Editorial: Nature is trialling transparent peer review — the early results are encouraging
Credit: Getty
Research papers are the product of lengthy discussions between authors and reviewers — guided by editors. These peer-review conversations can last for months at a time and are essential to progress in research. There is widespread agreement that the robustness and clarity of papers are enhanced in this process.
Peer-review exchanges are mostly kept confidential, meaning that the wider research community and the world have few opportunities to learn what is said in them. Such opacity can fuel perceptions of secrecy in publishing — and leaves reviewers and their key role in science publication underappreciated. It also robs early-career researchers of the opportunity to engage with examples of the inner workings of a process that is key to their career development.
A full year’s data are now in, and the results are encouraging. During 2021, nearly half of authors chose to publish their discussions with reviewers, although there is variation between disciplines . Early data suggest more will do so in 2022. This is a promising trend. And we strongly encourage more researchers to take this opportunity to publish their exchanges.
Publishing peer-review exchanges, in addition, recognizes the effort that goes into the endeavour. Peer review is integral to being a researcher. Making reviewers’ work public illustrates the lengths that researchers will go in the service of scholarship. According to one study, reviewers in total do tens of millions of hours of peer review each year (
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
4 Bay Area counties saw big population declines last yearCalifornia's population dropped for the second year in a row, but there's indication that the rate of decline may be slowing, the state's Department of Finance said Monday.
Read more »
Has an Old Soviet Mystery at Last Been Solved?One February night in 1958, something caused a group of skiers to cut their way out of their tent and flee into a howling blizzard, in 20-below-zero temperatures, in bare feet or socks. What was it?
Read more »
Officials cancel last day of Mississippi Mudbug Festival after deadly shootingOfficials canceled the last day of the three-day Mississippi Mudbug Festival following a shooting Saturday night in which one person was killed and five people were wounded.
Read more »
San Jacinto College offers adult learners chance to finish with ‘Last Step Scholarship’Adult learners who had to put their educational goal on hold because of COVID-19, a family issue, or for other reasons, can now take that last step and complete their certificate or degree with tuition, books and class materials covered at San Jacinto College with the Last Step Scholarship. Thanks to a generous anonymous donor, they can move into a good-paying position and the career of their dreams.
Read more »