Analysis of the recent ICE immigration enforcement surge in Minnesota, which led to deaths, and its connection to broader challenges to democracy. The article discusses how current immigration policies, enacted through democratic processes, are unjust and can be seen as a form of democratic fascism. It further examines the role of both Democrats and Republicans in shaping these policies, highlighting the tension between majority rule and individual rights.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents escort a detained immigrant into an elevator after he exited an immigration courtroom, Tuesday, June 17, 2025, in New York. ICE has now announced the end to its recent immigration enforcement “surge” in Minnesota, after its tactics resulted in the death of two people.
As ICE tactics continue to undermine due process rights, the New York Timesand kindred others have reflected on the role ICE plays in a broader challenge the Trump administration poses to democracy. Trump’s immigration policies are dramatically unjust. But meaningful reflection on what’s wrong with them means recognizing an uncomfortable fact: they are not “undemocratic” but all too much a product of democracy. It’s an uncomfortable fact that Donald Trump won the 2024 election, not just in the electoral college but by 2 million in the popular vote. And he did it by loudly campaigning for his immigration policy. He promised to carry outRemorseful Trump voters have no excuse for thinking they voted for something else. The signs of Trump’s democratic roots are often hidden behind critics’ evasive relabeling: his “populism.” His immigration policy aims to scandalize a broad class of voting citizens by demonizing the non-citizen minority. “Populism” is just another name for the democracy that certain elites don’t happen to like. They go back to calling it “democracy” when the majority targets the rights of minorities they happen to despise, like businessmen. In its basic, original meaning, “democracy” just means majority rule unconstrained by checks and balances designed to protect individual rights. Remember: the Athenian democracy voted to put Socrates to death. The governments of southern U.S. states — and of the Confederacy — elected politicians and passed popular laws that enslaved millions of African Americans. Even abolition didn’t stop Southern majorities from restricting their rights and tolerating lynch mobs under Jim Crow. Majority rule unconstrained by the rights of individuals is majority tyranny. Many have characterized Trump’s policies and ICE’s tactics as autocratic or even fascistic. They have a point. But democratic fascism is no contradiction. Remember, the Nazi party first rose to power in Germany after being freely elected Trump is not the only one to blame for the rise of fascistic immigration policies. The laws that classify 10 to 15 million people in the U.S. as “illegal” have been on the books for decades. They were passed by duly elected representatives — including the Democrats. It’s these laws that mandate treating immigrants as having no right to travel, work, or live peacefully among us. The current labyrinthine set of foreign worker quotas that dispenses jobs by permission of the government was first adopted in 1952 by a Democratically controlled Congress and finalized in 1965 during the heyday of LBJ’s Great Society. Even when “progressive” Democrats controlled both Congress and the White House in 2009 and 2021, they didn’t prioritize changing the laws. Democrats have evaded their responsibility for these laws by choosing not to enforce them, as in Obama’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. But lax enforcement only played into the hands of “law and order” politicians. When Republicans decided to enforce the laws on the books, of course it required massive fascistic intrusion into and destruction of the lives of immigrants and citizens alike.anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, we should recall that the Founders themselves warned us against unconstrained majority rule . They gave us a system in which our elected officials are constrained by law with checks and balances designed to limit their ability to violate individual rights. This is sometimes what people mean by our “democracy,” but that’s a misnomer. The Founders gave us not a democracy, but a constitutional republic, a system premised on limiting government’s function solely to protecting the individual’s rights. The laws Trump is enforcing are not “undemocratic.” But they do violate constitutional rights. Even non-citizens have a right to liberty. Laws restricting immigrant labor violate the freedom to work and engage in trade. But these are freedoms Democrats long ago sold down the river when they sought ever-increasing regulations on the freedom of businessmen.Opinion: City parking revenue should be used for infrastructureOpinion: My case shows why Black men need to worry about prostate cancer If Trump’s ICE now assaults procedural rights like due process, it’s because he like so many other Presidents have habituated action by executive order. This is enabled by a Congress that has delegated so much power to the executive through laws aimed at achievingpolicy goals that ignore individual rights. Such laws require the oversight of a massive and intrusive administrative state. And the Supreme Court tolerates it all because it is unwilling to apply “strict scrutiny” to any but the most blatantly anti-liberty laws. It recently described the concept of “liberty” as tooWhen a president enforces popular laws passed by Congress, and is unconstrained by a docile Supreme Court — the chaotic, tyrannical presence of ICE thugs on our streets “isVoters made this possible. They need to reflect on the consequences of their past decisions and try to reverse course. Paradoxically, they need to vote for politicians and policies who commit to protect individual rights as sacrosanct — even in the face of what voters demand.Overnight thunderstorms pound San Diego County and more wild weather is on the wayFierce winds cause 222 flight delays at San Diego International AirportIt’s not just Balboa Park. New parking meters across San Diego face a fierce backlash.After second trial, jury convicts San Diego County deputy who seriously injured restrained inmate
ICE Immigration Democracy Trump Constitutional Rights
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Walz and Frey should say ‘thank you’ for Minnesota ICE operation: HomanHoman previously announced the Department of Homeland Security would soon be ending its immigration enforcement operation in Minnesota.
Read more »
Homan tells Minnesota leaders to say 'thank you' instead of demanding reimbursement as ICE operation endsFox News Channel offers its audiences in-depth news reporting, along with opinion and analysis encompassing the principles of free people, free markets and diversity of thought, as an alternative to the left-of-center offerings of the news marketplace.
Read more »
ICE to Reduce Enforcement Surge in Minnesota, Says White House Border CzarTom Homan, White House border czar, announced a significant drawdown of immigration enforcement in Minnesota's Twin Cities area, with over 1,000 agents already departed and hundreds more scheduled to leave. A small security force will remain to protect remaining agents. Enforcement will continue nationwide.
Read more »
Immigration Agents Begin Leaving Minnesota's Twin Cities Amidst Drawdown of Enforcement SurgeThe Trump administration is scaling back its immigration enforcement surge in Minnesota's Twin Cities area, with over 1,000 agents already withdrawn and hundreds more set to depart. This decision follows criticism of the operation, including the shooting deaths of two U.S. citizens. A small security force will remain to protect agents, and investigations into fraud and protests will continue.
Read more »
Small ‘security force’ to stay in Minnesota despite ICE surge ending: HomanThe development comes after Homan said President Donald Trump authorized a full end to 'Operation Metro Surge' in Minnesota.
Read more »
Minnesota Republicans defend their focus on fraud despite the ICE surge that followedMinnesota Republicans say they were right to invite social media influencers into the state to highlight social service fraud, though Democrats blame Republicans for paving the way for the ICE surge.
Read more »