Both Republicans and Democrats have said STAAR sets students up for failure, raising questions about basing a state takeover on the test’s results.
Read full article: Military veterans, active-duty members receive free admission to San Antonio Zoo throughout November FILE - The Ford logo is seen above the entrance to the Ford Motor Company Kentucky Truck Plant, Wednesday, April 30, 2025, in Louisville, Ky.
KSAT 12 may be unavailable on YouTube TV starting Oct. 31Recommended Videos The state takeover of the Fort Worth Independent School District is largely based on student performance on the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness — a testing system that came under scrutiny this year and led state lawmakers to replace it over concerns that it set students up for failure. The widespread criticism of STAAR has prompted questions about the fairness of the takeover, including whether the state should replace an elected school board and a superintendent if the test driving the decision does not adequately capture student learning. Texas’ accountability system assigns school districts a letter grade each year for how well they teach children, close academic achievement gaps and prepare students for life after high school graduation. If a campus receives five consecutive failing grades, state law requires the education commissioner to either order the closure of the school or replace the district’s board with a new group of leaders.last week to replace the North Texas school district’s board and name a state-appointed superintendent, saying the district’s current leaders had “failed the students of Fort Worth ISD.”, Morath pointed to data showing that only 34% of Fort Worth students are currently performing at grade level and that 20 campuses have produced “academically unacceptable” results for multiple years in a row. But that rationale has not convinced public education advocates and Fort Worth parents like Zach Leonard, who say Morath’s reliance on STAAR test results to justify his decision “is problematic.” “We’re using a deeply flawed system to determine who’s going to get their district taken over,” Leonard said. “Until we solve the root cause, which, A, is funding and, B, is fixing the deeply flawed system in Texas — the A-F ratings and STAAR testing — we’re going to continue having this cycle of public school districts being taken over.” Over the course of this year, both Republican and Democratic legislators blasted the test for how poorly they said it assessed the academic performance of Texas’ 5.5 million public school students.by calling on lawmakers during two overtime lawmaking sessions to “replace it with effective tools to assess student progress and ensure school district accountability.” Rep., one of the Republicans who co-authored the state law eliminating STAAR, criticized the test for what he described as a high-stakes, one-size-fits-all design. Standing in the Texas House chamber, the public education committee chair said the test creates anxiety for students and teachers and that it produces “absolutely no information that a parent can understand.”, another Republican who played a significant role in crafting the legislation to eliminate the test, if he agreed that STAAR “is not really a measure of a child’s improvement.” Bettencourt responded, “Absolutely.”by the 2027-28 academic year and replace it with three shorter exams. The governor’s office in a statement did not address the critiques of the test or the fairness of the accountability system. Andrew Mahaleris, a spokesperson, instead reiterated that Abbott “supports appointing a board of managers for Fort Worth ISD to ensure students receive a top-quality education.” He highlighted that the Houston school district takeover has resulted in improved test results.versions of the test mostly aligned with Texas’ content and learning standards. The reports concluded that students were mostly capable of understanding what they were reading on the exam. Texas rolled out a. It not only determines how the state holds schools accountable for subpar academic performance, but the test also decides whether students can graduate high school and whether teachers in certain districts receive Educators say that many districts have focused heavily on “teaching to the test” because of STAAR’s high-stakes nature. In the eyes of Janet Harrison, an instructor of more than two decades who was recently hired to teach literacy in the Fort Worth district, Texas children have missed out on critical learning opportunities because of their schools’ hyperfocus on STAAR. “You’re not preparing your students to read, write, and think, and do math,” Harrison said. “Basically, you’re teaching them how to take one particular kind of test, and statewide … yes, we are absolutely setting our students up for failure.” Fort Worth ISD Superintendent Karen Molinar told the Tribune that she recognizes that the question of whether the takeover is fair does not change what’s written in the law, which grants the education agency the authority to take action if a campus does not meet Texas’ academic standards. She expressed disappointment in her district for not doing more to lift students up to grade level across all subjects. Molinar also noted that if the district is doing what’s best for students, it won’t need to depend on “trying to crack the code” of an assessment. The Fort Worth district for years had struggled to educate its students, especially the children living in predominantly Black and Hispanic neighborhoods. Many