San Antonio's Ethics Review Board on Wednesday reprimanded Councilman Marc Whyte, saying he violated the city’s ethics code by urging law enforcement officials to dispatch additional personnel to investigate a potential child-abuse case.
As a result of details revealed during the hearing, a prominent local attorney suggested he may pursue an ethics complaint against Councilman Manny Pelaez . District 10 Councilman Marc Whyte speaks to reporters following Wednesday's Ethics Review Board hearing.
San Antonio's Ethics Review Board on Wednesday reprimanded Councilman Marc Whyte, saying he violated the city’s ethics code by urging law enforcement officials to dispatch additional personnel to investigate a potential child-abuse case. After deliberating for an hour in executive session, the board found that Whyte's actions violated three sections of the code. The board voted 6-1 to reprimand the District 10 councilman and require him to undergo ethics training. Wednesday's three-hour hearing stemmed from an April 26 incident during which Whyte, a first-term councilman representing District 10, and District 8 Councilman Manny Pelaez — a current mayoral candidate — allegedly asked the Bexar County Sheriff's office to intervene in a family matter at the home of high-profile attorney Martin Phipps. The Whyte and Pelaez made the request after Whyte's wife conveyed concerns that Phipps was physically abusing his child during a court-ordered visit, according to testimony from the meeting. The board determined that White used his council position to unfairly advance private interests, wielded the prestige of his city position to advance private interests and attempted to use city resources for purposes unavailable to members of the public. However, the board unanimously agreed that Whyte hadn't taken official action likely to affect his wife's economic interests. "I don't know that the code was truly analyzed and that the words were looked at," Whyte told reporters after the hearing."If you go and look at the code, what it says is I can't do something that's not lawfully available to another member of the City of San Antonio. Nothing we did that night a member of the city couldn't have done."Details about the potential extent of Pelaez's involvement in the April 26 incident weren't revealed to the public or media until Wednesday's official meeting.According to an official timeline presented at the hearing by an outside attorney the city retained as an independent investigator, Phipp's ex-wife, Jessica Joyner, called 911 at 8:19 p.m. and told San Antonio Police that her children were in danger at her ex-husband's King William home.SAPD arrived at Phipps' house at 8:30 p.m., while Lorien's request for Whyte to get involved occurred 20 minutes later, according to details presented in the timeline. "You have to impart on how serious this is," Lorien wrote in a text message shared during the hearing."Martin has a serious drug problem and mental health issues. These kids have not seen him in 18 months due to his behavior. This was a trial run visitation." During the time of the alleged incident, Whyte and Pelaez were attending a private Fiesta event at Hotel King William, less than a half mile from Phipps' home, according to details discussed at Wednesday's meeting. At the hearing, Whyte and Pelaez both testified that they flagged down an off-duty Bexar County deputy doing security at the party to make the deputy aware of the investigation at Phipps' home. The issue at hand, Ethics Review Board member Jude Valdez said was that the BSCO deputy informed both Whyte and Pelaez that police were already on the scene due to Joyner's 911 call. "Knowing that the police were already on their way and already there, why did you feel it necessary to engage all the individuals that you engaged in the conversation about getting someone else, getting the police or the sheriff or someone else out there as well?" Valdez asked White during the hearing. In the end, the majority of the board agreed that Whyte had used his position and influence to send additional law enforcement to Phipps' residence. "I am telling you, as God as my witness, that if it wasn't for SAPD and their professionalism and the principles that they followed — those sheriff's deputies were over there to get my children, to get the results that they wanted, and it wasn't there for them," Phipps testified, stopping at one point to stifle tears. Whyte worked at Phipps' law firm before becoming a councilman, and Phipps served as Whyte's mock trial coach when he was a St. Mary's Law School student, according to the councilman's Wednesday testimony. What's more, Whyte's wife, who's also an attorney, represented Phipps' ex-wife in a technical appellate point in her custody battle with Phipps last year. Whyte's wife is no longer involved in that case, however.Wednesday's hearing also shed light on what may have been a larger