Threatening to withhold welfare payments seems to encourage compliance, a study of the world's largest conditional cash-transfer scheme found
central to welfare systems. In developing countries some “conditional cash-transfer” programmes offer families on low incomes benefits only if the children are sent to school and vaccinated. Payments may be suspended if they do not meet the conditions, but relatively little is known about how recipients respond.
The authors analyse the behaviour of recipients of the world’s largest conditional cash-transfer scheme, Bolsa Família , which covers 14m poor households in Brazil, or roughly a third of the country’s population. Its budget amounts to 30bn reais —0.4% of. In order for a family to receive the benefit, the children must attend school for at least 85% of days in a month. Parents whose children play truant first receive a warning; further absences eventually lead to payments being suspended.
But the ripple effects do not end there. Families punished by having their benefit withdrawn or receiving a warning have an opportunity to punish in turn—at the ballot box. The authors examine the results of mayoral elections in 2008, and find that municipalities with a high share of penalised recipients were less likely to vote for the Workers’ Party , the party that introduced the benefit in 2003 and was leading the federal government at the time.
Under Brazilian electoral law, mayors can be in office for only two terms consecutively. The authors compared the behaviour of mayors with the most to lose—those with an extra term to run, in narrowly contested municipalities—with those who had reached the term limit. First-term mayors were more likely to be lenient.
The authors stress that the effects of Bolsa Família are still very positive overall. But their research shows the importance of taking account of a policy’s knock-on effects when considering its impact. Schemes with sophisticated incentives provoke sophisticated responses."Spilling over"
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Shunned in New York, Brazil leader plans to meet Bush, Cruz in TexasBrazil President Jair Bolsonaro plans to meet with former U.S. President George ...
Read more »
New York City Has a New Way to Teach MathNew York City is pushing a math curriculum for the coming fall that some public school teachers say doesn’t focus enough on teaching the concepts underlying the subject.
Read more »
Tyra Banks On Her New Sports Illustrated Cover: 'This Is A New Me''This is a new me, this is an older me, this is a thicker me, this is a wiser me, this is a thankful me.'
Read more »
U.S. measles outbreak grows with 75 new cases, mostly in New YorkU.S. health authorities recorded 75 new cases of the measles in the latest week,...
Read more »
Tyra Banks Says Her Return To The Sports Illustrated Cover At 45 Sends An Important Message'This is a new me, this is an older me, this is a thicker me, this is a wiser me, this is a thankful me.'
Read more »
Ambitious 'Green New Deal' Will Have Huge Impact On New York City Real EstateThe New York City real estate market is expected to see some big changes as a result of recently-passed legislation designed to push back against climate change, which includes requiring owners of residential and commercial buildings to cut energy usage and carbon emissions or face steep fines.
Read more »
Amazon's new Go store in New York will be its first to accept cashThe newest Amazon Go store will be doing something old: accepting cash.
Read more »
Intel’s new boss wants to teach the chipmaker new tricksIntel dominates the market for chips that power desktop PCs. Its new boss wants to expand its reach
Read more »