Elie Mystal: 'Trump judges do not believe in the rule of law. They do not believe in precedent. They do not believe in facts. They do not believe in logic. They just believe in whatever is going to help Donald Trump'
At each step of the way, Cannon’s often dubious legal conclusions add up to a political win for Trump and dangerous precedent for our criminal justice system. First, Cannon concluded that she had jurisdiction to rule on Trump’s request for a special master, deciding that she possessed something called equitable jurisdiction, which she admitted is reserved only for “exceptional circumstances.”
Cannon first concluded that Trump “has an individual interest in and need for the seized property” because the documents the FBI obtained included a few “medical documents, correspondence related to taxes, and accounting information,” and also information potentially subject to the attorney-client privilege. But this reasoning misses the point.
And again, the magistrate judge granted the search warrant here so the DOJ could search for and obtain documents which, if mishandled, threaten our national security. But sure, let’s allow Trump to halt this entire investigation based on a small number of personal documents that were validly obtained by the DOJ.
Cannon, in her continued fretting over Trump’s reputation, focuses on “wrongful indictment[s],” and reminds us that “as a function of Plaintiff’s former position as President of the United States, the stigma associated with the subject seizure is in a league of its own.”The meat of Trump’s claim, of course, is that he is entitled to a special master to make determinations as to whether the documents the FBI found at Mar-a-Lago are covered by an evidentiary privilege.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Trump-Appointed Judge Cuts Trump a Huge Break“How on Earth could a judge who made it through law school think that Donald Trump can take the property of the government, the federal government, take it home and then have to have a special master decide whether they can investigate him?”
Read more »
Judge Grants Trump Bid for Special Master in Document SearchThe decision authorizes an outside legal expert to review the records taken during the Aug. 8 search and to weed out from the rest of the investigation any that might be protected by claims of attorney-client privilege or executive privilege.
Read more »
Trump Went Judge Shopping and It Paid Off in Mar-a-Lago CaseOn Monday afternoon, Judge Aileen Cannon single-handedly hit the brakes on the most politically sensitive and consequential FBI investigation ever undertaken.
Read more »
These 12 Democrats voted to confirm judge who granted Trump special masterJudge Aileen Cannon's decision has been widely criticized by legal experts who questioned her interpretation of legal precedent.
Read more »
Judge grants Trump special master to review documents seized by FBI during Mar-a-Lago searchA federal judge has granted a request by former President Donald Trump’s legal team to appoint a special master to review documents seized by the FBI during a search of his Florida home last month.
Read more »
Should DOJ Appeal Judge Cannon’s Incredibly Flawed Trump Special Master Ruling?The DOJ may not be able to afford leaving this order’s precedent on the books, given its numerous analytical flaws. But it might be faster to just accept a wrong ruling.
Read more »