Leonardo Garcia Venegas, a 26-year-old construction worker, says ICE agents detained him three times despite his proof of citizenship.
agents three times in less than a year, despite showing proof of citizenship and presenting identification, according to court filings. and Customs and Border Protection, two key arms within DHS, are facing a flurry of backlash after cases emerged that thea 26-year-old construction worker alleges in a federal class-action lawsuit that immigration officers unlawfully stopped, detained, and arrested him in Baldwin County on multiple occasions, ignoring his government-issued REAL ID, according to court documents reviewed byThe documents, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Alabama, challenge what it describes as three Department of Homeland Security enforcement policies.
This includes anpolicy allowing officers to enter private construction sites without a warrant, another permitting detention without individualized suspicion, and a policy allowing continued detention after presentation of evidence of lawful status.operate under increased pressure amid President Donald Trump’s push to carry out what he has called the largest mass deportation effort in U.S. history, aimed at removing millions of migrants without legal status from the country. Garcia Venegas was first detained on May 21, 2025, when immigration officers entered a private construction site in Baldwin County where he and other workers were building homes, according to court filings.
The site was fenced and marked with No Trespassing signs, but officers allegedly ran onto the property without a warrant and targeted Latino workers while leaving others alone. Court documents say Garcia Venegas identified himself as a U.S. citizen and offered to show documentation, but officers tackled him, handcuffed him, and held him for more than an hour.
He repeatedly told officers he was a citizen and provided an Alabama STAR ID, a form of REAL ID issued to citizens and lawful residents, but was kept in restraints until his status was later confirmed, according to the filing. Footage shows an immigration officer telling Garcia Venegas,"You’re making this more complicated than you want to," before moving toward him.
The video then shows the officer grabbing him as Garcia Venegas responds,"Don’t touch me," and says he can provide his identification. Officers then force him to the ground, where he repeatedly states that he is a U.S. citizen.
Garcia Venegas said in court filings that officers dismissed his identification as fake and held him for more than an hour.that"there was no mistake" during the encounter, adding that Venegas"attempted to obstruct and prevent the lawful arrest of an illegal alien," which led to his arrest.
"Leo had to take nearly two weeks off from work to recover emotionally after his first arrest, at a significant financial cost. Leo felt dreadful after his arrest—not only because it happened once but because he knew it could happen again," a court filing reads. Garcia Venegas was detained again on June 12, 2025, while working alone inside a partially constructed home at a residential development in Baldwin County, according to court documents.
An immigration officer entered the home without a warrant after spotting him through a window and directed him to leave the property, despite Garcia Venegas sayingper the filings. Court documents allege the officer spoke to him in Spanish and ordered him to step outside, where another agent had positioned himself nearby.
The filings say Garcia Venegas was surrounded and escorted off the site, with officers walking in front of and behind him as they led him to an unmarked vehicle more than a dozen lots away. According to the complaint, he again presented his REAL ID and said that he was a U.S. citizen, but officers told him the identification could be fake and transported him for further checks.
The filing states that agents detained him while they verified his status and also held other workers from the same development, including individuals with lawful status. Garcia Venegas was held for approximately 20 to 30 minutes before being released after authorities confirmed he was a citizen, according to a court document.
In a filing submitted May 4, 2026, Garcia Venegas said he was detained a third time on May 2, 2026, during an encounter outside his home, according to court documents. The motion and accompanying declaration state that federal immigration officers approached him and physically restrained him without first asking any questions. He told officers he was a U.S. citizen and presented his REAL ID, but the filing alleges they continued to detain him despite that.
According to the declaration, he was placed in handcuffs and leg restraints and put into the back of an enforcement vehicle, where officers then began questioning him about his place of birth. He told them he was born in Florida and offered to retrieve his U.S. passport from inside his home, but the officers declined to review it, the filing states.
The document says officers searched his wallet and used a handheld device to scan his driver’s license while he remained restrained in the vehicle. He was released only after agents verified his lawful status, according to the declaration. The filing also states officers required a K‑9 drug search of the vehicle he had been driving before removing his restraints, prolonging the encounter even after his identity had been confirmed.
Attorneys for Garcia Venegas argue the incident mirrors his prior detentions, writing that officers again held him"well after" he presented evidence of his citizenship and that the repeated encounters demonstrate a continuing pattern. Garcia Venegas argues in court filings that the alleged policies violate the Fourth Amendment, which protects against unreasonable searches and seizures, as well as federal regulations governing immigration enforcement.
Attorneys said the third detention shows an ongoing risk that he could be stopped again during routine activities, including driving or going to work. The motion argues that the repeated incidents strengthen his request for a preliminary injunction, which would limit further enforcement actions against him while the case proceeds.
Windham said:"Twice last year, masked federal agents raided his private construction sites without a warrant, detained him without any reason to suspect a crime, and refused to credit his REAL ID as proof of citizenship. And just last weekend, federal agents followed him home and, without a warrant, dragged him from his truck while he was holding his REAL ID and threw him in leg shackles.
Each time, the agents released Leo well after they should have realized he's an innocent American citizen.
"This can't go on. While Leo's lawsuit brings several different claims, the thrust is simple: The federal government has no right to raid private worksites without a warrant. The federal government has no right to stop, tackle, or shackle hardworking American citizens based on nothing more than the job they hold and the way they look. That's unconstitutional, it's un-American, and we will not rest until it ends.
" The lawsuit seeks to block further enforcement actions and to recover damages for the alleged unlawful arrests and detentions.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Kacey Musgraves Teams With Mariachi Brothers Detained by ICE for Powerful Rendition of ‘Tú, Sólo Tú’Kacey Musgraves sang 'Tu, Solo Tu' with the Mariachi Brothers detained by ICE during one of her shows.
Read more »
Defendant testifies he panicked when ICE agents swarmed his carThursday may end up being the final day of the trial for Robyn Argote-Brooks, the man who rammed into multiple ICE agents vehicles.
Read more »
Polish mother Beata Siemionkowicz detained by ICE in Kentucky since last August, despite Green CardTwo suburban women are facing Mother's Day without their mom, a Polish immigrant who has been in ICE custody since last August even though she has a valid visa and permanent resident card.
Read more »
▶ Man claims he was wrongfully detained by ICE agents after bloody takedown in BronxAn ICE takedown caught on camera in the Bronx left a 19-year-old bleeding and requiring stitches to his head. It wasn't until later that agents found out they…
Read more »