Mother Blames Biden‑Era Policy for Son and Daughter‑in‑Law's Death in Oregon Crash

At a House Judiciary Committee hearing, Elizabeth Carter accused a catch‑and‑release policy under President Biden and Secretary Mayorkas of causing her son and daughter‑in‑law's death in a 2025 Oregon highway collision. She alleged irregularities in licensing and federal‑state cooperation over the illegal Indian driver involved. The testimony has raised questions over intergovernmental coordination and road safety.
During a House Judiciary Committee immigration subcommittee hearing, 51‑year‑old Elizabeth Carter offered a heartrending testimony that her 25‑year‑old son, Billy Carter, and his 24‑year‑old wife, Jenny Lynn Lower, would be alive today if the U.S. government had not followed a so‑called catch‑and‑release policy at the southern border.
The mother claimed that an illegal Indian truck driver, Rajinder Kumar, who was released into the United States by former President Joe Biden and former Department of Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, caused a fatal collision on Highway 20 in Oregon on November 24, 2025. The crash occurred just fifteen days after the newlyweds returned from their second wedding reception. Billy and Jenny died instantly when their car jackknifed into Kumar's semi truck.
Also readOregon Coach Dan Lanning Laments Lack of Leadership and Performance After Oklahoma State Defeat
Carter's narrative painted a series of administrative failures. She recalled that Kumar had crossed the U.S.‑Mexico border near Lukeville, Arizona, in November 2022, and was promptly released from custody. According to the mother, the same officials who allowed him entry also granted him a federal work permit and a commercial driver's license from the state of California-a state she described as a "sanctuary state.
" She alleged that no state or federal agency had been allowed to coordinate on whether the driver had a legitimate license, and that Oregon had subsequently declined to cooperate with Immigration and Customs Enforcement when ICE tried to detain him in April 2026. In this context, she argued that the injuries that killed Billy and Jenny could have been avoided had proper legal avenues been followed.
Carter's plea was not purely emotional; she urged lawmakers to investigate the chain of custody and to hold officials accountable for decisions that, she expressed, "left me feeling betrayed by my government.
" She highlighted the broader issue of how the catch‑and‑release policy-intended to expedite the return of migrants-has, in her view, created dangerous conditions on U.S. roads. The mother demanded a fair trial or at least a thorough inquiry into the circumstances surrounding the crash, reasoning that people born in the country deserve better protection.
Her testimony is a stark reminder of how administrative policies can intersect with personal tragedy, and it may influence future legislative debates about immigration enforcement, driver licensing, and intergovernmental cooperation. The hearing also served to spotlight the tension between federal immigration enforcement and state regulatory authority. While the Biden administration and Mayorkas oversaw the initial release of Kumar, state officials in California and Oregon had separate, often contradictory, policies regarding licensing and cooperation with ICE.
This disjointed approach was a point of contention for Carter, who accused the federal‑state divide of undermining public safety. In the wake of her testimony, the House Judiciary Committee is reportedly tasked with reviewing the agency's procedures and the legal permissibility of issuing Commercial Driver's Licenses to individuals with uncertain immigration status.
If successful, the committee could prompt a broader reevaluation of the policy that permitted the driver's presence on the highway, potentially prompting reforms that would both respect federal immigration laws and enhance road safety protocols.
Get an alert when there is news on Politics
Follow Politics











