The Dallas City Council is facing criticism for its chaotic handling of the city manager search and its failure to conduct performance reviews for key appointees. This dysfunction highlights a lack of clear goals and accountability within the council, raising concerns about the city's leadership.
The Dallas city manager search has played out in the chaotic fashion we've come to expect from this City Council. There was the lackluster recruitment brochure draft and the trickle of information about candidates. And nothing screams 'we've got our act together' like eleventh-hour candidate interviews the day before Christmas Eve.
We wish the next city manager the best of luck because no amount of talent and hard work can overcome a fundamental flaw of this search, and that is the lack of formal, measurable goals by the City Council. Our city is about to hire its CEO, but its board of directors has no metrics to set expectations or hold that person accountable for the most important job in Dallas. If you want to understand how dysfunctional the situation is, start with the fact that the council's appointees — the city manager, city attorney, city secretary and city auditor — haven't had a performance review in more than two years. Our last city manager, T.C. Broadnax, had his last evaluation in August 2022. He left in May 2024. Interim City Manager Kimberly Bizor Tolbert, the front-runner for the job, hasn't had an evaluation since her appointment last spring. The council has hired a consultant over the years to help conduct the evaluations of its appointees. But no consultant can fix this council's main problem, and that is its inability to come together to develop a consensus around four or five priorities and the metrics to measure progress in those areas. Even when performance reviews for council appointees were happening, the process was broken. The council's consultant called council members individually to solicit feedback, with the consultant identifying “themes” shared verbally with the council, and with no particular comments attributed to specific people, according to a 2022 memorandum from Management Partners, the firm hired to do the work. The city manager and other appointees were “invited” to prepare a report on their accomplishments and goals for next year, with the potential for “refinements” based on council input. There was no written report from the performance evaluation, other than any goals reports produced by the appointees. And don't expect even a veneer of transparency for taxpayers. Last year, we requested Broadnax’s goal reports and were told by the city that there were no responsive records, only to hear a council member remind her colleagues last week that Broadnax produced a memo with his goals after his last performance review in 2022. City staff failed to release this memo in response to our request. Such a document should be public under the Texas Public Information Act. Now, on the brink of hiring its next city manager, the council is panicking about the fact that it hasn't evaluated its council appointees in a long time and that it has no measurable goals for any of them. The council committee whose job it is to codify the annual review process can't seem to agree on how to move forward. Mayor Pro Tem Tennell Atkins chairs the committee. In a December meeting, he led a discussion on next steps to resume performance reviews of council appointees. Council members learned that their previous consulting firm, Management Partners, had been acquired by Baker Tilly, the company that is leading the messy city manager search. But the woman who had worked closely with the council on previous performance reviews was no longer associated with either company. The committee gave city staff mixed signals on how to proceed. Some council members said they wanted to continue working with the previous consultant. Others asked to hear from Baker Tilly. Some said they were dissatisfied with the previous consultant or concerned about Baker Tilly and wanted to hear from other vendors. Council members said to move quickly. By the time the council committee picked the conversation back up this month, confusion reigned. Baker Tilly prepared a presentation that described a performance review process very similar to what the council had with its previous partner. Atkins indicated that the council was moving forward with Baker Tilly using an existing contract, and other committee members pushed back. Meanwhile, an assistant city manager and an assistant human resources director couldn’t answer a council member’s simple question about when the council appointees were last evaluated.“Yes, we are overdue for these reviews, but I think that they should be pursued seriously with the appropriate time periods involved,” said council member Paul Ridley
Dallas City Council City Manager Search Performance Reviews Accountability Transparency Local Government
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Dallas City Council divided over search for new city managerThe ad-hoc committee removed one of the four previously named semi-finalists, and two new finalists have been added. However, those names haven’t been made public yet.
Read more »
Dallas City Council meltdown over city manager search an embarrassmentDallas City Council, it’s the holidays. Please take a breath of fresh pine air and work out this search in a new spirit of cooperation before nobody ends up...
Read more »
Dallas City Council to Interview Candidates for Permanent City ManagerThe Dallas City Council is narrowing down the search for a permanent city manager, with three finalists set to be interviewed in January. Community meetings will precede the interviews, giving residents a chance to weigh in on the candidates.
Read more »
Dallas City Council Narrowing Search for New City ManagerThe Dallas City Council has moved quickly to advance three candidates to the finalist stage in the search for a new city manager. After a series of interviews and debates, the council will now allow the community to weigh in before making a final decision. The new city manager will face significant challenges, including hiring a police chief and addressing budgetary concerns.
Read more »
Dallas City Council Announces Semifinalists in Search for New City ManagerThe Dallas City Council has narrowed down the search for a new city manager to three semifinalists: interim city manager Kimberly Bizor Tolbert, Fort Worth assistant city manager William Johnson, and Sacramento assistant city manager Mario Lara. The candidates will meet with community members in Dallas the second weekend of January and participate in interviews with the city council. A final decision is expected by January 15th.
Read more »
Dallas City Council Member Seeks Regulation of Over-the-Top Holiday LightsAfter a dazzling holiday light display in Preston Hollow drew large crowds and diverted city resources, Dallas City Council member Gay Donnell Willis is calling for policy review to balance public safety with holiday cheer.
Read more »