All conversations about Victor Wembanyama’s MVP candidacy are missing one crucial point—NBA history says young stars almost never win the league’s signature award.
The Spurs superstar posted 26 points, 15 rebounds and five blocks to lead his team to a win over the Heat in merely 26 minutes of play. San Antonio outscored Miami by 19 points when the tall Frenchman was on the floor.
It was the dominant two-way display we’ve become accustomed to seeing out of Wembanyama this season; really, the stats only begin to scratch the surfaceIt was also, without a doubt, an MVP-caliber performance. Wembanyama provided enormous value the likes of which only he is capable of providing. After the game, he spelled out that case as clearly as possible for the NBA world when asked by Jared Weiss of“I think right now, it is still reasonable there is a debate,” Wembanyama said. “My goal is to make sure there is no debate anymore at the end of the season. ... My first would be that defense is 50% of the game and that is undervalued, so far, in the MVP race. I believe I’m the most impactful player defensively in the league. Second argument would be that we almost swept in the season and we dominated them three times with their real team and four times with the, you know, more rotation players. My third argument would be that offense impact is not just points.”It’s a good case. While Wembanyama doesn’t quite go bullet-for-bullet down the list of MVP requirements in the modern game—stats, wins and narrative—he comes pretty close. His set of arguments sparked a wave of Wembanyama MVP discussion. His case has been hotly debated alongside that of Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and Luka Dončić. But when trying to project how the race will shake out down the stretch of the season, there is one factor that keeps getting overlooked whenever Wembanyama’s candidacy is discussed: his age.When looking at Wembanyama’s MVP case in totality, it is important to acknowledge the factors he’s battling against. One of those factors is just how young the Spurs star is. It doesn’t preclude Wembanyama from winning the award, of course, but history shows players that young don’t take home MVP. Wembanyama only turned 22 in January. That means he would be the youngest MVP in NBA history if he won this year’s award. Derrick Rose currently holds that honor after winning the 2011 MVP at 22 years, seven months old; he is the only player in league history to win MVP before turning 23. There is literally no precedent for a player as youthful as Wembanyama winning the biggest individual award in the sport. That reflects the simple reality that players that age just don’t win MVP.they are young. But 22-year-old NBA stars are just getting their first bite at the MVP apple, so to speak. The competition is often fierce enough that a relative lack of established track record can be used against them. There’s a risk of rewarding a flash-in-the-pan season that inspires hesitation in voters. Not to mention the human element of the voting process where the idea a youthful player has plenty of good years left may push voters to another equally deserving but older candidate. Rose is the gold standard for young MVP candidates now, and he enjoyed a very particular set of circumstances to win at his age. He led the Bulls to 62 wins as the undisputed motor of the offense and averaged 25 points and seven assists per game with truly electrifying highlights. Rose was a national sensation. He also had the good fortune of going up against LeBron James in his first Miami season after two consecutive MVP wins—which meant voter fatigue combined with the “Heatles” narrative to form an anti-LeBron votex that year. That left a wide-open lane that Rose gladly stepped into, one that disappeared immediately as James won the next two MVPs. The reasoning in the Rose case and at large is mostly all unquantifiable. But so is the formula behind MVP voting. We can best glean information about that formula from past results. And those past results tells us that, for one reason or another, young superstars very rarely win MVP.Could Wembanyama break the trend? Absolutely. Unlike many young stars who are coming into their own, he isn’t playing for an average team with the freedom to do basically whatever he wants every night. The star center is the most important player on the second seed in the West, one of the only teams in the NBA believed to have a chance at unseating the reigning champions. Furthermore, his actual arguments as laid out above are quite solid. Wembanyama’s three blocks per game and various advanced defensive statistics back up his claim to the most impactful defensive player in the NBA; his individual defensive rating of 103.5 ranks third in the league and his 4.4 defensive win shares are more than any other player. His showings on that end of the floor can be equally as eye-popping His Spurs should win nearly 60 games and, as noted by Wemby himself above, have plenty of statement victories over the best team in the NBA in Oklahoma City. Despite all that he lags behind a bit in narrative—until recently, few expected the Spurs big man to even qualify for end-of-season awards. But there is no doubt among fans and media that Wembanyama is one of the best, most impactful players in basketball right now. That’s a lot of boxes that are checked, and he has a few more weeks remaining in the season to improve his odds. The only real knock against the big man is his scoring numbers. Wembanyama averages 24.3 points per game this year with above-average efficiency numbers. If he won MVP at that number, it would be the lowest PPG number for an MVP since Steph Curry’s win in 2015. Before him you’d have to go all the way back to Steve Nash’s two wins in the mid-aughts to find an MVP who averaged fewer than 24 points per game. Scoring numbers have always been a large part of any MVP discussion, but there’s been a particular emphasis in that department in the last decade; it makes for yet another trend Wembanyama is battling against. There has never been a player in the NBA like Wembanyama and thus it would line up if he managed to pull off something never before seen in the NBA. But winning MVP is a tall task, one made all the taller with history working against him.Liam McKeone is a senior writer for the Breaking and Trending News team at Sports Illustrated. He has been in the industry as a content creator since 2017, and prior to joining SI in May 2024, McKeone worked for NBC Sports Boston and The Big Lead. In addition to his work as a writer, he has hosted the Press Pass Podcast covering sports media and The Big Stream covering pop culture. A graduate of Fordham University, he is always up for a good debate and enjoys loudly arguing about sports, rap music, books and video games. McKeone has been a member of the National Sports Media Association since 2020.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
How Victor Wembanyama and Spurs picked apart the Heat's defenseThe San Antonio Spurs' offense took off against Miami behind Victor Wembanyama, but here's a look into what both sides did on that end of the floor.
Read more »
Victor Wembanyama says he should lead the MVP race after performance in MiamiAfter a dominant win over the Miami Heat, Victor Wembanyama went through why he feels he'll be a deserving candidate for MVP.
Read more »
Victor Wembanyama wants the MVP award, and wants to leave no doubt by season's endVictor Wembanyama is making it clear: He wants to win the NBA’s MVP award this season
Read more »
Spurs' Victor Wembanyama makes his case for NBA's MVP awardVictor Wembanyama is making it clear: He wants to win the NBA's MVP award this season.
Read more »
Wembanyama makes MVP case as Spurs clinch divisionMIAMI (AP) — Victor Wembanyama is making it clear: He wants to win the NBA's MVP award this season.The San Antonio star — moments after his team officially clinched its first Southwest Division title in nine seasons — de
Read more »
NBA MVP Odds: Victor Wembanyama Gaining Ground on Luka Doncic, Shai Gilgeous-AlexanderBreaking down the latest odds to win the NBA's MVP award in the 2025-26 season.
Read more »