involvement by Pelaez in the Phipps matter. Pelaez texted San Antonio Police Chief William McManus about the investigation at Phipps' house on the night of April 26 and also looped in employees in the City Manager's Office, according to the timeline presented Wednesday. At around 9:30 p.m. — an hour after SAPD arrived at Phipps' home and some time after Pelaez and Whyte were informed that authorities were on the scene — Pelaez texted McManus and Deputy City Manager Maria Villagomez that he and Whyte"have a problem." "Please call Whyte. URGET ," Pelaez wrote. "Family violence case happening now in King Williams . Mom of victim called us. Mom's name is Jessica Joyner. I'm told assalailant is Martin Phipps!""I'm told officers on the scene said that he was conducting 'reasonable disciple' on the minor," Pelaez said in one of the messages."Minor claims he was hurting ." During the hearing, several board members expressed concern that Pelaez looped in both McManus and, more specifically, the City Manager's Office in the matter of a private citizen — and for an incident in which the councilman wasn't directly involved. Even so, Pelaez played down those concerns, telling the board he always involves the City Manager's Office when he thinks something is important. "Something that I do whenever I have contact with law enforcement or something significant happens that I know may come to the attention of the city manager, the city attorney or the chief, is I always — as just a matter of practice — text them so that they can hear from me," Pelaez said. The revelation that Pelaez may have reached out to McManus and top city officials about the Phipps case comes roughly a week after Pelaez raised eyebrows by"We get to park wherever the hell we want," Pelaez said during that discussion."All of us get invited to every Spurs game and all the high-ticket concerts. And by the way, those of us up here who talk about regular-ass people and regular folks and being poverty pimps and all that stuff, you'll see them all in the luxury suites and at luxury events and galas, right?""There is no victory. So, I'm gonna go home with my children," he said."It's a good day, but … I'll send you a copy of what's being filed next." Since 1986, the SA Current has served as the free, independent voice of San Antonio, and we want to keep it that way. Becoming an SA Current Supporter for as little as $5 a month allows us to continue offering readers access to our coverage of local news, food, nightlife, events, and culture with no paywalls.Michael Karlis is a Staff Writer at the San Antonio Current. He is a graduate of American University in Washington, D.C., whose work has been featured in Salon, Alternet, Creative Loafing Tampa Bay, Orlando Weekly, NewsBreak, 420 Magazine and Mexico Travel Today. He reports primarily on breaking news, politics...By Emily Foxhall, Alejandra Martinez and Yuriko Schumacher, The Texas Tribune, and Dylan Baddour and Martha Pskowski, Inside Climate News
Please follow us on Google to support us Councilman Manny Pelaez Ethics Review Board Martin Phipps San Antonio City Council San Antonio Politics
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Lawyer Martin Phipps alleges San Antonio councilman deleted message at heart of ethics caseThe public pissing match between District 10 Councilman Marc Whyte and a former colleague turned adversary — controversial San Antonio attorney Martin Phipps — took another odd turn on Tuesday.
Read more »
San Antonio’s ethics board orders hearing into attorney Phipps’ complaint against Councilman WhyteFiled by attorney Martin Phipps, the complaint alleges Whyte abused his office by asking SAPD and BCSO to send officers to Phipps' home.
Read more »
Internal disharmony hits San Antonio Philharmonic board as anticipated season awaitsA dispute among board members of the San Antonio Philharmonic is casting a cloud over the orchestra’s triumphally announced third season.
Read more »
Documentary featuring San Antonio band Pariah to debut this week at San Antonio Film FestivalSan Antonio metal band Pariah will feature heavily in a new documentary about infamous Austin rock venue The Back Room, which will make its debut this weekend at the San Antonio Film Festival. Bloody & Bruised: The Untold Story of the Back Room, directed by J. Budro Partida, will screen this Saturday at 7 p.m. at the Radius Center.
Read more »
San Antonio Board of Realtors implementing newly mandated real estate guidelines next weekOn Wednesday, August 14th, the San Antonio Board of Realtors is implementing new, nationally mandated, rules for real estate listings.
Read more »
Ethics board finds San Antonio councilman abused his powerIn a rare hearing Wednesday night, the City of San Antonio’s Ethics Review Board ruled that Councilman Marc Whyte (D10) abused his position when he tried to get local law enforcement to respond to a local attorney’s home this spring.
Read more »