The Supreme Court ruled in favor of a Colorado counselor who challenged a law banning conversion therapy for minors, ruling that lower courts failed to apply 'sufficiently rigorous First Amendment scrutiny.'
Washington — The Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled in favor of a Colorado counselor who challenged a state law that bans 'conversion therapy' for minors, ruling that lower courts failed to apply 'sufficiently rigorous First Amendment scrutiny' in the case.
The high court ruled 8-1 that Colorado's law, when applied to talk therapy provided by counselor Kaley Chiles, regulates speech based on viewpoint. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the lone dissenter. She read her dissenting opinion from the bench.The ruling reverses a decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit that found the law did not violate Chiles' free-speech rights. The appeals court instead concluded that it regulates professional conduct and only incidentally burdens speech.The decision from the high court is a narrow one and does not overturn Colorado's law outright. It requires the lower courts to apply a more stringent level of review when evaluating its constitutionality.'Colorado's law addressing conversion therapy does not just ban physical interventions. In cases like this, it censors speech based on viewpoint,' Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote for the majority. 'Colorado may regard its policy as essential to public health and safety. Certainly, censorious governments throughout history have believed the same. But the First Amendment stands as a shield against any effort to enforce orthodoxy in thought or speech in this country.'Gorsuch write that Colorado's law doesn't just regulate the content of Chiles' speecy, but 'goes a step further, prescribing what views she may and may not express.'In her dissent, Jackson wrote that to do anything other than allow Colorado's regulation of medical treatment 'opens a dangerous can of worms.''It threatens to impair States' ability to regulate the provision of medical care in any respect. It extends the Constitution into uncharted territory in an utterly irrational fashion. And it ultimately risks grave harm to Americans' health and wellbeing,' she wrote.Colorado's ban on conversion therapyColorado is one of more than 20 states that have enacted restrictions on conversion therapy. Its measure, called the Minor Conversion Therapy Law, was enacted in 2019 and prohibits mental health professionals from engaging in any practice or treatment, including talk therapy, that attempts to change an individual's sexual orientation or gender identity. Violators face fines of up to $5,000 and may be suspended from practicing or stripped of their license.Several years after Colorado's law went into effect, Chiles, a licensed counselor who performs 'faith-informed' counseling when sought, sued state officials. She argued that the ban violates her free-speech rights by censoring her conversations with patients based on viewpoint and the content of those discussions. She aims to engage in talk therapy with minors who want to 'reduce or eliminate unwanted sexual attractions, change sexual behaviors or grow in the experience of harmony with physical bodies.' Chiles argued that under Colorado's ban, families and teens who want to address gender dysphoria by aligning identity and biological sex at birth cannot work with a licensed counselor to help reach that goal. But the measure does allow treatment that supports patients undergoing gender transition, Chiles' lawyers said.Colorado officials, though, said the law regulates medical treatments and practices provided by professionals licensed by the state. They argued it is part of a long history of states regulating the health care profession to protect patients from substandard or harmful treatment. Major medical associations have warned that practices aimed at trying to change a patient's sexual orientation or gender identity are potentially harmful to young people and not supported by credible scientific evidence.Lower courts had upheld Colorado's law, finding that it regulates the professional conduct of mental health professionals, not their speech.The decision from the Supreme Court joins a line of rulings that stand at the intersection of the free speech rights of religious parties and LGBTQ rights. The high court in 2015 legalized same-sex marriage and, five years later, ruled that a federal civil rights law prohibiting workplace discrimination based on sex extends to gay and transgender people.But its conservative majority has in recent years also sided with plaintiffs who have raised religious objections to state and local measures. In its last term, the high court ruled in favor of a group of Maryland parents who wanted to opt their children out of instruction featuring storybooks that address gender identity and sexual orientation. In another dispute from Colorado, the Supreme Court in 2023 found that the First Amendment prohibited the state from forcing a Christian graphic designer to express messages that were contrary to her closely held religious beliefs.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Supreme Court rules against Colorado ban on LGBTQ ‘conversion therapy’The Supreme Court has ruled against a law banning “conversion therapy” for LGBTQ+ kids in Colorado, one of about two dozen states that banned the discredited practice. The high court majority sided Tuesday with a Christian counselor who argues the law banning talk therapy violates the First Amendment.
Read more »
Supreme Court rules against Colorado's ban on conversion therapy aimed at LGBTQ youthLawrence Hurley is a senior Supreme Court reporter for NBC News.
Read more »
Supreme Court rules against Colorado ban on ‘conversion therapy’ for LGBTQ kidsThe Supreme Court has ruled against a law banning “conversion therapy” for LGBTQ+ kids in Colorado, one of about two dozen states that banned the discredited practice.
Read more »
Supreme Court rules against Colorado ban on ‘conversion therapy’ for LGBTQ kidsThe Supreme Court has ruled against a law banning “conversion therapy” for LGBTQ+ kids in Colorado, one of about two dozen states that banned the discredited practice.
Read more »
Supreme Court rules against Colorado ban on ‘conversion therapy’ for LGBTQ kidsThe justices agreed that the law raises free speech concerns.
Read more »
Supreme Court rules against Colorado in First Amendment dispute over ‘conversion therapy’ banThe Supreme Court ruled against Colorado in a dispute over its 'conversion therapy' ban, which the justices agreed was a free speech infringement.
Read more »