Netflix's Missing You: Plot Holes and Confusing Elements Leave Viewers Disappointed

Television News

Netflix's Missing You: Plot Holes and Confusing Elements Leave Viewers Disappointed
MysteryNetflixMissing You
  • 📰 screenrant
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 101 sec. here
  • 8 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 61%
  • Publisher: 94%

Netflix's Missing You, based on Harlan Coben's novel, follows a detective investigating her father's murder when her ex-fiancé reappears. While the show boasts a strong cast and intriguing premise, viewers have criticized it for numerous plot holes and illogical character decisions that detract from the mystery.

The viewers of Netflix ’s Missing You have panned the show because of the numerous plot holes and confusing elements that distract from the story. Based on the 2014 eponymous novel by New York Times best-selling author Harlan Coben , the show follows a police detective named Kat Donovan who reinvestigates her father’s murder once her ex-fiance reappears on a dating app. Based on Missing You ’s excellent cast and interesting premise, viewers engaged with the show expecting a decent mystery story.

Related Missing You's Rotten Tomatoes Score Puts More Pressure On Netflix's Next Harlan Coben Show The current critical results of Missing You on Rotten Tomatoes have put even more pressure on the next Harlan Coben adaptation on Netflix in 2025. At least two victims were from the same area. If more came from Kat’s city, that would offer an even bigger trail. Even if they were from different locations, systems now exist for police in an area to communicate across precincts. It seems outrageous that the police wouldn’t have clocked the pattern sooner.

If Clint had been murdered 11 years before, that would be 2003, and he was with Parker for 14 years, placing the start of their relationship in 1989. This timeframe makes much more sense when looking at the attitudes around LGBTQ+ people than in a modern setting. Unfortunately, despite updating Aqua in a positive way, the writers didn’t bother to update crucial parts of Clint’s story from Harlan Coben’s Missing You novel when putting it onscreen.

4 Nobody Contacted Parker For 11 Years After Clint’s Murder The Timeline In Missing You Seems Implausible Many details in Missing You’s story seem highly unlikely and too coincidental. A prime example of this is the fact that Kat is the first person to search out Parker, Clint’s lover, eleven years after the murder. This isn’t an indictment of Kat’s mother because she had a good reason to ignore her husband’s male lover. She explains that it was easier for her to look the other way.

Moreover, the farmhands are shown disposing of the bodies in an incinerator. Bones don’t fully burn, so the increased attention could have uncovered the human bones or bone fragments of his victims. So, his choice to burn the farm would’ve served as a catalyst for him getting caught. Ultimately, it might not be a plothole, but the decision is, at the very least, confusing and foolish on the part of Titus – a man who is smart enough to cover up his crimes from the start.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

screenrant /  🏆 7. in US

Mystery Netflix Missing You Harlan Coben Plot Holes

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Netflix's Missing You: Key Differences From Harlan Coben's NovelNetflix's Missing You: Key Differences From Harlan Coben's NovelNetflix's adaptation of Harlan Coben's 'Missing You' diverges from the source material in several key ways, including a change of location and alterations to certain characters.
Read more »

Missing in Houston: 37 Years After His Car Was Found, Thurlow Buchanan is Still MissingMissing in Houston: 37 Years After His Car Was Found, Thurlow Buchanan is Still MissingThurlow Buchanan's family has lived with unanswered questions about his disappearance for 37 years, a mystery that began on a November night in 1987. His car was found in Houston, but he was never located.
Read more »

Missing in Houston: 37 Years After His Car Was Found, Thurlow Buchanan is Still MissingMissing in Houston: 37 Years After His Car Was Found, Thurlow Buchanan is Still MissingFor 37 years, Thurlow Buchanan’s family has lived with unanswered questions about his disappearance, a mystery that began on a November night in 1987.
Read more »

Missing in Houston: 37 Years After His Car Was Found, Thurlow Buchanan Is Still MissingMissing in Houston: 37 Years After His Car Was Found, Thurlow Buchanan Is Still MissingFor 37 years, Thurlow Buchanan's family has lived with unanswered questions about his disappearance, a mystery that began on a November night in 1987. Thurlow vanished at 21 years old, leaving behind a family desperate for answers and a trail that led to Houston. His pickup truck was found abandoned near the University of Houston campus, where his girlfriend attended school.
Read more »

Richard Armitage to Star as a Cop in Netflix's 'Missing You'Richard Armitage to Star as a Cop in Netflix's 'Missing You'Richard Armitage takes on his first police role in Netflix's upcoming adaptation of Harlan Coben's 'Missing You'. The actor teases fans about his character, DCI Ellis Stagger, hinting at a major secret and a significant event in the first episode that will impact both Stagger and Kat Donovan, played by Rosalind Eleazar.
Read more »

You're Missing Out On An Overlooked Replacement For Mindhunter That's Already On NetflixYou're Missing Out On An Overlooked Replacement For Mindhunter That's Already On NetflixBrandon is an entertainment writer covering Movies and Television for a variety of digital publications. When he isn&039;t working, Brandon loves reading and watching as many movies as he reasonably can on any given day.
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-08-30 20:04:22