A fight brewing at the state Capitol pits powerful industries, politicians and regulators against each other, and it will have an impact on energy bills, electric grid reliability and the environment.
It’s been almost two years since the big blackout of 2021, and most people agree the Texas power gridNow, a fight is brewing at the state Capitol over that very issue. It pits powerful industries, politicians and regulators against each other, and it will have an impact on energy bills, grid reliability and the environment.
After the last big blackout, state lawmakers passed Senate Bill 3, telling the commission to improve grid reliability. So, commissioners have been working on changing the state’s electricity market. They want to reform how energy is bought and sold on the power grid to create a market that makes sure power is there when people need it. To do that, the commission hired a consulting firm that came up with a plan called a Performance Credit Mechanism, PCM for short. Basically, this plan would create reliability credits that electricity providers have to buy from power generators . The credits represent a commitment from those power generators to deliver electricity when the grid is most stressed. “I believe that PCM is the right solution because it's a comprehensive solution that sets a clear reliability standard as required by [Senate Bill] 3,” Peter Lake, chair of the Public Utility Commission, said earlier this month. The consulting firm that came up with the plan says it will cost $5.7 billion more a year. Supporters say power generators will use that money to invest in new power plants and to keep the energy supply humming in extreme weather. They also argue that not all that extra money will be shouldered by consumers. But, in Texas, consumers typically end up eating extra costs.The plan is supported by power plant owners, who stand to earn money from the credits. The Electric Reliability Council of Texas, the state’s grid operator, is in favor of it.The list of opponents appears to be significantly longer. The independent market monitor, a position that serves kind of as a third-party auditor for the Texas grid, does not think it is a good plan. Consumer and environmental groups oppose it or are skeptical. The Texas Association of Manufacturers, a group that represents big industrial energy users in the state, is against it. The oil and gas lobby is not convinced it will work, and many state politicians also oppose it.Environmentalists point out that the plan is designed to bringOthers, who want more natural gas plants built, argue that the PCM may not accomplish that goal. Some would preferof new plants instead of the addition of a new layer of rules into the already complex Texas energy market. And others say a big overhaul of the energy market is not even necessary, and that the grid can be improved without investing billions in building more power plants. “I think we have an operational flexibility problem,” Carrie Bivens, the PUC's independent market monitor,. “I do not believe we have [an energy] capacity problem.” One thing all opponents agree on is that the plan is untested. It will cost billions, but there’s no real-world example to show it will work.Despite those concerns, the Public Utility Commission approved the PCM plan last week, setting up a showdown at the Texas Legislature. In a vote Thursday, the commission adopted an outline of the plan, but said it would delay implementing it “until such time as the 88th Legislature has had an opportunity to render judgment on the merits of the PCM and/or establish an alternate solution.” That could mean lawmakers are invited to weigh in with new legislation. But if they don’t, state regulators will take that inaction as a green light to move ahead with the plan. KUT emailed the Public Utility Commission for clarity on how it expects the legislature to weigh in, but has not yet heard back. Either way, state lawmakers have already started reacting. State Sen. Charles Schwertner, who authored last session’s big grid overhaul bill, called the Public Utility Commission's approval of the PCM “unacceptable” hours after the vote. "Today, the [Public Utility Commission] chose to ignore the clear direction of the [Legislature]” by approving the PCM, Schwertner . “In the weeks ahead, the Texas Senate will hold hearings and consider whatever legislation is necessary to correct this error and fulfill our obligation to the people of Texas."to support it. Your gift pays for everything you find on KUT.org. Thanks for donating today.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
New York leading the way in attempting to bar Capitol insurrectionists from holding public office | amNewYorkDemocratic lawmakers in a handful of states are trying to send a message two years after the violent attack on the U.S. Capitol: Those who engage in an attempted overthrow of the government shouldn't be allowed to run it.
Read more »
'A violation of our rights': Protestors march at Capitol against anti-drag performance billsProtestors flocked to the Phoenix Capitol Sunday to fight back against proposed anti-drag legislation heading into this legislative session.
Read more »
The first statue removed from the Capitol: George Washington in a togaSome statues depicting enslavers are being removed from the Capitol. But the first one ever evicted was a half-naked depiction of George Washington in a toga.
Read more »
Protest held at Arizona capitol over newly introduced 'anti-LGBTQ' billsProtestors took to the Arizona capitol this weekend arguing against what many are calling anti-LGBTQ bills that were just proposed in the state legislature.
Read more »
Film tragedy sparks bill for firearm safety on Texas film and TV setsRep. Sheryl Cole has filed House Bill 1471, which would require any film or television project that accepts state incentive funds to require anyone handing a gun to complete the state’s Hunter Education course.
Read more »
CEO Marina Gonzales brings voices of Hispanic businesses to Texas Capitol - Dallas Business JournalSan Antonio Hispanic Chamber of Commerce Marina Gonzales talks about the newly formed Texas Hispanic Chamber of Commerce Coalition and its goals for the latest session of the Texas Legislature on the Texas Business Minds podcast.
Read more »