A Louisiana federal judge has tossed a lawsuit against Oprah over 'The Great Debaters'
, The Weinstein Company and MGM over the 2007 film, which starred and was directed by Denzel Washington. David Wayne Semien alleged Tolson's family was "not compensated in any monetary way" for the use of Tolson's name and "unique life experiences" as a professor at Wiley College who in the 1930s led the school's debate team to a national championship amid segregation.
Defendants asked the court to toss the suit arguing that not only are filmmakers protected by the First Amendment, but also that the complaint was filed a decade too late and Louisiana, where Tolson resided, doesn't recognize posthumous rights of publicity, so the rights to his story died with him in 2006.
Then, in March 2018, the matter was stayed pending TWC's bankruptcy until Semien asked the court to un-pause the case. The bankruptcy judge granted the request, giving U.S. District Judge S. Maurice Hicks Jr. the green light to consider the defendants' motions to dismiss. Hicks first addressed whether Semien was too late in bringing the suit. He had argued that the alleged injuries didn't just happen when the film debuted, but that they continued as it was marketed and sold. Hicks disagreed, and found that the bulk of Semien's suit was filed more than eight years too late.
With regard to the remaining claims, Hicks found that the Tolson family's decision not to hire lawyers to draw up contracts in relation to the film because Harpo staffers allegedly told them "we are going to take care of you" isn't enough to sustain a cause of action for detrimental reliance.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
‘On The Record,’ Russell Simmons #MeToo Doc, Charts Course to Sundance After Oprah ExitUpdate: A spokesperson for Kirby Dick and Amy Ziering says the filmmaking team will participate in print and broadcast interviews at the Sundance film festival. The accusers featured in the film ar…
Read more »
Oprah Says Sundance Doc Exit is 'Not a Victory for Russell' SimmonsAppearing on 'CBS This Morning,' Winfrey explained why she took her name off of Kirby Dick and Amy Ziering's upcoming film about sexual assault in the music industry, featuring women who've accused the Def Jam founder of sexual misconduct.
Read more »
What you need to know about Oprah Winfrey's controversial new book club pick 'American Dirt'The novel, which tells the story of a family's border crossing, has elicited sharp criticisms from the Latinx community.
Read more »
Amy Schumer Really Asked Oprah for Her Constipation AdviceMost people wouldn't feel comfortable bringing up their BMs in conversation with Oprah. But most people aren't Amy Schumer. The comedian recently told Oprah she…
Read more »
Oprah defends exiting #MeToo doc after pressure from Russell Simmons: 'This is not a victory for him'Oprah Winfrey is setting the record straight on her decision to pull out of 'On the Record,' a documentary focused on the MeToo movement in the music industry.
Read more »