Big fund companies have mixed records voting on shareholder proposals. One idea would require mutual funds to make proxy votes front and center.
The era of low-cost index funds from asset management giants such as Vanguard Group and BlackRock has simplified the fund-buying process — and that has been a good thing — but there is more work to be done.
Investors can choose funds designed as environmental, social and governance investments. But the vast majority of investors are still in funds designed to buy stocks first and deal with the social repercussions after as they cast votes at annual meetings — the most votes of any public company shareholders.
"The N-PX are not well-structured disclosures," said Jackie Cook, founder of FundVotes, which was acquired last year by Morningstar as the investment research platform pushes further into the area of ESG investing data."Votes need to be disclosed at the individual fund level, ballot by ballot, and proxy by proxy."
The late Vanguard Group founder Jack Bogle said in one of his last warnings in late 2018 that among the biggest issues the index fund giants would face in the future is their oligopoly status and societal influence. He was specifically referring to the fact that the dominant index funds vote corporate proxies on behalf of so many individual Americans, and on complex issues such as climate change.
"I'm not criticizing her [Hester Peirce] for having her view, but she has spoken her mind, just like Rob Jackson," Smith added."These dynamics within the SEC will affect whether such an idea would get air time and be considered a priority, but you have to put these things forward to get public debate."Niels Holch, a mutual fund lawyer and head of the Coalition of Mutual Fund Investors in Washington, D.C., said he has found Jackson to be thoughtful and not partisan.
Cook said Morningstar won't initially include proxy voting records as part of its influential overall fund ratings. It already offers separate sustainability ratings on funds. But its plan is to enable investors to compare asset managers against each other, as well as at the level of their individual funds.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
SEC steps on Tesla 'reasonable' to prevent problems: commissionerThe U.S. securities watchdog's request that a federal judge hold Tesla Inc ...
Read more »
Former SEC lawyer sounds alarm on ‘the greatest retirement crisis’ in history“Pension detective” Ted Siedle, a former SEC lawyer who now runs Benchmark Financial Services, was awarded a record $78 million for blowing the whistle on...
Read more »
Uber files with SEC to go public in the year’s most anticipated tech IPOThe ride-hailing company said it has 3.9 million drivers and operates in more than 700 cities.
Read more »
Treasury sec takes fight over Trump's tax returns to a new levelThe law says the administration must honor Richard Neal's demand for the president's tax returns. Team Trump isn't overly concerned with what the law says.
Read more »
Exclusive: Blocking Trump tax return release puts Treasury Sec. in legal jeopardyIn a new Daily Beast article, tax expert David Cay Johnston reveals that if the treasury secretary and IRS commissioner do not comply with the request to release Trump's tax returns, they will be violating a law punishable by up to five years in prison. Lawrence O’Donnell discusses with David Cay Johnston in an exclusive interview.
Read more »
Italian economy minister expects growth to pick up in H2: TV interviewEconomy Minister Giovanni Tria expects Italy's growth to pick up in the sec...
Read more »
NBC News on Twitter“PeteWilliamsNBC Grady's departure may be necessary to avoid any legal challenges to McAleenan’s installation as acting DHS secretary, according to the officials, due to Grady's current place in the statutory order of succession.”
Read more »
Treasury Secretary Mnuchin says U.S. and China have agreed on the trade deal enforcement mechanismThe treasury secretary said that, if completed, the agreement would be the most significant change to U.S.-China economic relations in 40 years.
Read more »
Perspectives: These firms have an outsize influence on Corporate America. The SEC needs to regulate themThese firms have an outsize influence on Corporate America. The SEC needs to regulate them | By Radhakrishnan Gopalan, Todd Gormley and Todd Milbourn for CNNBusiness Perspectives
Read more »