A sample of 4,013 participants from 24 countries were asked about aggression toward siblings and non-sibs, to determine whether aggressive sisters are an American phenomenon.
Although males are generally more aggressive, recent findings indicate a different pattern inside the family. Perhaps aggressive sisters is an American phenomenon, due to greater gender equality in recent years.
To distinguish cultural and evolutionary explanations, data were collected from 24 societies around the world., and other measures of aggressive behavior, sisters are every bit as likely to hit, kick, or yell at their siblings as are brothers. The general pattern, and the exceptions, were presumed to have something to do with evolved influences on human behavior. Aggression outside the family has to do with what evolutionary biologists call, which leads to relatively higher female selectivity in choosing mates, and thus contributes to . Aggression inside the family is, according to evolutionary biologists, a different game, in which both sexes are competing for the same resources. But the finding of high aggression among sisters might instead have been explained by something about American culture, such as changing social expectations about female competitiveness in recent years. If the phenomenon has something to do with human evolution, we would expect it to be universal. If, on the other hand, the phenomenon has something to do with American culture, we might expect it to look different in other cultures, and perhaps theTo address this question, a team of researchers headed by Michael Varnum and myself comparedaggression to aggression between non-siblings in 24 different societies . The questions included things like “Have you ever hit or slapped a brother?” “Have you ever hit or slapped a male friend?” “Have you ever hit or slapped a female acquaintance?” .Source: This is a public domain figure from the article being reviewed here Figure 1 shows the results for four categories of aggression directed toward people outside the family . Blue dots indicate that, for a given country and a given type of aggression, males are significantly more aggressive. Gray dots indicate no significant difference, and red dots indicate that females are significantly more aggressive. In 48 instances out of 96, males are significantly more aggressive than females. In three instances, females are significantly more aggressive. In the other cases, the differences are not significant. The bottom line indicates that, averaged across all the countries, males are more aggressive in all four categories. But now look at Figure 2, which depicts results for the same four categories of aggression directed against siblings. Here we see a different pattern.In only two of 96 cases are brothers more aggressive toward siblings than are sisters, whereas in 22 cases, sisters are more aggressive toward siblings. In roughly 75% of the instances, the sex differences are not significant. Looking again at the bottom line, the average difference across countries for hitting and slapping indicates a statistically significant, but not large, tendency for sisters to hit more as children, and no average difference as adults. For yelling, though, there are larger average sex differences, with females yelling at siblings more as children and as adults. These findings suggest that sex differences found outside the family are either absent or reversed for sibling aggression. They do not support the idea that the pattern has anything to do with American culture. From one perspective, it has been suggested that sex differences will disappear as females gain more social power. But the pattern was independent of a country’s economic development of gender equality.Why the difference between aggression inside and outside the family? Aggression outside the family, as I noted earlier, has been found across animal species, and has been linked to males competing for status as a means to appeal to mates. Inside the family, this is not what is going on, instead siblings are competing over shared familial resources.Varnum, M. E., Kirsch, A. P., Beal, D. J., Pick, C. M., … & Kenrick, D. T., Commonly Observed Sex Differences in Direct Aggression are Absent or Reversed in Sibling Contexts.Kirsch, A. P., Kenrick, D. T., Ko, A., Pick, C. M., & Varnum, M. E. . Sibling aggression is surprisingly common and sexually egalitarian.Self Tests are all about you. Are you outgoing or introverted? Are you a narcissist? Does perfectionism hold you back? Find out the answers to these questions and more with Psychology Today.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Construction crews find remnants of devastating 18th-century fires beneath iconic American cityFox News Channel offers its audiences in-depth news reporting, along with opinion and analysis encompassing the principles of free people, free markets and diversity of thought, as an alternative to the left-of-center offerings of the news marketplace.
Read more »
European Union and Mercosur bloc of South American nations sign landmark free trade agreementThe European Union and the Mercosur bloc of South American countries have formally signed a long-sought landmark free trade agreement. The deal inked on Saturday caps more than a quarter-century of torturous negotiations to strengthen commercial ties in the face of rising protectionism and trade tensions around the world.
Read more »
European Union and Mercosur bloc of South American nations sign landmark free trade agreementThe European Union and the Mercosur bloc of South American countries have formally signed a long-sought landmark free trade agreement.
Read more »
American Horror Story: Evan Peters on Ariana Grande; Season 13 UpdateKnowing that we have a 13th season of Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk's American Horror Story hitting our screens this October, with Jessica Lange, Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Angela Bassett, Kathy Bates, Ariana Grande, Emma Roberts, Billie Lourd, Gabourey Sidibe, and Leslie Grossman, is a pretty good way to start the new year.
Read more »
Did Ford's CEO just tell us the name of the Kodiaq rival they're launching next year?Indirect replacement for Focus will be a Spanish-built Kuga sibling with rugged design
Read more »
Navigating Sibling Comparisons and Fostering IndividualityA parent seeks advice on how to handle sibling comparisons between her two daughters, one academically inclined and the other more creative, and how to nurture each child's individual strengths and sense of self-worth without unintentional comparisons.
Read more »