educators, families and officials in and around Fort Worth have agreed that Texas should have a mechanism to hold school districts accountable when they do not meet the needs of students.in areas where districts say they need it most highlight a broader issue: The state is endeavoring to hold schools accountable while sharing some of the blame for their shortcomings. Hundreds of districts are operating at a budget deficit after going six years without comprehensive school funding legislation, meaning they are increasing class sizes, cutting instructional staff, and shutting down schools and programs that contribute to positive student achievement. The Fort Worth district approved a“So to identify a school district and say there are several issues in this domain, that speaks to our state,” Clark said. “So as a state, what are we doing differently to prepare our students for success? Has TEA come up with a strategic, true intervention for our state as a whole, or are they targeting certain school districts?” Clark also highlighted the progress the Fort Worth district has made over the last two years, notably reducing the number of F-rated schools from 31 to 11., a Republican State Board of Education member who also represents North Texas, said he is “not a fan of STAAR.” Having one test at the end of the year places too much pressure on students and teachers, Hall said, which is why he supports phasing out the test and relying on three shorter tests that allow schools to track progress throughout the year., or MAP, that also show Fort Worth students struggling in critical areas. That’s a major reason why he supports the takeover. “This is a check and a balance at the state level that was necessary,” Hall said. “This is the state taking accountability and saying, ‘Things are not going well. Student outcomes are too low. We’re going to step in, and you turn this around.’ And so I think that’s accountability taking place right there.”, who a decade ago introduced the part of the state law that can trigger a takeover if a district endures five consecutive years of failing grades, said he stands by the approach. During his time as chair of the House Public Education Committee, Dutton noticed that any time he asked school leaders about the demographic group that struggled the most academically, they would consistently point to Black boys. The Houston Democrat said he wondered why districts could make it work “on the other side of town” where white children made up the majority, but not in communities with mostly kids of color. He said the current law helps ensure the state can hold districts accountable for not serving the children who need the most support. However, Dutton disagrees with how Texas’ unpopular standardized exam has become such a major component of the public education system. “I’m not married to the STAAR test,” Dutton said. “But I do think we ought to have something that indicates whether our children are achieving. Whether that’s the STAAR test or another kind of test, we ought to make sure that happens.”Federal, local law enforcement teams crack down on credit card skimmers in San AntonioManu Ginobili, Fabricio Oberto, family and friends attend world premiere of Tim Duncan documentarySan Antonio woman shares videos from Jamaica during Hurricane Melissa1 dead, 3 detained after Northwest Side motel shooting, SAPD saysKendall County residents recover from EF-1 tornadoHalloween season: How your brain turns fear into funJames Talarico shares his favorite things about TexasTCEQ approves wastewater facility permit over Helotes Creek watershed
Public Education Fort Worth School Accountability STAAR Test Well A Homepage Texas Legislature
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Fort Worth ISD Parents Fear the Same Chaos that State Takeover Has Brought to Houston ISDTEA intervention into locally controlled school districts has become increasingly common—despite mixed results.
Read more »
Fort Worth ISD board meets for first time after state takeover announcementFort Worth ISD parents slammed the board for school closures and leadership issues as the Texas Education Agency moves to remove all trustees.
Read more »
Board meets with TEA officials for the 1st time as state takes over Fort Worth ISDThe Texas Education Agency is taking over Fort Worth ISD after the district failed to meet state accountability standards, prompting the school board to prepare for its first meeting with state officials this week before being replaced by a state-appointed board of managers.
Read more »
How a single Fort Worth ISD campus prompted a state takeoverThe district has struggled to bring students’ grades up, especially at campuses in low-income neighborhoods with large Black and brown populations.
Read more »
Texas Education Agency Takes Over Fort Worth ISD Due to Persistent Academic StrugglesThe Texas Education Agency is intervening in the Fort Worth Independent School District after a campus's repeated failure to meet state academic standards, leading to the removal of elected school board members and the appointment of a new board of managers. This decision follows a history of academic challenges within the district, particularly in low-income neighborhoods, and aims to improve educational outcomes for students.
Read more »
Fort Worth ISD takeover was largely based on STAAR, despite plans to replace itBoth Republicans and Democrats have said STAAR sets students up for failure, raising questions about basing a state takeover on the test’s results.
Read more »