Two new studies reveal the impact of financial incentives on surgical practices. A change in Medicare billing for hernia repair led to a significant increase in the reported size of hernias, suggesting surgeons may be overestimating size for greater reimbursement. A second study exploring incentives for active surveillance in low-risk prostate cancer found no significant change in adoption rates, highlighting the influence of financial rewards for surgical procedures.
,” Cyndi Lauper famously sang about love to a pulsating rock ‘n’ roll beat. So, too, when it comes to financial incentives for surgeons, two new studies suggest, although “How much money?” and “What do I have to do?” are the keys to unlocking monetary motivation.
research letter, examined the impact of a new Medicare billing code for abdominal hernia repair that paid surgeons more if the hernia measured at least 3 centimeters in size. Previously, “size was not linked to hernia reimbursement,” noted University of Michigan researchers. Surprise! The percentage of patients said to have smaller, lower-payment hernias dropped from 60% to 49% in just one year. Were “small hernia” patients being denied care? Nope. Were surgeons perhaps more precise in measuring hernia size? Maybe. Or possibly, wrote the researchers in careful academic language, “the coding change may have induced surgeons to overestimate hernia size.” Ambiguous tasks, they added, “can be conducive to perceptive bias and potentially even dishonest behavior, perhaps more so with financial incentives at play.” This being an academic publication, two footnotes informed us that dangling money in front of our eyes can cause people to “see what you want to see” and come up with an “elastic justification” for truth. If a simple coding change can apparently boost the number of large-hernia patients by 18% in just one year, what about a payment incentive meant to induce more urologists to follow the medical evidence on low-risk prostate cancer and adopt “active surveillance” , rather putting patients through a painful and expensive regimen of biopsies and surgery? A second study, also in Michigan, involved commercial and Medicare-age members of the state’s Blue Cross and Blue Shield plan. However, after three years and more than 15,000 patients, “the payment incentive was not associated with increased surveillance use among patients with low-risk disease,”active surveillance for low-risk prostate cancer patients among Michigan urology groups – a rate adjusted for the patient’s clinical condition – ranged from 30% to 73%. In one urology practice, the rate among individual clinicians –Yet even in those physician groups with the lowest rate of active surveillance use and the highest proportion of patients from Blue Cross – the groups expected to be most “sensitive” to a financial incentive – there was no statistically significant change. Why? Once again, the researchers carefully noted that surgical treatment decisions “may be partly driven by nonclinical factors, including financial incentives.” For instance, “physicians may make thousands of dollars more in the first year through primary treatment as opposed to active surveillance.” Moreover, for any individual surgeon to actually receive the health plan’s financial incentive, the entire urology group had to meet a target requiring almost three-quarters of men eligible for active surveillance to either be offered it as an option or accept it. For all the loud proclamations by payers, providers and policymakers that the U.S. healthcare care system is well on its way to “value-based payment,” the pronouncements about an emphasis on patient preferences and the “cost-quality equation” remain just that empty words when compared to the concrete value signified by an immediate paycheck boost. When a new billing code pays more to individual surgeons, significant change swiftly follows, even if only in documentation. Roll out a convoluted payment scheme that requires an entire surgical group to alter its doctors actually practice, however, and very little happens. The “effective” way “to align prostate cancer care quality with payment,” the researchers concluded, may require “reimbursement parity between management strategies.” In other words, if you want financial incentives for surgeons to really work, it pays to remember a declaration a Tom Cruise film made famous: “
FINANCIAL INCENTIVES SURGICAL PRACTICES HERMIA REPAIRS PROSTATE CANCER ACTIVE SURVEILLANCE
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
NFL Players With Financial Incentives in Final Weeks of SeasonSome NFL players stand to earn significant bonuses in the final weeks of the regular season based on their performance. The article highlights players like Smith and Mayfield whose incentives could reach millions of dollars.
Read more »
Is Intuitive Surgical Stock a Trump 2.0 Play?The article explores the potential for Intuitive Surgical (ISRG) stock to benefit from a potential Trump presidency in 2025. It highlights the company's strong performance and the growing trend towards robotic surgery, arguing that ISRG could be a good investment even amidst uncertainty surrounding healthcare policies.
Read more »
Intuitive Surgical (ISRG) May Rally Towards $580Intuitive Surgical (ISRG) has been trending higher since April and is currently forming another potential bullish pattern. If this pattern completes, ISRG could rally to $580 from its current price. The stock is closely watching its 50-day moving average, which it has been flirting with recently. A dip under this average could trigger a breakout in the bullish pattern.
Read more »
Can Financial Incentives Boost Active Surveillance Rates for Low-Risk Prostate Cancer?A cohort study analyzed data from 15,273 men with prostate cancer to determine active surveillance rates at difference points in time.
Read more »
Check Your Health- Advances in Hernia Surgical CareHernias are a common medical problem. In the United States more than 1.6 million hernia surgeries are performed each year. A hernia is a weakness in the abdomin
Read more »
Financial Incentives Help Smokers Quit for LongerNew research reveals that offering financial rewards, such as cash, vouchers, or returned deposits, can significantly increase the success rate of smoking cessation, even after the incentives are discontinued.
Read more »