Cosmologists are facing a puzzle: observations of the early universe suggest a lower expansion rate (Hubble constant) than those from the late universe. A new study proposes that the Hubble constant could be evolving over time, potentially resolving this tension. This finding could indicate new physics or simply a misinterpretation of the data.
Image of the large-scale structure of the Universe, showing filaments and voids within the cosmic structure. Who knows how many other civilizations might be out there? Credit: Millennium Simulation Project Cosmologists have been struggling to understand an apparent tension in their measurements of the present-day expansion rate of the universe, known as the Hubble constant.
Observations of the early cosmos – mostly the cosmic microwave background – point to a significantly lower Hubble constant than the value obtained through observations of the late universe, primarily from supernovae. A team of astronomers have dug into the data to find that one possible way to relieve this tension is to allow for the Hubble constant to paradoxically evolve with time. This result could point to either new physics…or just a misunderstanding of the data. “The point is that there seems to be a tension between the larger values for late universe observations and lower values for early universe observation,” said Enrico Rinaldi, a research fellow in the University of Michigan Department of Physics and coauthor on the study. “The question we asked in this paper is: What if the Hubble constant is not constant? What if it actually changes?”Cosmologists employ a variety of probes and observations to determine the fundamental properties of our universe. They try to measure its age, its contents, its expansion rate, and more. After almost a century of intense scrutiny, those cosmologists have developed a coherent, consistent model of the universe. In short, our cosmos is about 13.77 billion years old, is constantly expanding, and is made of mostly dark energy and– with normal matter like stars and planets and clouds of gas making up a brightly-lit minority of the ingredients of the universe. Leaving aside the gigantic mysteries of the true nature of dark energy and dark matter, in recent years cosmologists have run into another frustrating puzzle: different probes Measurements taken of the young universe, like the cosmic microwave background , tell us that the Hubble constant is somewhere around 68 km/s/Mpc . But more local, late-universe measurements, like observations of supernovae, lean towards a different answer: a Hubble constant of more like 74 km/s/Mpc.A team of astronomers led by Maria Dainotti, an assistant professor at the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan and the Graduate University for Advanced Studies, SOKENDAI in Japan and an affiliated scientist at the U.S. Space Science Institute, which are a particular kind of explosion that happens when white dwarf stars accumulate too much mass from a companion star, which triggers a runaway nuclear fusion event. This fusion event has roughly the same brightness every time it happens, so astronomers can use these supernovae as “standard candles” – since they know how bright the supernovae should be, they can compare that to how bright they appear to be and calculate a distance. By combining many such measurements over a wide range of distances, astronomers can calculate the expansion history of the universe. The team used a catalog of over 1,000 supernovae observations and separated them into different bins of distance ranges, with each bin representing the same number of supernovae. They then used each bin to measure the Hubble constant. In the standard cosmological picture, the expansion rate of the universe is constantly changing as the cosmos evolves, but the Hubble constant is a fixed number – it’s the expansion rate of the universe right now. Each bin of supernovae should yield the same Hubble constant, but in their analysis the researchers allowed the Hubble constant to not be so constant – they allowed for the possibility that it could change with time. By using different bins, they could test to see if the Hubble constant stayed fixed across the different bins, or if it did indeed vary. “If it’s a constant, then it should not be different when we extract it from bins of different distances. But our main result is that it actually changes with distance,” Rinaldi said. “The tension of the Hubble constant can be explained by some intrinsic dependence of this constant on the distance of the objects that you use.”Ultimately, the astronomers found in the study that by adding a little bit of flexibility to the standard cosmological models – by allowing the Hubble constant to change with time – they could relieve almost all of the tension between the supernovae and cosmic microwave background measurements. The researchers were able to extrapolate their evolving Hubble constant back to the time of the cosmic microwave background and match it up with those results. “The extracted parameters are still compatible with the standard cosmological understanding that we have,” he said. “But this time they just shift a little bit as we change the distance, and this small shift is enough to explain why we have this tension.” The new results are not altogether surprising. It’s always possible to make differing observations agree by adding more complexity to models. In this case, the researchers added a new variable – how quickly the Hubble constant changes with time – and they were able to find a way to connect the early- and late-time measurements of the Hubble constant. Also, the work did not find a statistically significant measurement of this varying Hubble constant. Although they were able to relieve the tension in cosmological observations, they were not able to conclusively say that the Hubble constant is changing with time. These results, if they hold up, could give theorists a pathway to introducing new physics into the universe to explain the Hubble constant tension. Or it might also mean that supernovae aren’t as “standard” as we think they are, and that perhaps some bias is creeping into the observations to spoil those measurements of the Hubble constant.
Cosmology Hubble Constant Universe Expansion New Physics Data Analysis
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Webb and Hubble snap the same object for two views of one galaxyTwo different space telescopes have looked at the same galaxy, so you can see the difference in how they observe the universe.
Read more »
'Baywatch' star Nicole Eggert breaks down in tears over 'cancer tattoos': 'A constant reminder'“Every step of this process is never gonna let you forget it, there’s just always going to be a constant reminder.” — Nicole Eggert.
Read more »
Constant Financial Worry May Signal Money DysmorphiaA financial therapist explains that money dysmorphia, a distorted perception of your financial reality, can disrupt your daily life and lead to isolation, even if your bank account tells a different story.
Read more »
Inside the Hubble Space Telescope's 23-year-long look at a beautiful blue galaxyLarissa G. Capella is a Brazilian science writer based in the U.S. with a broad passion for the sciences, including physics, astronomy, geoscience, neuroscience, and more. She earned both a B.S. in Physics and a B.A. in English from Western Washington University in 2024.
Read more »
Pop Star Addresses Body Shaming and Constant Online CriticismPop star Ariana Grande has spoken about the pressures of maintaining a perfect image and the constant online discourse about her weight. In an interview with French social media star Sally, Grande expressed discomfort with the scrutiny she has faced since she was 16 and critiqued the public's tendency to share opinions on her appearance, emphasizing the importance of a strong support system.
Read more »
Philadelphia Business Owner Lives in Constant Fear as Armed Robber Search ContinuesPhiladelphia police seek a suspect tied to three armed robberies at local stores on October 7, 8, and 9. The robber appears to be shopping before pulling out a weapon and demanding money. The third incident involved a BB gun.
Read more »