Among the cases cited by prosecutors is a high-profile animal cruelty prosecution that attracted widespread attention in 2025.
Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman has escalated an extraordinary legal battle with a Superior Court judge his office has accused of repeatedly undermining prosecutors by slashing charges and handing down lighter sentences.has filed motions seeking to disqualify Judge Yvette Verastegui, who serves in the Clara Shortridge Foltz Criminal Justice Center in downtown Los Angeles , from hearing certain criminal matters.
The challenge stems from a series of cases in which prosecutors allege Verastegui reduced charges or imposed sentences far below those sought by the“When a judge goes ahead and either reduces charges or orders a much more lenient sentence that is not based on the facts and the law, we will vigorously oppose that,” Hochman told The Post. Among the cases cited by prosecutors is a high-profile animal cruelty prosecution that attracted widespread attention in 2025.
Joeboury Coleman and Shayla Alcala were charged after videos circulated online allegedly showing a seven-month-old puppy being kicked and thrown down a multi-story stairwell. According to court records, Verastegui accepted open pleas over prosecutors’ objections after the District Attorney’s Office indicated it was prepared to proceed to trial. Joeboury Coleman and Shayla Alcala charged after videos circulated allegedly showing puppy, seven months’ being thrown down a multi-story stairwell.
Alcala had two felony counts reduced to misdemeanors and was sentenced to one year of summary probation, along with counseling and educational programs. , the graffiti-covered downtown Los Angeles skyscrapers that became a national symbol of urban blight after taggers scaled the unfinished high-rises and covered dozens of stories with graffiti. In February 2024, authorities arrested Don Kung, who was accused of rappelling down one of the towers while spray-painting the tag “SAUT” across multiple floors.
According to court records, prosecutors alleged the vandalism caused more than $70,000 in damage and offered a plea deal requiring the defendant to plead guilty to a felony, complete graffiti-removal work and pay restitution before potentially earning a reduction to a misdemeanor. Verastegui later indicated she would reduce the case to misdemeanors and impose probation, community service and restitution over prosecutors’ objections, according to court filings.
A third case involved Giovanni Garcia, who was facing felony charges and had three prior serious felony convictions, commonly known as strikes. Court records show prosecutors argued Garcia’s criminal history warranted a substantially longer prison sentence than the one ultimately contemplated by the court. Verastegui dismissed the prior convictions and effectively resolved the case before it had been assigned to a trial judge, court records show.
“If we give an offer and a defendant doesn’t want to accept the offer, that’s certainly their right,” Hochman said. “But when a judge, without the full review of all the facts and the law, decides a much more lenient sentence or set of charges is appropriate without conducting a full hearing, and as importantly, without hearing from the victims of the crime, then we believe that judge is acting inappropriately.
”“Our goal is to ensure that victims receive the full measure of justice based on the facts and law of every case,” Hochman said. According to Hochman, the department where Verastegui serves has traditionally played a largely administrative role, assigning trial-ready cases to available courtrooms rather than resolving disputed criminal matters.
“We are not going to let her unilaterally come up with resolutions that we believe completely undersell a case and do additional damage to victims. ” Hochman argued that reducing charges in serious criminal cases can undermine deterrence and erode public confidence in the justice system.
“Another important aspect of any prosecution is the message it sends to others thinking of engaging in similar crimes, that they will be held accountable and the consequences will be significant,” he said. “When a judge countermands that message without basing her order on a full grounding of the facts and the law, it does a disservice to the entire criminal justice system.
” The District Attorney’s Office maintains it is not challenging a judge’s authority to disagree with prosecutors after conducting a full review of the facts and legal record. Rather, Hochman argues the department where Verastegui sits was never intended to function as a venue for resolving contested criminal cases before they are assigned to trial courts.
“We’ll respect a judge’s decision when they’ve put in the work and reviewed the record,” Hochman said. “What we’re objecting to is when that process isn’t happening and defendants are receiving substantially reduced outcomes over the objections of prosecutors and victims. ” Judge Verastegui and the Los Angeles Superior Court did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Joeboury Coleman and Shayla Alcala charged after videos circulated allegedly showing puppy, seven months' being thrown down a multi-story stairwell.
Please follow us on Google to support us US News California Los Angeles
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
The Super Mario Galaxy Movie Shoots for the Stars and Lands Among ThemThe Super Mario Galaxy Movie has officially passed the $1 billion milestone worldwide, making it the first billion-dollar movie of 2026. The movie's massive gross has pushed the two-film Illumination franchise to a cumulative worldwide gross of $2.3 billion, allowing it to oust Madagascar as the ninth highest-grossing animated franchise of all time.
Read more »
College Football's No. 4 WR Sparks Fierce Recruiting Battle Among Five Major ProgramsA wide receiver prospect considered one of the best in the country as part of the 2027 college football recruiting class is getting some serious exposure on the
Read more »
Among Us TV Show Takes the Streaming World by Storm on Paramount+The animated series based on the popular video game has quickly become a global hit, topping charts in multiple countries and earning critical acclaim.
Read more »
Paramount's Among Us Series Conquers Initial CritiquesParamount's new series Among Us has taken over the streaming charts with a near-perfect rating of 97% on Rotten Tomatoes. The series is based on the popular video game of the same name and features a cast of well-known actors.
Read more »