GE2019: Does Labour need a new direction after Corbyn?
Iain Watson's view from a wind-chilled knoll in Middlesbrough was not promising Labour's lost its fourth general election in a row. And it will soon have a new leader. But will this be enough to get it back into government?I perched on a grassy knoll on the outskirts of Middlesbrough on the eve of poll.
It was the perfect vantage point for surveying the turnout at one of Jeremy Corbyn's last campaign rallies, in an adjoining open-air car park. This was a far cry from the mass rallies I had seen in the 2017 campaign - but, to be fair, it was a week day and it was freezing. But it wasn't the enthusiasm of the hardy activists that was in question, but the loyalty of Labour voters who had voted to leave the EU. I was hearing they were also about to leave behind their traditional party loyalties, despite party chairman Ian Lavery declaring at the rally:"This election has nothing to do with Brexit." I was told that seats which had been Labour since their creation - such as Blyth Valley - could fall. Local and regional activists, however, were hoping the North East of England would be unduly disastrous for the party and that other areas would fare better. But I was also being told of problems in the West and East Midlands and, 24 hours later, the dire predictions proved accurate.Image caption Jeremy Corbyn's election result brought back memories of Michael Foot in 1983, rather than Tony Blair in 1997, 2001 and 2005 Well placed sources thought Labour would suffer a net loss of seats but wouldn't fall below 230. The more pessimistic confided a figure of 220. In the end, with 203 seats, it was a worse parliamentary haul than Michael Foot's post-war low in 1983.He or she who controls the past controls the future. So that's why shadow chancellor John McDonnell was quick out of the traps to blame the defeat on Brexit.The grassroots movement he formed with Jon Lansman - Momentum - declared it would"keep Labour socialist".Image copyrightIf this narrative wins, it would help clear the ground for another leader from Mr Corbyn's wing of the party. Some close to Mr Corbyn hoped that would be shadow minister Laura Pidcock, but the public begged to differ and ejected her from her Durham seat. So the current favourite on the Left is shadow business secretary Rebecca Long-Bailey. When Mr McDonnell says the next leader should be a woman, he is almost certainly thinking of her.Defeated parliamentary candidates, such as Phil Wilson in Sedgefield, Tony Blair's old seat, and Ruth Smeeth, in Stoke, have pointed out that Mr Corbyn's leadership came up on the doorstep more than Brexit. The party's former general secretary, Lord McNicol, has said the problem isn't so much Corbyn as what he called"Corbynism" - the move of the party to the left, with a narrower group of less experienced MPs in frontbench positions, and an offer of change that may have seemed too radical for some former supporters.If a wider review of the party is on the agenda - a change of direction, not just a change of leader - this could help hopefuls such as Sir Keir Starmer and Emily Thornberry. Sir Keir was never quite trusted by the leadership but the pro-Remain membership has been impressed with him as shadow Brexit secretary. A quick contest would suit him, but Mr Corbyn seems in no rush to go. Some MPs are muttering that they may even mount a challenge - which needs a fifth of the parliamentary party - if his"period of reflection" begins to stretch in to a lengthy meditation.Jess Phillips is touted by many as a possible replacement for Jeremy Corbyn Another potential candidate who would move the party away from the Corbyn era is Jess Phillips. Many of the membership may believe she'd try to move the party to the centre, though in the Blair years she would have been regarded as"soft left". But her supporters hope, in a contest, she would encourage non-members to sign up as"registered supporters" and re-shape the party as a more social democratic entity, but led by someone who doesn't look or sound like a conventional politician and who may be a match for that other big personality, Boris Johnson.I have had activists and insiders complain about the organisation as much as the politics. One source said:"We need to look at why we were sending hundreds of people to Boris Johnson and IDS's seats, which we couldn't win, when canvassing sessions elsewhere were being cancelled for a lack of volunteers." While Momentum tried to divert resources to certain seats, critics say the party itself lacked coherence Some unions are irritated that they never got a list of target seats or advice on where best to send their members.Overall, critics complained of a lack of coherence.Individually, some are, by any measure, popular - just as the current leadership claim. But taken together, one now former MP told me:"It was like the Generation Game conveyor belt. One of the few things we didn't offer voters was a cuddly toy, or if we did, I missed it. "But all the other items - broadband, pensions, free buses - came so thick and fast no-one could remember them. Not a single voter mentioned a single retail offer on the doorstep."So the big question facing the main, but diminished, party of opposition is this: Does it simply want a new leader, or does it really need a new direction?
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Who will be next Labour leader after Jeremy Corbyn?John McDonnell, Emily Thornberry, Keir Starmer, Angela Rayner and Sadiq Khan are among some of the favourites.
Read more »
Former Labour MP slams Jeremy Corbyn saying party is 'racist and nasty'Ruth Smeeth said ‘Jeremy Corbyn’s actions on anti-semitism have made us the nasty party. We are the racist party.'
Read more »
Election 2019 results live: Boris wins by LANDSLIDE – Corbyn quits as Labour COLLAPSEBORIS JOHNSON has officially won the 2019 general election as Labour's 'red wall' has officially fallen with swathes of voters crossing the rubicon to ensure Brexit is carried out.
Read more »
Devoid of agility, charisma and credibility, Corbyn has led Labour into the abyss | Polly ToynbeeThe Labour leader has allowed his party to be riven by sectarianism, antisemitism and Brexit, says Guardian columnist Polly Toynbee
Read more »
Ex-Labour home secretary calls Momentum a 'cult' and attacks Jeremy CorbynIt’s been a rough election for rival parties as Boris Johnson’s Conservatives won a landslide GE19
Read more »
Jeremy Corbyn unrepentant following Labour Party's historic election defeatJeremy Corbyn has refused to apologise to Labour MPs despite leading the party to one of its worst ever election results, insisting he did “everything I could”.
Read more »