset to clinical outcome–based treatment cutoffs," he said, noting that this approach is currently used for decisions on cholesterol-lowering therapy orRegarding this suggestion of using a TSH cutoff of 7 mIU/L to diagnose subclinical hypothyroidism, Cubb said:"It really depends on the specific population. In an elderly patient, a higher TSH may be of less clinical concern when compared to a female who is actively trying to get pregnant." "Overall, I think we do need to better understand what appropriate TSH ranges are in specific subpopulations, and then with time, make this more understandable and available for general medicine as well as subspecialty providers to be able to utilize," she noted. Regarding the particular Japanese findings cited by El-Khoury, Cubb observed that this was a very specific study population,"so we would need more data showing that this is more generalizable." And she noted that there's also diurnal variation in TSH."In the [Japanese] paper, patients had their thyroid labs drawn between 8:00 AM and 9:00 AM in a fasting state. Oftentimes in the US, thyroid labs are not drawn at specific times or [during] fasting. I think this is one of many factors that should be considered."But overall, Cubb said that both the Japanese study and El-Khoury's letter highlight"how season, in and of itself, which is not something we usually think about, can affect thyroid lab results. I believe as more data come out, more generalizable data, that's how evidence-based guidelines are generated over time." According to El-Khoury, fixing the laboratory reference range issues would likely require a joint effort of professional medical societies, reference laboratories, and assay manufacturers. But with seasonal variation, that might be a difficult task. "The problem is, in laboratory medicine, we don't have rules for an analyte that changes by season to do anything different. My goal is to get people to at least acknowledge this is a problem and do something," he concluded.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
MTA to test cameras on buses as side mirrors keep smacking objects on streetsOfficials say about a quarter of the bus collisions reported last year involved side mirrors.
Read more »
C.J. Stroud dismisses low cognitive test results: 'I'm not a test taker, I play football'The 2023 NFL Draft begins Thursday, and former Ohio State quarterback C.J. Stroud shrugged off any concerns about his recent S2 Cognition Test scores.
Read more »
AI Detects Severe Thyroid Eye DiseaseResearch demonstrates that the analysis of CT scans by AI can aid in diagnosing thyroid eye disease and evaluating its severity. autoimmunedisease ocularhealth ARVO2023
Read more »
Rocky Mountain National Park announces summer seasonal Hiker Shuttle operations begin May 26Rocky Mountain National Park will operate the Hiker Shuttle during the 2023 summer season beginning on Friday, May 26. Seven-day service will operate May 26 through Sept. 4.
Read more »
10 Exciting New & Seasonal Aldi Items To Score In MayAldi features products from its private label to national brands in the “Aldi Finds” section, and this May there are so many new good ones.
Read more »
Seasonal Mukbang: 7 Korean Spring Dishes You Must Try Before the Season Ends | allkpopSpring in Korea brings a unique twist to the traditional dishes, where warmer weather calls for comfort food to relieve stress. With the arrival of f…
Read more »