The NHL playoffs have seen criticisms from fans for more than a decade now, but with the current season seeing yet another repeat of the Stars against the Wild fiasco, the hockey world seems to be done.
The annual debate over NHL playoff seeding has returned with added intensity as the postseason picture crystallizes. The Dallas Stars and Minnesota Wild sit on a collision course for a first-round series despite their conference-wide standings suggesting they deserve softer opponents.
Meanwhile in the Pacific Division, the Edmonton Oilers and Vegas Golden Knights would meet as the fifth and seventh-best teams in the conference. The disparity has reignited calls for the league to abandon its divisional format and return to conference-wide seeding.the league's reasoning during an edition of Daily Faceoff LIVE, noting that ownership and executives remain committed to the current system. "They've been very adamant about not changing it," Pagnotta said. "There's a lot of people that want it to go back to 1-8 rather than how it's set up divisionally, but the league really likes the fact that you've got meaningful games in round one." The league believes divisional matchups create significantly more compelling opening-round series. Pagnotta pointed to the potential Stars and Wild showdown as exactly the type of high-stakes matchup that drives viewership and fan engagement throughout the first round.The league's internal research has convinced leadership that divisional matchups produce superior television ratings compared to the old conference seeding format. Commissioner Gary Bettman and Deputy Commissioner Bill Daly have made their position clear through conversations with reporters. "From what the league has studied over the years has been that that has led to better ratings throughout the course of the playoffs," Pagnotta revealed. "Again, you can argue that 1-8 should be better. You should reward those teams that have had better seasons to face lesser opponents." The league remains adamant despite valid arguments for rewarding regular season success with favorable playoff matchups. Ownership and executives prioritize creating rivalries and meaningful early round battles over traditional seeding based purely on conference-wide standings and point totals.The NHL has also dismissed suggestions to expand the playoff field or implement a play-in tournament similar to other professional leagues. Bettman and Daly argue that the final five to six weeks of the regular season already function as an extended playoff race. "Once the trade deadline hits, you get those five, six weeks going into the playoffs. That's your play-in tournament," Pagnotta explained. "How many meaningful games are we keeping tabs on right now to see who's getting points and who's not?" The league maintains that the current structure creates sustained drama throughout the final month of the regular season. Teams fighting for playoff positioning generate compelling storylines and television ratings without needing additional postseason expansion or play-in tournament games. Make sure you bookmark Breakaway On SI for the latest news, exclusive interviews, recruiting coverage, and more!Deepanjan Mitra is an NHL-focused sports writer with over 1.5 years of experience delivering comprehensive ice hockey coverage across leading digital platforms. Currently contributing to Pro Football Sports Network , he specializes in breaking news, trade deadline analysis, playoff narratives, and real-time game recaps across all 32 NHL teams. A passionate Florida Panthers and Colorado Avalanche fan, Deepanjan brings authentic enthusiasm to his professional coverage—from the Panthers' historic 2025 Stanley Cup run to the Avalanche's championship legacy. His work spans player rankings and team previews to deep-dive historical features on iconic playoff moments and legendary rivalries.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
USC and ABC won’t change California governor debate format, reject accusations of biasSome Democratic candidates criticized the debate organizers for not inviting candidates of color to participate.
Read more »
Victor Wembanyama snaps the Spurs' 6-season playoff drought in dramatic fashion with game-winning shotFox News Channel offers its audiences in-depth news reporting, along with opinion and analysis encompassing the principles of free people, free markets and diversity of thought, as an alternative to the left-of-center offerings of the news marketplace.
Read more »
San Jose Sharks hit with another key injury as playoff push continuesSan Jose Sharks look to end three-game skid on Saturday against the Philadelphia Flyers
Read more »
MacKinnon stars as the Avalanche beat the Blackhawks 4-1 to clinch playoff spotNathan MacKinnon had three assists in Colorado's 4-1 victory over the Chicago Blackhawks, helping the Avalanche become the first NHL team to clinch a playoff spot this season.
Read more »
Stars stumble in OT vs. Wild in preview of possible playoff showdownThe Wild are in third place in the Central Division — five points behind Dallas and 14 up on Utah.
Read more »
Dallas Stars fall to Minnesota Wild 2-1 in OTVladimir Tarasenko scored 3:06 into overtime and the Minnesota Wild beat the Dallas Stars 2-1 on Saturday in what could be a first-round playoff preview.
Read more »