If the Adobe-made VoCo, a 'photoshop for audio' was deemed too much of a risk to release, what the heck is OpenAI's Sora?
In 2016, Adobe developed a technology that was best described as “Photoshop for audio.” It would be able to change words in a voiceover simply by typing new words. Sounds scary, right? It was, and Adobe never released it — for good reason.
Called project VoCo, the technology was showcased during Adobe’s “Sneaks” event at its annual MAX conference and immediately turned heads. After MAX, the feedback regarding VoCo was so significant that Adobe felt the need to “It’s a technology with several compelling use cases, making it easy for anybody to edit voiceover for videos or audio podcasts. And, if you have a 20-minute, high-quality sample of somebody speaking, you may even be able to add some new words and phrases in their voice without having to call them back for additional recordings,” Mark Randall wrote, focusing on the positives of the technology. “That saves time and money for busy audio editors producing radio commercials, podcasts, audiobooks, voice-over narration and myriad other applications. But in some cases, it could also make it easier to create a realistic-sounding edit of somebody speaking a sequence of words they never actually said.” Randall would go on to argue that new technology like this, while it might be controversial or scary, has many positive effects, too. While admitting that “unscrupulous people might twist for nefarious purposes,” he goes on to defend developing the technology because of the good it can do. “The tools exist to cut and paste speech syllables into words, and to pitch-shift and blend the speech so it sounds natural,” he argued. “Project VoCo doesn’t change what’s possible, it just makes it easier and more accessible to more people. Like the printing press and photograph before it, that has the potential to democratize audio editing, which in turn challenges our cultural expectations, and sparks conversation about the authenticity of what we hear. That’s a great thing.” While Adobe may have taken this stance initially, VoCo never saw the light of day. Clearly, Adobe realized that the risk of what VoCo could do would outweigh the benefits. Or, perhaps more likely,just couldn’t stomach the idea of attempting to defend the company when the technology was used to put unseemly words into the mouth of a world leader.I vividly remember sitting in the crowd watching the VoCo presentation and thinking, “This cannot be put out there. Any good it could do will be vastly outweighed by the damage it can cause.” I never thought I would be pointing to Adobe as a shining example of ethics and morality, but here we are. Adobe agreed and VoCo never saw the light of day.But the folks at OpenAI don’t seem to be driven by the same morality, or at least aren’t afraid of potential legal repercussions. Maybe it’s because the company thinks it can head off any of these issues through coding, but I find myself wondering what ever happened to ethical software development?— a brand new text-to-video artificial intelligence software — someone at OpenAI didn’t raise their hand with concerns about what ramifications this technology would have. Despite this, the company pushed forward, making the active choice to ignore those concerns.. The capabilities of this software which is just in its infancy are already astounding, yet I can’t help but be filled with a sense of dread and foreboding. If VoCo was deemed too much of a risk, how is Sora not? Just because you can make something doesn’t mean you should.. It was way more advanced than anything we had ever seen before. It was shocking. But now in 2024, AI has seeped into so many parts of daily life and now after more than a year of AI image generators, perhaps people aren’t really realizing what’s happening. We are a frog that doesn’t know it’s being boiled.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
OpenAI's Lobbyists Are Targeting The Pentagon And Other Defense AgenciesI'm an Oakland-based technology reporter and Senior Writer at Forbes. Contact me at semersonforbes.com or securely on Signal at 510-473-8820.
Read more »
OpenAI Co-founder Karpathy Leaves the CompanyKarpathy, one of the co-founders of OpenAI, has announced his departure from the company. He stated that his exit is not a result of any specific event or drama. Karpathy plans to work on personal projects and see what the future holds.
Read more »
OpenAI’s Sora Turns AI Prompts Into Photorealistic VideosOpenAI's entry into generative AI video is an impressive first step.
Read more »
OpenAI’s Video Generator Sora Is Breathtaking, Yet TerrifyingOpenAI released its premier AI text-to-video generator, and the results are as incredible as they are concerning.
Read more »
OpenAI’s Sora Turns Short Text Prompts into Photo-Realistic VideoOpenAI announced Sora, a new text-to-video AI program that can turn short prompts into photo-realistic video.
Read more »
The Best Clips From OpenAI's New Video Generator, So FarThe ChatGPT-maker just unleashed a text-to-video generator called Sora. Take a look at what your future is going to look like.
Read more »