Iowa’s Supreme Court kept abortion from effectively being outlawed in the state by not actually reaching a decision in a case. How could that be? Jordan_S_Rubin explains.
. How could that be? That’s because the six justices voting in the appeal deadlocked 3-3 on Friday. So that means the district court’s ruling, which blocked a six-week ban from taking effect, will stand.
In 2019, the district court blocked Iowa’s so-called fetal heartbeat law, which would ban abortions at about six weeks — before many women know they’re pregnant. Of course, that was before the U.S. Supreme Court overruled Roe v. Wade a year ago, throwing abortion rights into chaos nationwide.for states to ban abortion, Iowa’s Republican governor, Kim Reynolds, tried to put the heartbeat law into action.
Procedurally, it’s an unusual situation that failed to produce an actual opinion of the court. Nonetheless, justices wrote opinions explaining themselves — and taking judicial jabs at one another. Summing up the three justices’ opinion who voted against Reynolds, one of those justices wrote that it would be “legislating from the bench to take a statute that was moribund when it was enacted and has been enjoined for four years and then to put it into effect.” An opinion from the other side countered that the Iowa Legislature had already legislated the law in question; there just wasn’t a majority in this case to exercise discretion to act on it.
At any rate, because of this strange stalemate, the law remains blocked and abortion remains legal in Iowa for now — that is, through about 20 weeks.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Six-week abortion ban blocked by Iowa Supreme CourtThe state Supreme Court deadlocked 3-3, meaning the governor's attempt to reinstate a stricter ban failed. Abortion remains legal up to 20 weeks of pregnancy.
Read more »
Iowa Supreme Court prevents 6-week abortion ban from going into effectThe court was split in a 3-3 decision on the case, meaning abortion remains legal in Iowa.
Read more »
In rare 3-3 decision, Iowa Supreme Court declines to reinstate law largely banning abortionAbortion will remain legal in Iowa after the state’s high court declined Friday to reinstate a law that would have largely banned the procedure, rebuffing Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds and, for now, keeping the conservative state from joining others with strict abortion limits.
Read more »
Iowa Supreme Court Deadlocks on Six-Week Abortion BanThe justices were split 3-3 on the decision, upholding a lower court’s 2019 ruling that blocked Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds’ strict “fetal heartbeat” law from taking effect.
Read more »
In rare 3-3 decision, Iowa Supreme Court declines to reinstate law largely banning abortionIowa’s high court refused Friday to unblock a strict ban on most abortions.
Read more »
Bid to ban abortions in Iowa after six weeks blocked by state Supreme CourtAbortion in Iowa will remain legal until 20 weeks of pregnancy after a deadlock on the state’s Supreme Court over whether to grant a request by Gov. Kim Reynolds (R) to reinstate a law that would have banned the procedure in most cases after six weeks.
Read more »