Joint SEC-CFTC interpretive guidance outlines how the agencies will determine whether a cryptocurrency is a security.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and Commodity Futures Trading Commission published interpretive guidance explaining how they might define what is or isn't a security in crypto; the CFTC also issued a no-action letter for a non-custodial wallet provider to facilitate derivatives and prediction markets transactions; Arizona is filing criminal charges against a prediction market provider; and by the way we kind-of-sort-of have hints of movement on market structure legislation.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission published interpretive guidance this week — joined by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission — laying out how it approached the question of what in crypto it will deem a security.What is, and isn't, a security has long bedeviled the industry. We had efforts at somewhat defining this from the SEC in the past — Bill Hinman's "When Howey met Gary " speech, for example — but this week'sit saw in the crypto space, with one of these categories being digital securities. These are cryptocurrencies that meet the definition of a security under any other context, but happen to be tokenized, the guidance said. For example, if a crypto asset meets the prongs of the Howey Test, it's a security.Other categories include payment stablecoins, digital tools, digital collectibles and digital commodities, which are generally not securities unless the issuers or operators take actions that might meet securities regulations, such as fractionalizing the tokens in question. "We establish a straightforward taxonomy of crypto assets — most of which are not securities — and clarify how the Supreme Court’s Howey test applies when a crypto asset is part of an investment contract," SEC Chair Paul Atkins and Commissioners Hester Peirce and Mark Uyeda"Market participants — from innovators and issuers to individual investors — should review this interpretation to better understand the regulatory jurisdiction between the SEC and CFTC," the CFTC said in a press release. "The interpretation will be published on CFTC.gov and in the Federal Register." Congressman Troy Downing called the guidance "very positive," but said Congress still needed to pass market structure legislation as a future administration could undo the interpretative guidance. "Just having another two or three years of this and then having ambiguity out there doesn't make most people comfortable on doing any kind of big investment," he told CoinDesk. "But it's a great start because this is exactly what the industry wants, and it allows some people to move forward." Chris LaVigne, a partner at the law firm Withers, said the guidance "predictably concludes that most crypto assets and many common crypto activities are not securities," though the agency kept some discretion to being an enforcement action in this area. "The guidance moves the securities inquiry away from the asset or activity itself and re-centers the analysis on the transactions and representations in which these assets or activities arise or are marketed," he said. "By doing so, the SEC did not completely eliminate uncertainty or its enforcement role, because it concludes that a crypto asset that is not a security can nonetheless be sold as part of an investment contract if it is marketed with promises of profit derived from the issuer’s essential managerial efforts." A crypto that was marketed as a security may eventually be deemed something else "once those promises are fulfilled or no longer operative," he said. This might affect securities more broadly than just crypto assets.Jason Gottlieb, a partner at Morrison Cohen, said the Commodity Exchange Act defines commodities as a list of products , services and other issues "in which contracts for future delivery are presently or in the future dealt in." This legal definition diverges from the definition seemingly being used in the guidance. The CFTC's approach to crypto over the past decade has evolved since some early lawsuits, where it claimed jurisdiction over bitcoin, leading it to seemingly have jurisdiction over non-security cryptocurrencies. But this definition needs to be codified by market structure legislation, he told CoinDesk. "People need to understand that jurisdiction is still uncertain. The SEC is clearly saying 'we don't have jurisdiction if the token does not meet these criteria,'" he said. "Just because the SEC does not have jurisdiction does not mean the CFTC does." Gottlieb said he was part of a case before the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals seeking to gain clarity on this question, but market structure legislation would be needed to cleanly grant the CFTC jurisdiction over all non-security cryptocurrencies. The status of that legislation also remains up in the air. Senator Cynthia Lummis , speaking at the DC Blockchain summit earlier this week, said she anticipated a markup may happen in the final weeks of April. The issue of stablecoin yield may be resolved with an agreement that stablecoin issuers and their partner firms would not describe their products using bank terminology, though she cautioned that she hadn't seen any specific language yet. The flip side, several individuals told me, is that the Clarity Act might require the SEC to go back to the drawing board on how it's defining securities in crypto. But this falls under the category of bridges that can