Some of the nation's most powerful conservative judges took collective aim Wednesday at the idea that homeless people with nowhere else to go have a right to sleep in public.
reiterated a separate 2018 decision
On Wednesday, the 9th Circuit issued an order denying the city’s request, indicating a majority of its 29 active judges had voted against rehearing the case. O’Scannlain wrote that the September decision was an “inventive, judge-made novelty.” He said it is “telling” that the 9th Circuit is the only circuit “bold enough” to embrace such a doctrine, which he said “effectively requires local communities to surrender their sidewalks and other public places to homeless encampments.”“One need only walk through our neighborhoods — through the Tenderloin or Skid Row — to know that our communities are fast coming undone,” he wrote.
“Homelessness, drug addiction, barely concealed narcotics dealing, severe mental health impairment, the post-COVID hollowing out of our business districts.”Such problems defy easy solutions, Bress wrote, but will be made even worse by the majority’s decision in the Grants Pass case, in which he said the court had “injected itself into the mix” by imposing “sharp limits” on local government responses.
Silver and Gould wrote that both Smith’s dissent and O’Scannlain’s statement “significantly exaggerate” their September holding — which related specifically to homeless people sleeping outside in Grants Pass, a city that lacked sufficient shelter beds to house them. Silver and Gould wrote that, contrary to suggestions by Smith, the homelessness problem in the American West and across the U.S. predates both the 2018 and September decisions by the 9th Circuit that upheld a right of homeless people to sleep outside with bedding when they have nowhere else to go.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
9th Circuit conservatives blast homelessness ruling, say issue is 'paralyzing' U.S. WestSome of the most powerful conservative judges in the U.S. took aim at the idea that homeless people with nowhere else to go have a right to sleep in public.
Read more »
9th annual Careathon presented by Duval Asphalt is FridaySince 2015, more than $1.7 million has been raised through Careathon.
Read more »
9th Circuit Court declines to rehear ruling that upheld homeless right to sleep outside when no shelter space availableA federal appeals court Wednesday refused to rehear a three-judge panel’s ruling that prohibited the city of Grants Pass, Oregon, from criminally punishing homeless people who sleep in public places when they have nowhere else to go.
Read more »
Rodriguez delivers in 4-run 9th against All-Star closer Doval as Mariners beat Giants 6-5The right-hander had never allowed more than three earned runs in a game and had given up a total of eight in 38 prior appearances this season. He also had gone 58 straight games without permitting more than one run.
Read more »
Veterans will be connected to these key resources at Santa Clara Co.'s first 'Stand Down' eventOn July 8th and 9th, more than 50 providers will offer free food, haircuts, mental services, legal services, and more to veterans at the Santa Clara County Fairgrounds. Here's what to know.
Read more »
Federal judge restricts Biden officials from contact with social media firmsThe injunction came in response to a Republican lawsuit alleging U.S. agencies went too far in encouraging social media companies to address posts related to vaccines and elections.
Read more »