The Batsa challenge – unlike the one mounted by Fita which the high court dismissed – challenges the constitutionality of the ban. But a finding today that the ban was rational effectively dooms any argument of unconstitutionality.
Cape Town – The government has taken British American Tobacco South Africa to task for accusing it of being responsible for the lengthy delay in the hearing of its "urgent" challenge to the ban on the sales of tobacco products during level 3.
Batsa described the decision, which followed presentations by the State to Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe, as troubling. It dismissed the main contention by the tobacco association that she had acted irrationally in prohibiting the sale of cigarettes in regulations governing the state of disaster declared in response to the Covid-19 health crisis, terming the ban properly considered.
"The requirement of rationality is thus not a particularly stringent test and should also not be conflated with the requirement of reasonableness, even in those cases in which a law or the exercise of a public power infringes a fundamental right." In disagreement, the court found though a survey relied upon by the ministry indicated that the vast majority of smokers had still obtained cigarettes despite the three-month-old ban, it suggested that some had given up.
It also rejected the argument that the ban was cruel towards smokers, and said the fact that tobacco was addictive did not render it an essential good.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Bad news for smokers: High court says cigarette ban was rationalBad news for smokers as high court dismisses Fita cigarette ban case Fita
Read more »
'Cigarettes are not essential': Court orders tobacco ban to stay in placeJUST IN | 'Cigarettes are not essential': Court orders tobacco ban to stay in place
Read more »
Bad news for smokers as high court dismisses Fita cigarette ban caseBad news for smokers as high court dismisses Fita cigarette ban case Fita
Read more »
BAT’s challenge to tobacco ban to be heard only in AugustJudge President John Hlophe says the ban on cigarette sales should be heard by a full bench of the Western Cape high court, with BAT calling the delay ‘inexplicable’
Read more »
BATSA challenge to tobacco sales ban to be heard on June 30South Africa's biggest cigarette manufacturer said it reached an agreement with the state attorney that the matter was urgent and would be heard on Tuesday, a week later than initially scheduled.
Read more »
High Court throws out Fita’s tobacco ban caseThe court found the minister made her cigarette ban decision objectively, after considering all the relevant medical literature
Read more »