be crossed when they're reached. Senator Tim Scott , the chair of the Senate Banking Committee, said lawmakers are also close to agreements on issues like ethics and quorums on the regulatory agencies — some of the outstanding areas of disagreement on the bill. Downing said he saw an April time frame as doable for advancing market structure legislation. The closer lawmakers get to the end of the year, however, the less likely it would be that anything could be passed, he said, pointing to the midterm election. "But I don't think it's impossible." Senator Kirsten Gillibrand said on stage at the DC summit that she was "optimistic" there would be a markup soon, which would then lead to the Banking and Agriculture Committee's bills combining."One of the issues that I think is very important that people should be aware of is the Senate wants an ethics provision," she said. "I think the House would have had even more support on the Democratic side if they had retained their ethics provisions in their bill. It's very important that members of Congress do not get rich off of this industry, because they have access to non-public information, because they have positions of power and authority." Downing said the market structure bill needed to address consumer protections and money laundering, without being so restrictive that companies would be scared to do anything. "Nobody wants bad actors in their space and nobody wants that reputation of bad actors using this as a tool to do bad things," he said. "... If you bring those in too narrow, nobody's going to do anything innovative.""Community lenders, community banks are worried about depositors all exiting the market, in which case you're not doing mortgages on small farms in Montana, right?" he said. Late Friday, Senators Angela Alsobrooks and Thom Tillis told Politico they had reached an agreement on the yield issue, though the details had not been shared with the banking or crypto industries as of press time.refused to grant an administrative motionIn Nevada, a judge ruled that Kalshi can't offer sports, election or entertainment-related event contracts at least temporarily. According to the order by Judge Jason Woodbury, the record in Nevada's case against Kalshi so far suggests that it offers products defined by state law, making its conduct subject to Nevada's gaming regulators. "The question of federal preemption in this regard is nuanced and rapidly evolving," the judge wrote. "At the moment, the balance of convincing legal authority weighs against federal preemption in this context."goes further, alleging misdemeanor violations on small bets placed on professional football and college basketball games, upcoming elections and on whether bills become law and whether public figures will show up to sporting events. "Arizona law prohibits operating an unlicensed wagering business, and separately bans betting on elections outright," Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes' office said in"To ensure responsible gaming, casinos, sportsbooks and online gaming sites have to follow minimum age requirements, participate in integrity monitoring and support critical consumer protections, like programs that help people with gambling addictions," she said. "Yet, this past year, emboldened by limp and overly permissive federal regulators like the Commodity Futures Trading Commission , so-called 'prediction markets' have transformed themselves into illegal sportsbooks, offering their users illicit sports wagers."If you’ve got thoughts or questions on what I should discuss next week or any other feedback you’d like to share, feel free to email me atSam Bankman-Fried, the former FTX chief serving a 25-year fraud sentence, has stepped up public praise of President Donald Trump, including support for recent U.S. strikes on Iran. His comments, issued via prison-approved intermediaries, highlight Trump-era policies on gas prices and crypto regulation and have fueled speculation he is seeking a presidential pardon. The outreach comes as the FTX Recovery Trust moves to return about $2.2 billion to creditors amid near-full recoveries for many.Mar 21, 2026
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Iowa State loses star F Joshua Jefferson to injury in NCAA blowout of Tennessee StateIowa State star Joshua Jefferson left in the first half of the second-seeded Cyclones' 108-74 romp past No. 15 seed Tennessee State with a left ankle injury Fri
Read more »
Alabama Learns From SEC Tournament, Uses 'Urgency' To Survive And AdvanceThe Crimson Tide showed a completely different response to an early deficit against Hofstra than it did a week ago.
Read more »
What We Learned From Iowa State Basketball's Victory Over Tennessee StateThe Iowa State Cyclones were able to get a big win over their first-round opponent in the NCAA tournament.
Read more »
Gemini, Crypto.com Latest Crypto Firms to Blame Downsizing on AIMeanwhile, some companies have abandoned crypto entirely to focus on the higher profits available in AI.
Read more »
SEC crypto guidance puts the 'final nail' in the Gensler era: AnalystThe most recent news about crypto industry at Cointelegraph. Latest news about bitcoin, ethereum, blockchain, mining, cryptocurrency prices and more
Read more »
Dem Sec’y of State Benson: SAVE Act Is Attempt to ‘Rig’ ElectionsSource of breaking news and analysis, insightful commentary and original reporting, curated and written specifically for the new generation of independent and conservative thinkers.
Read more »