Former USC women's volleyball coach Mick Haley's age discrimination complaint against Donna Heinel could potentially be subject to discovery-phase parameters.
On Monday, the arbitrator ruled against Heinel and in favor of Haley on both requests, according to an email reviewed by the Los Angeles Times. Because of the delay in discovery related to Heinel’s indictment, the arbitrator ordered to continue the hearing from August 2019 to March 2020, a decision that served as a blemish on Haley’s victory and a desired result for USC.
The most important development, though, is that Heinel will now be deposed regardless of the status of her criminal case. “Mr. Haley objects to allowing Dr. Heinel to use a parallel criminal proceeding to bring this civil matter to a halt as well as using the indictment as a shield indefinitely to frustrate the course of discovery to her sole advantage,” the arbitrator wrote. “I am not persuaded at this juncture that Dr. Heinel cannot participate fully in this arbitration with regard to facts which do not implicate her criminal case.” According to the email, Heinel asserted that “the stay and protective orders were necessary because she is in an untenable position of choosing to defend herself in this arbitration thereby harming her criminal case or invoking her Fifth Amendment rights and not being able to defend herself against Claimant’s allegations.” Heinel’s attorney, Nina Marino of Kaplan Marino in Beverly Hills, responded in a statement to The Times.“Civil matters are commonly stayed pending the resolution of criminal matters in order to protect the integrity of the legal proceedings,” Marino said. “Our client has a right to fair process in both the criminal and civil arenas. We are of course disappointed the stay was not granted, but the arbitrator’s decision to continue the civil hearing at least protects our client’s right to defend herself — for now.” Attorneys from each side will now be tasked with establishing parameters aimed at allowing Heinel, who was fired by USC on the day of her arrest, to participate in discovery without implicating her criminal case. Most of Haley’s case against Heinel and USC is not expected to overlap the criminal allegations. But there will be some overlap, particularly involving Haley’s allegation that Heinel limited him in the composition of his roster. The 200-page federal complaint details, through court-approved wiretaps of government witness Rick Singer, the myriad ways in which Heinel allegedly pushed fake athletes through USC’s athletic admissions subcommittee in return for payments from the prospective students’ parents totaling more than $1.3 million. The affidavit alleges that two Bay Area parents, Todd and Diane Blake of Ross, Calif., bribed Heinel to get their daughter admitted into USC as a purported women’s volleyball recruit in the fall of 2017, which ended up being Haley’s last season as the Trojans’ coach. The parents allegedly provided Heinel a falsified resume that included their daughter receiving a number of honors and playing on a club team that qualified for junior nationals three years in a row. The Blakes allegedly wrote a check to “USC Women’s Athletics” in care of Heinel for $50,000 and later sent $200,000 to Singer’s made-up charity. The Blakes’ daughter enrolled at USC but was not listed on the women’s volleyball roster in the fall of 2018. Ludmer, Haley’s San Diego-based attorney, told the Times that Haley did not know about the Blakes’ daughter’s admission and had never seen their names until they appeared in the federal indictment.Interviews by The Times with former USC athletic department staff members in March revealed that Heinel had the power to prioritize one athlete over another in her dealings with the subcommittee. Coaches could ask Heinel for help getting a preferred walk-on into the school, but, ultimately it was up to her. The allegations against Heinel contained in the affidavit could bolster Haley’s claim that Heinel negatively affected his roster and, therefore, his team’s competitiveness. The Trojans won the 2002 and 2003 national championship under Haley. During his last season in 2017, USC went 25-10, finished second in the Pac-12 and advanced to an NCAA regional final. In December of 2017, USC athletic director Lynn Swann announced Haley would not return for another season. Swann replaced Haley with Brent Crouch, 43, a month later. In his first college head coaching job, Crouch went 55-66 in four seasons at the University of Portland, which had gone 0-27 the year before he took over. In Crouch’s first season at USC, the Trojans went 22-11 and lost to San Diego in the second round of the NCAA tournament. USC women's volleyball coach Mick Haley shouts instructions during a playoff match in December 2011. One of the allegations Haley made against USC in the complaint is negligent hiring, supervision and retention. Ludmer is expected to highlight that USC hired an athletic director in Swann with no prior experience running a large athletic department. Ludmer will also try to establish that Swann gave Heinel minimal oversight, an assertion that has been buttressed by the allegations in the criminal case and Swann’s response to it. Swann told The Times in March that he was “blindsided” by the news of Heinel’s alleged involvement in the scheme. “The reason why no one would know that this was happening is because we had one person in charge of submitting the academic records to our admissions department,” Swann said of Heinel. “And that one person was in charge of getting that information back and distributing it to the coaches and letting other people know.”The Sports Report NewsletterThe best, most interesting and strangest stories of the day from the L.A. sports scene and beyond.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
David Sills, who committed to USC at 13, signs with Bills as an undrafted free agentDavid Sills didn’t quite take the path to the NFL he might have expected when he committed to USC as a 13-year-old quarterback in 2010. Now a receiver, he signed with the Buffalo Bills as an undrafted free agent.
Read more »
New Tent Facility Set to House Migrants Amid Surge of FamiliesFederal authorities have erected a huge white tent in the desert on the outskirts of the small border town of Donna, Texas, to cope with a surge of migrant families that is overwhelming existing resources.
Read more »
USC announces five-year deal with 790 AM to broadcast football and basketball gamesThe school announced Wednesday that it has signed a five-year agreement with 790 AM.
Read more »
Growing 2020 Democratic field triggers a mad dash for donors -- and complaints from campaignsThe growing 2020 Democratic field triggers a mad dash for donors -- and complaints from campaigns
Read more »
Prosecutors urge judge to reject Roger Stone’s challenges to indictment, Mueller probeThe Justice Department opposes the novel claim by Stone that Congress funded ‘independent counsels’ not ‘special counsels.’
Read more »
Two new tent cities along U.S.-Mexico border operating as a 'band-aid' for surge of immigrantsThe two camps, located in El Paso and Donna, Texas, were opened on Thursday and can each hold up to 500 people. A temporary solution for an area of the border that sees between 1,200 and 1,500 people a day.
Read more »
UCLA sweeps USC to win NCAA women’s beach volleyball titleThe UCLA women’s beach volleyball team won the school’s 117th NCAA championship on Sunday in Alabama, beating rival USC in the final.
Read more »
Riot Games workers walk out to protest forced arbitrationThe company behind “League of Legends” is trying to force sexual harassment lawsuits into arbitration. But the company's workers are pushing back.
Read more »
Riot Games workers walk out to protest forced arbitration of sex discrimination suitsMonday's action, the first of its kind in the video game industry, comes amid a surge in tech worker activism and a growing interest in unionization among game developers.
Read more »
Apple To Face EU Competition Probe Following Spotify ComplaintThe EU plans to launch a formal probe into Apple's App Store after Spotify accused the Californian tech giant of 'tilting the playing field to disadvantage competitors'
Read more »
The U.S. and China: It’s complicatedOn today’s Post Reports: damianpaletta on Trump’s latest tariff threats to China, griffwitte on an apprenticeship program in Germany helping refugees. Plus, PostKranish on America’s first black sports hero.
Read more »